A successful City Council move to restore some oversight to waivers of the competitive bidding process was resisted by the Gainey administration, raising further questions about its commitment to open and fair dealing. Councilmembers’ unanimous vote against the administration’s self-serving arguments, meanwhile, represents an important assertion of council’s role as an independent watchdog, rather than subservient lapdog.

The modest anti-corruption reform the mayor opposed merely required the City Solicitor to approve bid waivers, which excuse the city from procurement rules that ensure taxpayer resources are used appropriately.

The waivers can be abused to hand out contracts to favored people and organizations while avoiding the required competitive process. Besides protecting taxpayers, open competition also protects city officials by ensuring a transparent process.

Council became interested in bid waivers after the suspicious hiring of Matrix Consulting Group to perform a study of the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police, and an unusual $300,000 contract with Homewood Community Sports for “workforce development.” In both cases, the administration filed a “waiver of competitive process” because the awardees were said to be the “sole providers” of the requested services.

Advertise with us

And in both cases, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has raised questions about the propriety of the waivers — especially in the Matrix case, where multiple members of the Gainey administration have repeatedly and falsely claimed that no other firm performs similar public safety studies. This has spurred an investigation by Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. into all city no-bid contracts since 2020.

Before 2020, all bid waivers required the signature of the City Solicitor. But that year, council removed the requirement, leaving only lay members of the procurement office to sign off. In other words, the Office of Management and Budget approved exceptions to its own rules without oversight.

The new ordinance, passed unanimously on Nov. 6, restored the previous practice. Nevertheless, City Solicitor Krysia Kubiak made spurious arguments against the move, most notably that the Law Department preferred to work in an advisory capacity, not an “adjudicatory” one.

But it is a core responsibility of the solicitor, enumerated in the city’s Home Rule Charter, to prepare city contracts — which means passing legal judgment on them. More likely, Ms. Kubiak was trying to keep the Law Department’s fingerprints off potentially sensitive documents. Under current practice, everyone can claim suspicious bid waivers weren’t legally vetted, giving OMB complete authority to suspend its own rules while protecting everyone from legal liability.

The unprotected party? City taxpayers.

Advertise with us

Restoring the previous practice ensures that someone with skin in the game — someone who could lose his or her law license for fraudulently or incompetently approving a waiver — must sign off. This further gives City Council confidence it isn’t approving corruption when voting on a contract with a bid waiver.

The ordinance was a modest good-government reform. That the Gainey administration fought it shows where its priorities are. And that City Council passed it shows the legislature is starting to stand up for itself, and for the people it represents.