I shouldn’t have been surprised at the news that Pirates general manager Ben Cherington expected skipper Derek Shelton to return next year. Mediocre institutions keep the same people around, doing the same things, because to change is to admit failure, and to be forced to do the hard and risky work of striving to do better.
That’s why it’s so hard for institutions with cultures of mediocrity to break their habits and to become excellent. The result is stagnation and paralysis — and even, in its most advanced forms, coming to regard excellence itself as suspicious. After all, it’s so much easier, and safer for the people in charge, to be merely mediocre.
The mediocre Pirates are the perfect franchise for what has become a very mediocre city.
Choosing mediocrity
I’m not one of those people who loves putting down his hometown. In college, my classmates joked that I was on the payroll of Pittsburgh’s tourism agency, given how much I talked it up. I grew up in the suburbs but moved to the city to be part of its fabric and its future.
But it’s precisely my instinctual optimism about Pittsburgh that makes the current state of its leadership so discouraging, and that motivates me to use whatever leverage I have to make that optimism realistic again.
This all comes to mind in the wake of Mayor Ed Gainey’s re-election announcement last Saturday, which kicks off a campaign that should be considered a referendum on Pittsburgh’s culture of mediocrity. Fittingly, it began with an embarrassingly mediocre event.
Read More
The announcement was staged on an uneven patch of dirt in Frick Park. The scene was meant to highlight the reconstruction of the overhead Fern Hollow Bridge — a state and federal project the Gainey administration had almost nothing to do with. But instead it looked like a band of politicos had gotten lost in the woods, and decided to hold a press conference addressing the wildlife.
As I’ve written before, I understand why Mr. Gainey defeated Bill Peduto in 2021. The incumbent had become complacent and much of the city saw him as distant. Mr. Gainey promised a fresh face and a more modest down-home approach to governing, not to mention the opportunity to make history. To choose him was not knowingly to choose mediocrity.
But to choose him again would be.
Conspiracy of mediocrity
Take this small but emblematic anecdote. Two weeks ago, the administration sent out a press release attempting to spin awful revenue figures as signs of the city’s good fiscal health. In that release, the mayor’s communications staff included official five-year financial projections from the Office of Management and Budget in the form — I am not joking — of a photo of a computer screen.
Not a spreadsheet. Not a PDF. Not even a screenshot. Someone in the mayor’s office got out their phone, took a picture of a city computer monitor and attached it to the official communication about the financial future of the city of Pittsburgh.
The Gainey administration has had more than its share of scandals and public missteps, but this sticks with me, because it could only happen within a culture where doing things the right way isn’t rewarded, or even expected. It’s the same carelessness the administration brings to the much more important work of balancing budgets and procuring services and following the law.
This isn’t how any successful enterprise is run, whether it’s a city, a township, a school district, a business or a child’s birthday party. But this is how Pittsburgh is being run.
In fairness to Mr. Gainey, his mediocrity is enabled by a cadre of public and private sector leaders who see it but refuse to say or do anything about it. It’s a conspiracy of mediocrity, where the safest choice for everyone is to do nothing rather than something — just like it’s safer for Mr. Cherington to keep Mr. Shelton around, so they can be mediocre together.
So nothing changes, and everyday Pittsburghers are subjected to amateurish government just as surely as they’re subjected to amateurish baseball.
Overcoming mediocrity
With the quality of young talent the Pirates have collected, they should at least be competitive, like other teams with similar prospects. The underperformance is a failure, and in a healthy institution — one that really aims for excellence — people with authority would be held accountable.
Pittsburgh has the natural and institutional resources to be competitive with peer regions, and even to excel beyond them. And yet it’s falling behind. On nearly every metric of growth and livability, in recent years peer cities like Cincinnati and, yes, Cleveland have surged past us. Allegheny County has the worst post-pandemic job-recovery figures in the country.
Next spring, Pittsburghers (at least the registered Democrats) will have a chance to hold their leader accountable in the primary election, and to take a step toward breaking the culture of mediocrity that is smothering their city’s potential. Removing Mr. Gainey might also disrupt the complacency of other nodes of power in the region.
The question — for the baseball team and for the city — is whether we are satisfied with mediocrity, or are willing to make the choice to aim for excellence.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Politicians trying to kill Nippon deal think Pittsburghers are stupid.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.