The bipartisan consensus against the Nippon Steel deal is an agreement to further devastate the Mon Valley economy, clownishly dressed up as pro-worker populism. It will be the end of steelmaking in the Steel City.
It treats the people of Pittsburgh as fools, as if we value the national origin of U.S. Steel’s ownership more than actual investment in our communities. They’re selling us ruination and telling us it’s what we want. It’s the kind of dishonest and unserious leadership Pittsburgh has experienced for the past few years, extended nationally, then turned right back on us.
And it’s a blaring signal of national weakness and petulance broadcast to Japan, and to the entire world.
Worth saving
I know that calling Pittsburgh the “Steel City” in the year 2024 is more branding than reality.
The U.S. Steel of the halcyon days, when the industry defined and dominated the region and its companies supported tens of thousands of workers nearly from cradle to grave, has been gone for a long time.
What’s left is like what was left of the Roman Empire at the dawn of the Middle Ages: smaller, weaker, barely recognizable, close to disappearing.
Read More
And yet what’s left still supports about 3,000 blue-collar workers and hundreds of white-collar workers directly, plus thousands more indirectly — contractors, suppliers, food and drink establishments and more. Losing Pittsburgh steelmaking is not trivial, and it is not only a matter of nostalgia.
Yes, it was churlish and heavy-handed for U.S. Steel to directly threaten to shutter the Mon Valley Works and abandon Pittsburgh, as it did on Wednesday. And yet the company’s treatment by public officials, and especially Nippon’s treatment, has been far beyond heavy-handed: demagogic, authoritarian and, in the case of the Japanese partner, xenophobic.
Further, the threat only said outright what everyone has known since the company reneged on its promise to invest billions in the Mon Valley in favor of its Arkansas facilities: U.S. Steel’s days in Pittsburgh were numbered. There was neither the will nor the capital to being the ancient mills into this century.
Nippon is offering not just a stay of execution. It’s offering a billion-dollar investment to extend steel’s presence in the Steel City for a generation or more.
No future without Nippon
Let’s consider what the politicians won’t say: There is no future for steelmaking, and steelworkers, in the Mon Valley without Nippon Steel.
All the populist language about opposing the deal to save jobs? They think it’s what we want to hear, because they think we’re stupid. And it will result, stupidly, in those jobs being lost forever.
To reiterate the point made time and again in these pages and elsewhere: The only alternative offer for U.S. Steel — from Cleveland-Cliffs — would have brought all American blast furnace steelmaking and iron ore reserves under one corporate roof.
It would have been an anti-trust nightmare and a redundancy disaster for Pennsylvania: The Mon Valley Works was always going to be superfluous in the new company’s portfolio, and its doomsday would likely have been accelerated. Further, the company’s headquarters would have almost certainly moved to the shores of Lake Erie.
What’s so galling is how obvious this is. It is not complicated. It doesn’t take an advanced degree in economics or metallurgy to figure out what the options are, and what will happen when one is chosen.
The politicians who are trying to score populist points by shrieking about “protecting workers” or “national security,” from local congressmen and senators to every person on the main presidential ballots, must know they are advocating for killing off the last steel in the Steel City.
And they must know that by any objective measure the American steel industry will be weaker without Nippon’s investment and expertise. And that will make America weaker, not stronger.
Recklessly stupid
They must know — unless they are so deluded by their own belief in their own power that they think they can legislate or regulate U.S. Steel into existing forever, an industrial zombie kept alive by the sheer will of the United States government.
But that’s the most dangerous fantasy of all — not just because it implies an economic system dictated by the federal government, but because it expresses to the world a deeply immature and insecure understanding of America’s place in the world.
You don’t have to love globalism to see this. I’m all for a new birth of economic nationalism. We should be trying to bring strategic supply chains, manufacturing and resource extraction within American borders.
We should try to stop companies beholden to governments with disparate interests from our own from gaining financial or governance leverage within or over U.S. companies, especially in sectors of strategic importance. We should be developing an industrial policy with a focus on resilience and abundance.
And the Nippon Steel bid doesn’t threaten any of those goals. In fact, it supports all those goals. To treat it as if it were a Chinese company offshoring U.S. missile manufacturing to Guangdong isn’t just wrong. It’s recklessly stupid.
It shows that U.S. leaders are heedless and insecure. And everyone, from Tokyo to Moscow to Beijing to Tehran, can see it.
This isn’t just a turning point for Pittsburgh; it’s a turning point for America. Does anyone have what it takes to lead with intelligence and integrity, or is this country as decrepit as the steel mills themselves — because we don’t even have the wisdom to accept a friend’s help to bring them into the future?
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “In barring PG from campaign coverage, Harris-Walz become what they oppose.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.