The Pittsburgh region is very different — much more so than usual — at the end of 2023 than it was at the end of 2022.

This was the first full year after the tide of the COVID pandemic had receded, and the last of the 12-year tenure of Rich Fitzgerald as Allegheny County Executive. As Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration became fully established on Grant Street, a few blocks away the long-awaited trial of the Pittsburgh synagogue shooter finally began, and ended, bringing to a close one of the darkest chapters in Pittsburgh’s history.

Downtown became a flashpoint, politically and sometimes literally, with anxiety over violence and drug use stifling the Golden Triangle’s awakening from pandemic hibernation. The post-pandemic optimism that some cities have experienced has not yet materialized in Pittsburgh, leading to fears a new era of stagnation has replaced the optimism of the 2010s.

New blood

Advertise with us

Into this moment step new leaders: earlier this year, Larry Scirotto as chief the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police and, in two days’ time, former state Rep. Sara Innamorato as Allegheny County Executive. Mr. Scirotto was handed the worst staffing crisis in the bureau’s history, and while violent crime, by the numbers, was down this year, dramatic declines in sworn personnel and morale have left the bureau struggling as the New Year approaches.

Ms. Innamorato, meanwhile, inherits arguably the most stable situation of all as the head of county government. But she, too, has urgent matters to attend to, beginning with leading a selection process for a new warden for the county jail. She also must turn around a homeless services operation that badly misjudged the wintertime stress on the shelter system, leaving dozens of people who would take shelter if it were available to brave cold nights outdoors.

And she must do this while selling a once-again shrinking county to business and industry. The loss of Giant Eagle’s O’Hara Township headquarters to Cranberry Township in Butler County, announced just last week, ends the year and Mr. Fitzgerald’s tenure on a sour note.

Meanwhile, hanging over taxing bodies at every level is the specter of a collapse in assessed commercial property values due to a bungled common level ratio — which has overestimated assessed values — and high office vacancy rates in the city’s central business district. But that’s a topic for another time.

City hall shakeup

Advertise with us

All this takes place during the first two years of the scandalously incompetent Gainey administration. Mr. Gainey was swept into office with an apparent mandate for progressive leadership but has accomplished no major progressive goals; regressed to machine-style governance in terms of transparency and accountability; failed to complete basic tasks, such as appointing members of important boards and commissions; consistently lied or dissembled to City Council and the public about its activities; and stifled what little economic development could have occurred in this high-cost, high-interest environment.

And now, at the end of only its second year, the administration has attracted the attention of law enforcement on multiple fronts, beginning with its deceptive use, revealed first on this page, of a Waiver of Competitive Process to procure an amateurish police staffing study.

Near the beginning of 2023, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board saw these problems building up, and urged Mr. Gainey to shake up his staff. He did not do so. We renew, with even greater urgency, our call to bring in more high-level staff with deep governing experience, and to cut loose some of the activists and organizers who have had 24 months to prove they can run a city — and have failed to do so.

New year, new Pittsburgh

Whether 2023 is remembered as the year Pittsburgh, and Western Pennsylvania as a whole, settled back into the (badly) managed decline of a generation ago, or as a post-pandemic hiccup before renewed creativity and growth, will depend on how the region’s leaders handle the new year of 2024. Indeed, if there is one lesson of 2023, it should be this: Leadership matters.

Advertise with us

Altogether, what Pittsburgh needs now is back-to-basics pragmatism married to an innovative and realistic vision for the region that marshals local, state, federal and private resources to achieve transformative change.

Examples of this kind of thinking include the Keystone Space and Defense Innovation District, which could transform the North Side, and the collaboration between the Steelers and the Richard King Mellon Foundation to bring a youth sports complex to Hazelwood Green, which could bridge the gap between the brownfield development and the neighborhood that gives it its name.

Whether the region’s leaders — new and established, conservative and progressive, public and private — are up to the task will set Pittsburgh’s course for many years to come.