A frustrating City Council argument last Wednesday about a wasteful lease for the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police headquarters highlights the necessity of maintaining fiscal responsibility. But has the city learned its lesson?
On Monday, councilors will vote on whether to approve a six-year extension of the city’s costly lease for the police building on Western Avenue on the North Side. The deal comes at a discount — thank goodness — of about $200,000 from the original 20-year contract, and with the right of first refusal to buy the property outright upon expiration.
The problem is that the lease will still cost the city over $8 million, on top of over $30 million already sunk into two decades of rent, for a building that is worth, in a very generous estimate, around $20 million. In other words, the city will have paid twice the value of the building — before buying the building.
The problem is, right now, there’s no better alternative. And the plan proposed by the previous administration has already been nixed.
This sad story begins 20 years ago, when the City of Pittsburgh was faced with a choice: Spend millions of dollars renovating an inadequate Public Safety Building on First Avenue in Downtown, or sell the property to PNC and use the proceeds to fund an alternative. The city chose the latter, and the land is now Firstside Park.
But in reality, the city didn’t have a choice at all, because it had neither money nor a worthy credit rating. The only option on the table was a lease that would fleece taxpayers in the long run, because the city lacked the short-term spending or borrowing power to do anything else.
Read More
Despite 20 years to plan, however, the city still doesn’t have an alternative, and thus finds its hand forced to sign another lease. For its part, the Peduto administration had kicked the tires on a massive plan, requiring significant federal and state funding, to turn the abandoned Veterans Administration hospital in Lincoln-Lemington into a public safety campus.
Besides providing a permanent home for the police, it would have liberated prime riverfront land in the Strip District, currently used for a variety of city needs, while providing revenue as a regional training facility. While the funding was hardly certain, the Gainey administration declined even to attempt the plan, removing the only close-to-viable alternative for the police HQ and forcing the expensive lease extension.
Throughout debate on the headquarters lease, councilors rightly asked if there weren’t some way to get a better deal: Could the city at least buy the property now, or in two or three years, instead of six? Office of Management and Budget director Jake Pawlak insisted that the administration had done the best they could: The city is completely at the mercy of the landlord.
Councilors insisted time and again that they understood the lesson of this episode — that they must steward taxpayer resources responsibly — and yet they are on the cusp of approving Mayor Ed Gainey’s 2024 budget, which includes five-year projections that hide expenses and exaggerate revenues, placing the city on a path to state oversight once again.
Which raises the question: Will the city even be able to afford the police headquarters building in 2029? Or will it, once again, be forced to rent because it’s too irresponsible to own?





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.