This is not a column about running the T to the airport. I’m all for bold ideas, but this one simply isn’t going to happen, ever. Tough geography, too expensive and minimal payoff — the light-rail ride to and from Downtown would take forever.

This is not a column about running the T to Oakland. It’s also too expensive, and the University Line/PRTX bus rapid transit link serves that purpose just, or at least nearly, as well as a subway would.

This is not even a column about permanently restoring service on the Allentown Line, even though that wouldn’t be expensive at all and would be a boost to the Hilltop neighborhoods.

No, this is a column about something much simpler even than that, something that drives me slightly batty every time I see the unused rails and platforms just waiting for a train to make them very useful once again. It’s about connecting Pittsburgh’s two best transit lines, the T and the East Busway, further linking the North Side and South Hills to the East End and beyond and bringing more riders into the transit system.

Advertise with us

It’s about using the one-third mile Penn Station light rail line once again.

Color by numbers

If you travel to a big East Coast city like New York or Washington, one of the most important wayfinding devices is the color-coded transit map. These lines help visitors and residents alike orient themselves and therefore become features of neighborhood identity.

In Pittsburgh, by contrast, the old streetcar lines served this purpose, with many of those old numbers, like the 39 Brookline, being held over for bus routes. While this system worked great (and remains serviceable) for natives who know the system, a bus network that requires local knowledge or a decoder ring isn’t ideal for tourists or newcomers.

But that actually sells Pittsburgh short: The city also has one of the best fixed guideway transit networks — that is, routes where transit vehicles have an exclusive right-of-way — of any comparable town in America. This includes not just the T and the East Busway but the South Busway and the West Busway, any one of which transit advocates in peer cities would sacrifice an extremity to have locally.

Pittsburgh Regional Transit has tried to market these as “lines” like big-city metros, to middling success. There’s Blue, Red and (kind of) Silver on the T, while East Busway routes are Purple, South Busway ones are Yellow and West Busway ones are Green. Then buses that use the Parkway North HOV lanes are Orange, but that’s cheating.

Advertise with us

Making connections

The problem, and I suspect one of the main reasons this system never really caught on, is that the color-coded “lines” rarely connect to one another. The T lines and the South Busway touch at South Hills Junction, but (this one kills me) you can’t even walk from the South Bank bus stop to the South Bank T stop. Meanwhile, the West Busway terminates at West Carson Street in the West End.

Color-coded buses do (generally) have consistent loops in Downtown, but there’s not much signage or mapping that helps people navigate that. The closest there is to a real connection is the Wood Street T Station, where University Line, East Busway and South Busway (but not West Busway) routes converge. This has made the corner of Sixth, Wood and Liberty crowded and confusing, not to mention a hub of police activity.

In other cities with robust fixed-guideway systems, part of the appeal is that transfers within that system are relatively seamless. Once you’re “in the system,” you don’t have to do a lot of walking or complex navigation to reach your destination. Wayfinding guides within the system make it easy.

In contrast, for anything but a straight-to-Downtown ride in Pittsburgh you typically have to piece together your route yourself.

Low cost, high benefit

There is, however, a way to alleviate the pressure on Wood Street and reduce friction for transit riders. Better still, it’s one PRT knows can work because the authority uses it during construction and on special occasions: the single line connector between Steel Plaza and Penn Station.

Advertise with us

Running a simple, free light-rail shuttle on this line would provide a direct connection from the terminus of the East Busway into the T system, and vice versa, without having to navigate Downtown at all. A rider from, for instance, Dormont or Bethel Park could go straight to East Liberty or Swissvale without ever leaving the fixed-guideway system. The whole thing would only require a few dozen steps between platforms at Steel Plaza and at Penn Station.

I understand the reason this does not exist is that, when it did exist, the service consistently rated dead last in PRT for cost versus revenue. But I’d argue that the benefits to the system are greater than can be directly measured: By seamlessly uniting the East Busway and the T, you encourage people to use the system who wouldn’t have otherwise. And you keep them in the system once they’re there.

Due to changing usage patterns, inconsistent state funding and massive legacy liabilities, PRT is constantly in cost-cutting mode. But restarting the Penn Station connector would be a low-cost way to make a big improvement to the system, while signaling to Pittsburghers the authority is open to creative solutions.