Mayor Ed Gainey presented a rosy vision of the City of Pittsburgh’s governance during his annual budget address to City Council, as should be expected of any chief executive. But unrealistic and misleading assumptions in Mr. Gainey’s proposed budget obscure the shaky foundations of the city’s finances, which could place Pittsburgh once again under state oversight in just a few years.
Most alarming of all, Mr. Gainey’s director of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), Jake Pawlak, has flatly asserted that “we don’t have a structural challenge,” but only a “temporary fiscal challenge.” This may be the case if the assumptions baked into Mr. Gainey’s budget are correct — an unprecedented rate of investment earnings, minimal raises in upcoming union contracts and consistently rising tax revenue — but they are not.
Instead, they are fiscal fig leaves that will justify short-term spending, while threatening the city’s long-term finances.
False projections
Mr. Gainey’s budget projects $80 million in investment income over the next five years, which is wildly unrealistic.
By law, the City of Pittsburgh must maintain a reserve fund balance of at least 10% of its annual expenditures. Right now, that fund contains about $150 million, or 23% of expenditures, which is largely invested in safe interest-bearing accounts. Additionally, Pittsburgh is nursing nearly $90 million in federal American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds.
Thanks to the Treasury bill rate being at its highest in nearly 25 years, this $240 million, plus other resting funds, is bringing in nearly $20 million in low-risk investment earnings this year. Compare this to low-interest periods during the COVID pandemic and after the 2008 Great Recession, when annual investment income was only about $100,000.
But this level of earnings won’t last.
When preparing a five-year fiscal forecast for the annual budget, OMB usually extrapolates the city’s current-year interest earnings into the future. That’s prudent when the income is low. But when it is at a one-time peak, assuming the city will earn nearly that much for five more years is deeply imprudent, and allows for misleading spending promises to be made that almost certainly cannot be kept.
Specifically, Mr. Gainey’s budget assumes the city will receive about $16 million in investment income each year for the next five years: an aggregate $80 million assumption that is not based in reality. Not only will the interest rates almost certainly drop, the money on which the city earns those rates will also go down considerably.
The budget projects drawing down reserve funds — the funds on which interest is earned — to less than half of current levels by the end of 2028. The city will also draw down its $88.5 million in ARPA funds, and must spend them completely by the end of 2026. Less money saved, less interest earned.
The only way the city will continue to collect $16 million in annual investment income is if rates skyrocket to levels not seen since the worst of 1970s stagflation. But that’s not going to happen, and both Mr. Pawlak and Mr. Gainey know it. The investment income is a misleading figure at the foundation of Mr. Gainey’s budget.
The budget projects drawing down reserves to the legal minimum by the end of 2028. But if investment income is closer to $12 million over the next three years — still unrealistically high — the city will reach that point before the end of 2026. And that’s not counting other hidden spending in the budget.
Hidden spending
As the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has already reported, Mr. Gainey’s departmental operating budgets assume that hundreds of union city employees will receive 0% raises in their new 2024 contracts, potentially hiding tens of millions in coming spending.
Sources indicate that the Gainey administration has promised City Council it has stashed away enough funds to cover these raises in a hidden $7 million annual line item in the Department of Human Resources and Civil Service. Besides being an unusual accounting practice, this will only suffice if negotiations yield a modest 2024 raise of 3% to 5%, followed by 3% thereafter. If the unions strike a deal similar to the police union, which would respond to recent record inflation, these allowances will leave $20 million in coming spending unaccounted for.
Taken together, these revenue and spending assumptions amount to up to $100 million in suspicious budgeting through 2028, leading to illegal deficits and reserves dwindling below the legal limit during 2026. At that time, it will become impossible to make legally required transfers to special funds, such as the Housing Opportunity Fund or the Stop the Violence Fund, without further depleting the reserves to dangerous levels.
Road to ruin
Lastly, the budget assumes $130 million in increased tax revenues over the next five years.
But the assessed value of property in the Golden Triangle is set to decline dramatically due to high post-pandemic office vacancy rates, and the city’s hostility to development — both in the Gainey administration and in the underlying zoning code — is hampering the growth needed to increase the city’s population and tax base. Generous tax revenue projections may have been sensible in the recent past, but they are optimistic at best today.
Altogether, the City of Pittsburgh’s financial foundations are much less stable than presented in Mayor Ed Gainey’s 2024 budget. While Mr. Gainey inherited some of these challenges, hiding them behind false and misleading financial assumptions is not a responsible way to address them.
The Mayor may be able to keep up the charade until his term in office ends in 2025, but after that Pittsburgh will need several years of austerity, and possibly state oversight, to recover.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.