It’s said that after candidly testifying to the Atlanta grand jury about Donald Trump’s interference with Georgia elections, South Carolina Sen. Lindsey Graham encountered the prosecutor, Fani Willis, in the courtroom corridors.

The senator, like many others a Trump critic turned Trump loyalist, stood before the woman who would later drag Mr. Trump to Fulton County for a mugshot — and embraced her. “That was so cathartic,” he said, like a penitent who had emerged from the confessional for the first time in years. “I feel so much better.”

His team angrily denied the story when it appeared in Michael Isikoff and Daniel Klaidman’s book “Find Me the Votes” early this year. The brief moment when Mr. Trump’s dominance of the Republican Party had come into question had passed. No good could come from appearing to dissent.

Yet it was possible — maybe not likely, but possible — that an organized movement to tell the truth could have sidelined Mr. Trump for good immediately after Jan. 6, 2021. The truth not just about what he said and did on that day, but about how little the people around him thought of him, about how badly he treated others and stewarded the government.

Advertise with us

But few spoke up, and it was soon too late. Just like it is now too late for the truth about President Joe Biden’s deteriorating condition. Just like it will soon be too late for the truth about the appalling mismanagement of the city of Pittsburgh.

Behind the curtain

When it all comes crashing down — in a company, a campaign, an administration — one fact always becomes clear: Many people knew about the problems that led to demise, and their silence both hastened the crash and made it worse when it came.

Since last Thursday’s disastrous presidential debate, it’s become clear just how many people in the White House, in Democratic circles and in the media knew how bad Mr. Biden’s condition had become — and hid that truth. Indeed, lied about it. The debate gave the world a 90-minute tour behind the curtain.

One of the most striking descriptions came from Alex Thompson, a reporter for Axios, on CNN the night of the debate: “The White House’s response every single time [Mr. Biden’s age] has come up for three and a half years has been to deflect, to gaslight, to not tell the truth. … There’s a reason he does not do events, almost ever, before 10 a.m. and is rarely on camera after 6 p.m.”

This commentary raises an obvious question: If this was all so well-known, why are we only hearing about it now? Hundreds of members of the media and other political insiders would have heard about or witnessed Mr. Biden as he appeared at the debate — but they kept it to themselves.

Advertise with us

People who know

For any given person at any given moment, the incentives rarely align in favor of speaking up. It’s easy and natural to believe that maintaining relationships now is more important than whatever good might come from blowing the whistle.

Yet when no one says anything, the crisis always deepens.

Take the situation in Pittsburgh today. The knowledge among the city’s movers and shakers that the Gainey administration is setting new lows for competence and trustworthiness is at least as pervasive as the knowledge in Washington of Mr. Biden’s frailty.

Some people, to be sure, have seen the administration only at its best, just as some people had seen Mr. Biden only on his good days. But this is the exception.

Pittsburgh’s eminences, including its media, know (or have no excuse not to know) that the city’s budget is built on sand; that political favors are being clumsily distributed left and right; that almost everyone who does business of any kind with City Hall is treated shabbily; that city government has been placed at the disposal of private interests like SEIU Healthcare; and that the administration struggles to complete basic tasks both obvious (turning on water fountains) and obscure (appointing members of boards and commissions).

Advertise with us

“Awful.” “Disaster.” “Worse than you know.” These are the words I hear again and again. These are the words used over coffee and drinks and club sandwiches among the people who know.

Linking arms

Yet you only know because this page, along with a few other journalists in the city, has reported on it. Outside of this, there is no organized movement to tell the truth. Just like with Mr. Biden. Just like with Mr. Trump.

So most Pittsburghers, especially if they pick and choose their news sources, can believe that the current incompetence is no different than the usual incompetence. That it’s just “city government.” They can believe what the people who know, know to be false: that everything is fine.

There is no individual fault here — it is not rational for any single person to charge into battle by themselves — but a collective fault: the inability of a critical mass of people to link arms and to share the risk of telling the truth. To do the hard thing together.

But as we see in Washington, not taking that risk is, for everyone, the riskiest move of all.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.