Mounting fracking foes have oil industry concerned

Grass-roots opposition is seen as threat to booming shale business

Share with others:

Print Email Read Later

HOUSTON — A fight over frack­ing is loom­ing in Texas. Another stand-off is shap­ing up in Col­o­rado. Yet drill­ers’ re­ac­tions couldn’t be more dif­fer­ent.

In Texas, drill­ers are do­ing their noisy, in-your-face frack­ing as usual. On a small farm about an hour from the Col­o­rado Rocky Moun­tains, the oil in­dus­try is giv­ing frack­ing a make­over, cut­ting back on rum­bling trucks and tamp­ing down on pol­lu­tion.

Oil com­pa­nies in Col­o­rado are re­spond­ing to a ris­ing tide of re­sent­ment, as lo­cal com­mu­ni­ties and en­vi­ron­men­tal ac­tiv­ists vie to im­pose mea­sures to ban frack­ing or re­strict drill­ing.

A se­ries of bal­lot ini­tia­tives and other grass-roots op­po­si­tion around the coun­try is seen as threat­en­ing the boom­ing shale in­dus­try, even in oil-friendly Texas, where the U.S. en­ergy re­nais­sance be­gan. If those ini­tia­tives “con­tinue to pro­lif­er­ate, then com­pa­nies lose ac­cess to those re­sources,” said David Spence, pro­fes­sor of law, pol­i­tics and reg­u­la­tion at the Univer­sity of Texas School of Law, who re­searches frack­ing and drill­ing rules.

Ci­ties and coun­ties na­tion­wide have so far passed 430 mea­sures to con­trol or ban frack­ing, the con­tro­ver­sial tech­nique of crack­ing sub­ter­ra­nean rocks to re­lease oil and nat­u­ral gas, ac­cord­ing to a run­ning list kept by Food & Water Watch, a Wash­ing­ton-based en­vi­ron­men­tal ad­vo­cacy group.

The in­dus­try’s new­found con­cern and sen­si­tiv­ity in some states rep­resents a shift in tac­tics, as com­pa­nies seek to avoid tak­ing the is­sue to the vot­ing booth, where suc­cess for ac­tiv­ists holds the po­ten­tial of slow­ing the U.S. drill­ing bo­nanza.

At an Anadarko Pe­tro­leum drill­ing site near Dacono, Colo., swarms of trucks and flood lights are hid­den be­hind a wall of hay bales, which soften the roar of die­sel en­gines. Giant pits of murky waste­wa­ter have been elim­i­nated us­ing re­cy­cling and pipe­lines. The num­ber of trucks and tanks needed in some lo­ca­tions has plunged to 50 from 400 in 2011.

Thanks in part to these mea­sures, a last-minute deal state of­fi­cials made with en­vi­ron­men­tal ac­tiv­ists helped Col­o­rado avert an anti-frack­ing vote ear­lier this month.

No such com­pro­mise was reached about 800 miles away in Den­ton, Texas, near the birth­place of the U.S. en­ergy boom. Some res­i­dents there say they are ex­as­per­ated with the un­will­ing­ness of pro­duc­ers to lis­ten to their pleas to avoid late-night drill­ing and put wells far away from where chil­dren play. They’re aim­ing to ban all frack­ing in a vote this No­vem­ber.

Com­pa­nies have alien­ated some vot­ers with an at­ti­tude sug­gest­ing “this is just the way that it is in Texas, and if you don’t like it, that’s just too bad,” said Den­ton res­i­dent Cathy McMul­len, who started push­ing for more reg­u­la­tions af­ter wells were drilled by a park near her home. “As far as the in­dus­try goes in Texas, there is no give-and-take. There is just ‘we give, and they take.‘ “

The lat­est two frack­ing bat­tles — one in the heart of Texas oil coun­try, where sup­port for drill­ing is gen­er­ally as­sumed — un­der­score the prog­ress that frack­ing op­po­nents are mak­ing at the lo­cal level af­ter strik­ing out to gain more state or fed­eral con­trol over the in­dus­try.

Den­ton, built around two uni­ver­sities within a 40-minute drive of Dal­las and Fort Worth, has played host to tow­er­ing rigs since the 1960s. The home sta­dium of the Univer­sity of North Texas Mean Green foot­ball team is flanked by both wind tur­bines and nat­u­ral gas wells.

The cur­rent up­roar be­gan in 2009 with a well site staked out across the street from a park, hos­pi­tal com­plex and hill­side neigh­bor­hood. Despite lo­cal op­po­si­tion, Fort Worth-based Range Re­sources Corp. se­lected the site along a busy Den­ton thor­ough­fare out of four lo­ca­tions it was con­sid­er­ing to drill into the gas-rich Bar­nett Shale, the orig­i­nal shale play, City Coun­cil­man Kevin Roden said.

Range Re­sources spokes­man Matt Pitza­rella de­clined to com­ment on the com­pany’s for­mer wells in Den­ton, which are now op­er­ated by Leg­end Nat­u­ral Gas. Leg­end did not re­turn calls seek­ing com­ment.

Early last year, Den­ton changed its reg­u­la­tions, re­quir­ing that new wells be lo­cated at least 1,200 feet from homes. A loop­hole still let pro­duc­ers drill more wells at an ex­ist­ing site, re­gard­less of the set­back rule.

In one Den­ton sub­di­vi­sion of brick homes and two-car drive­ways, pri­vately held EagleRidge Energy didn’t in­form res­i­dents when it be­gan work­ing with heavy equip­ment and oil­field ma­chin­ery as close as 187 feet to back­yards and win­dows in Oc­to­ber 2013, ac­cord­ing to city of Den­ton spokes­woman Lind­sey Baker. Some home­own­ers felt their houses trem­ble dur­ing drill­ing, jar­ring pic­tures from walls, while oth­ers strug­gled to sleep as pow­er­ful lights atop a rig blazed through win­dows at night.

EagleRidge started an­other well three blocks to the south, sand­wich­ing the com­mu­nity be­tween drill­ing sites. Traf­fic bogged down and roads de­te­ri­o­rated, as hun­dreds of trucks brought frack­ing ma­teri­als to the sites, Ms. Baker said.

Oil in­dus­try sup­port­ers ar­gue that the city is partly to blame for let­ting de­vel­op­ers build new res­i­den­tial com­mu­ni­ties in ar­eas pre­vi­ously per­mit­ted for drill­ing. “It’s a con­flict that was ac­tu­ally cre­ated by the ad­min­is­tra­tion in the city of Den­ton,” said Ed Ire­land, ex­ec­u­tive di­rec­tor of the Bar­nett Shale Energy Ed­u­ca­tion Coun­cil, who was ap­pointed to a Den­ton task force formed to ad­dress the con­tro­versy.

Still, res­i­dents’ re­quests for re­lief have drawn lit­tle re­sponse, said Maile Bush, 41, a stay-at-home mom.

“You kind of just put up with it, be­cause you don’t feel like you have a say,” said De­n­ise Diaz, 41, an or­tho­don­tist’s as­sis­tant whose back­yard faces an EagleRidge well. EagleRidge chief op­er­at­ing of­fi­cer Mark Grawe didn’t re­turn calls seek­ing com­ment.

Fed up res­i­dents launched a cam­paign to draft a frack­ing ban in Feb­ru­ary and gath­ered enough votes on a pe­ti­tion to take the ques­tion to vot­ers Nov. 4.

A sim­i­lar vote that would have se­verely cur­tailed drill­ing in Col­o­rado, where oil out­put grew by 30 per­cent last year, was can­celed af­ter Demo­cratic Gov. John Hick­en­looper cre­ated a task force to study the in­dus­try’s im­pact on lo­cal com­mu­ni­ties. The deal ear­lier this month was also a nod to com­pa­nies, in­clud­ing Noble Energy and Anadarko, that have be­gun tak­ing steps to ap­pease con­cerns.

Last Decem­ber, Anadarko named en­gi­neer Alex Hoh­mann, who pre­vi­ously helped com­plete wells, to lead a new team deal­ing with com­mu­nity re­la­tions. Now, Mr. Hoh­mann, 31, spends his time vis­it­ing po­ten­tial sites and neigh­bor­hoods, some­times go­ing door-to-door, act­ing as a kind of oil-drill­ing dip­lo­mat.

“When your oil­field is in­ter­min­gled with 250,000 peo­ple, it’s in­creas­ingly im­por­tant to take into ac­count the neigh­bor­hood, the church and the school,” Mr. Hoh­mann said on a re­cent tour of sev­eral Anadarko drill­ing sites. “We have to de­mys­tify it, to help peo­ple see it as com­pat­i­ble with their lives. That’s our in­dus­try’s chal­lenge.”?

colorado - United States - North America - Texas - Fort Worth - John Hickenlooper - Denton - Dave Spence - Range Resources Corp


You have 2 remaining free articles this month

Try unlimited digital access

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here

You’ve reached the limit of free articles this month.

To continue unlimited reading

If you are an existing subscriber,
link your account for free access. Start here