Patrick O’Connor has baked thousands of cookies, pastries and other sweet treats as a professional pastry chef.

Over his decade-plus career, the Mercer County native has honed his craft to the point where he could probably be blindfolded and still whip up a blue ribbon pie or batch of amazing sugar cookies.

Turning flour, sugar, eggs and fats into something delicious, however, is as much science as art form. So he understands the process might not be quite as easy for everyone else.

He made plenty of mistakes when he first started to help his mother, Debbie, decorate cakes and make cookies in middle school. And many of the aspiring bakers in the Intro to Baking class he teaches at Community College of Allegheny County’s culinary arts program also start from scratch.

Advertise with us

Baking can be especially stressful during the holidays when expectations are high, time can be short and the ruling thought is you have to be extremely meticulous.

O’Connor’s advice when you’re staring down a spatula? Don’t get stressed out about it!

“Holiday baking is something everyone should be able to do,” he says. “At the end of the day it’s just flour, sugar, butter, and eggs.... Your grandkids won’t complain if there’s too many chocolate chips or the cookie is a little chewier than last time.”

PJ O’Connor, associate professor of culinary arts at CCAC, rolls chocolate chip cookie dough for a portrait in the pastry kitchen at CCAC’s Allegheny Campus on Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026, on the North Side. (Sophia Lucente/For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

That said, the 38-year-old pastry chef, who will help judge the Post-Gazette’s 2026 Holiday Cookie Challenge at the CCAC on Dec. 1, offers some simple tips to cut the angst while making your baking flow a little smoother.

Get organized

Advertise with us

One of the biggest mistakes bakers make is failing to be properly prepared, O’Connor says. That can lead to baking errors like forgetting ingredients or failing to preheat the oven or bring butter to room temperature or over (or under) mixing the batter.

For professional bakers, mise en place -- French for “everything in its place” -- is crucial.

Not only do you need to read the recipe top to bottom after clearing your counter space to make sure you understand the instructions. You also should gather all your tools and equipment, pre-measure every ingredient and line or grease your bakeware.

“You don’t want to get halfway through a recipe and find out you don’t have enough sugar,” O’Connor says. “Being organized and ready makes baking more enjoyable.”

Pay attention to the ingredient list

Advertise with us

When it comes to baking, words matter. If you use salted butter instead of unsalted, for instance, you’re adding sodium to the batter, which can alter the taste and texture of a cookie. Similarly, mistaking baking soda for baking powder changes the chemistry of your recipe. Baking soda needs both moisture and an acidic ingredient to act as a leavening agent, helping cookies to spread and brown. Baking powder -- which makes cookies rise -- requires moisture and heat.

Also keep a careful eye on the type of flour used. While most recipes call for all-purpose, some require lower-protein pastry flour for more delicate, crumbly cookies.

Consider using a digital scale

Like all professional pastry chefs, O’Connor weighs recipe ingredients. Remember, baking is an exact science that relies on precise chemical reactions so even a slightest variance can change or ruin a recipe.

Measuring cups and spoons can vary in size and shape, so if you use them to measure ingredients when a recipe calls instead for grams, it won’t be as accurate. While that might not mean much in a single batch of cookies -- Santa will still wolf them down regardless -- it matters a lot when you are scaling a recipe up to six or seven dozen to feed a crowd.

Advertise with us

Don’t fret over fancy equipment

Don’t have a KitchenAid mixer with a whisk attachment? No worries! An electric hand mixer or hand-held metal whisk works just as well.

You can also use two forks to cut butter into flour if you don’t have a pastry cutter, and a wine bottle makes an OK substitute for a rolling pin. Snip off the corner of a plastic storage bag and you’ve got a pastry bag to pipe icing.

Follow the right order

To assure the proper texture, shape and structure to your cookie, it’s essential to add ingredients in the right order.

Advertise with us

Eggs and liquid extracts go in the bowl after fats and sugars have been creamed together. Dry ingredients -- which should be whisked in a separate bowl first --come next and should be mixed only until just combined. (Overmixing makes cookies tough.) Mix-ins like raisins, chocolate chips and nuts come last.

A word about rolling and resting

Another common mistake novice bakers make is using too much force when rolling out cookie dough. Rolling up and down over the same spot actually will overwork it, says O’Connor.

Instead, roll outward from the center using gentle pressure, and after a couple of passes, rotate the dough a quarter turn.

“You’re just trying to move the dough to fit the shape you want and the thickness you want,” he says. “You don’t want to hurt the dough or spread it.”

Advertise with us

Another important note: If your recipe calls for chilling, let the dough rest in the refrigerator so the butter or other fat firms up.

PJ O’Connor, associate professor of culinary arts at CCAC, rolls chocolate chip cookie dough for a photo in the pastry kitchen at CCAC’s Allegheny Campus on Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026, on the North Side. (Sophia Lucente/For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The same goes for cookie batter that gets dropped or spooned on the pan instead of rolled out. If a recipes calls for chilling before baking, it’s for a reason, O’Connor notes.

Not only does cold butter take longer to melt in the oven, resulting in a thicker cookie, but resting allows the flour to absorb more water, creating crispy edges and soft centers.

“It’s not just to make it easier to work with,” he says.

Bakers should also avoid using too much flour on the rolling surface and be judicious when reusing scraps -- dough gets tough after being re-rolled one or two times.

Advertise with us

Lining baking sheets with parchment paper allows for easier cleanup but will affect how the cookie spreads. It’s great for drop cookies but not necessary for cookies with a lot of fat or ones where you want a crisp, golden bottom.

Be patient!

It’s human nature to be impatient, but when it comes to baking it’s a sin. Resist the urge the open the oven to check if your cookies are done -- even a few seconds can lower the temperature, disrupting how the dough sets and spreads. Instead, opt for what O’Connor calls the 75% rule. Set your timer for three-quarters of the recipe’s minimum bake time to check progress early and avoid burning.

“It also helps to turn the pan halfway through baking to even the browning process,” he adds.

Most cookies will almost look underdone, with soft centers and crisp edges, and they will also lose their shine. Cut-outs should be pale all the way across.

Advertise with us
A freshly baked batch of chocolate chip cookies sits on a counter in the pastry kitchen at CCAC’s Allegheny Campus on Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026, on the North Side. (Sophia Lucente/For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

While cookies often taste best when warm, it’s important to wait a few minutes after taking them out of the oven to remove them to a cooling rack. Allowing a brief rest on the hot sheet allows the cookies to continue cooking with residual heat without breaking apart, says O’Connor.

“It gives the cookie time to set itself,” he says. “The fats need to settle for the structure to be complete.”

Sanitation

It probably goes without saying, but remember to wash your hands before any mixing, rolling or decorating takes place. Also, tie back long hair and put on a clean apron!

Take similar care with work surfaces and equipment. Everything should be washed and rinsed, including the bottoms of your cookie sheets and not just the tops.

Advertise with us

Storage

Any cookies that aren’t eaten right away should be stored in airtight containers after being completely cooled. It will prevent soft cookies from drying out and crisp cookies from getting soggy.

You can freeze most cookies for up to two months. Layer them in a rigid airtight container with parchment or wax paper between the layers to prevent breakage and thaw to room temperature in the container before serving.

Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

PG tested

Advertise with us
A freshly baked batch of chocolate chip cookies sits on a counter in the pastry kitchen at CCAC’s Allegheny Campus on Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026, on the North Side. (Sophia Lucente/For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Don’t have a digital scale? Because cups and teaspoons are “practical approximations,” Patrick O’Connor also provides household measures in this cookie recipe to make things easier for the home baker without. Just be sure to use the spoon and level method to measure flour, and pack brown sugar to eliminate air pockets.

Toasting the milk powder in a dry skillet over medium-low heat creates a rich and nutty, caramelized flavor that supercharges baked goods.

1 tablespoon instant nonfat dry milk powder (4.5 grams)

6 tablespoons plus 1 teaspoon unsalted butter (90 grams)

1 cup plus 1 tablespoon pastry flour (112.5 grams)

Advertise with us

¼ cup plus 1 tablespoon bread flour (37.5 grams)

¼ teaspoons plus a small pinch baking soda (1.5 grams)

Scant ½ teaspoon fine table salt (2 grams)

⅓ cup plus 1 tablespoon brown sugar, packed (90 grams)

3 tablespoons granulated sugar (37.5 grams)

Advertise with us

1 whole egg, beaten (45 grams)

½ teaspoon vanilla (2.5 grams)

½ cup semisweet chocolate chips (75 grams)

To toast milk powder, stir a small amount in a dry skillet over low heat until evenly golden and fragrant. Transfer immediately to a bowl, cool and break up clumps. Weigh or measure the amount needed. (Store any leftovers in an airtight container for up to 2 months.)

In saucepan over low heat, melt butter gently. Avoid browning or prolonged simmering, Cool until barely warm but still liquid.

Advertise with us

In large bowl, whisk together pastry and bread flours, baking soda and salt.

In a second bowl, stir together butter, sugars and toasted milk powder. Add egg and vanilla; stir until uniform without whipping. The sugar does not need to dissolve completely.

Fold in the dry ingredients until nearly incorporated. Add chocolate chips and mix just until no flour remains.

Chill briefly in fridge if needed to be scoopable. Divide into approximately 12 rounded portions. Cover tightly and refrigerate 12-24 hours.

When ready to bake, arrange on a parchment-lined baking sheet, about 3 inches between centers.

Advertise with us

Bake at 350 degrees for 12-15 minutes, checking at 11 minutes. Edges should be set and lightly golden; centers should be soft but no longer wet or raw.

Leave on baking sheet to cool for 5-10 minutes, then transfer to a rack.

Makes 12 large cookies.

—- Patrick O’Connor, CCAC pastry chef and culinary instructor