Contractor Fay, S&B USA Construction has proposed a public-private partnership with Pittsburgh that could invest several hundred million dollars to fix a wide range of bridge problems in the city.
If the concept wins state approval, it could lead to one contractor designing, building and maintaining a series of bridges in the city, which has been struggling to upgrade more than 140 bridges it owns.
The proposal Fay submitted to the state Department of Transportation’s P3 board in June said the concept could lead to $150 million to $400 million worth of bridge work in the city, but the company said it hasn’t chosen specific bridges for the project yet.
Pittsburgh Mayor Corey O’Connor, who mentioned the idea at the American Society of Civil Engineer’s release Tuesday of an infrastructure report card for the state, said the city strongly supports the proposal. At its December meeting, the P3 board is expected to discuss the proposal, which has been undergoing expedited review by PennDOT.
“We’re pushing for it,” the mayor said in an interview after the event. “That could be a real game-changer for Pittsburgh.”
The P3 program is designed to encourage grouping projects under one contractor or set of contractors to reduce costs through economies of scale. It can authorize public-private partnerships under two programs, projects proposed by PennDOT for contractors to bid on or projects proposed by private companies for consideration by the state.
For example, about 10 years ago, the state contracted with Plenary Walsh Keystone Partners on a five-year Rapid Bridge Replacement Program to replace more than 550 small bridges with similar designs for $942 million. That project worked because the contractor could buy a large amount of precast concrete beams at a lower price, then use them on a variety of projects.
Grant Ervin, vice president for external affairs at Fay, said the firm has been aware of the city’s bridge problems because it has been located here for decades. It decided to propose the Pittsburgh program after its success as a contractor and construction manager on a $2.3 billion PennDOT program to replace or rehabilitate six major bridges, including four on Interstate 80.
Fay proposed a program for seven bridges in a variety of sizes and conditions as an example, Ervin said, to gauge PennDOT’s interest in the concept. If the state approves the concept, the company would work closely with the city to determine which bridges to improve.
Then the project would go out for bids and any contractor could submit the lowest price to do the work.
“We’re not necessarily wedded to the bridges included in the proposal,” Ervin said. “The concept is the package of projects all moving ahead at the same time. We can work with the city to determine which bridges are best to include.”
Although Pittsburgh’s bridges rarely follow a similar design to allow mass purchasing of supplies, Ervin said, the savings would come from using groups of designers and engineers to work on several projects at once. Additionally, costs inevitably go up over time, so it would be less expensive to work on numerous projects at once rather than one after the other.
“The concept is based on procurement, resource allocation and defined geography, the 55 square miles of the City of Pittsburgh,” Ervin said.
The concept could lead to a series of bridges being finished in five to seven years, often the time it takes to design and build one structure. Although no decisions have been made yet, it probably would be less expensive over time to replace bridges rather than do a full rehabilitation because new structures could last for 70 years or more, Ervin said.
Fay hasn’t determined yet whether it would include long-term maintenance as part of the program.
O’Connor said the key for the city will be whether it is able to borrow the money to finance a group of bridges at a reasonable cost given its shaky financial condition.
The city has been focused on the condition of its bridges since the Fern Hollow Bridge in Squirrel Hill fell into Frick Park in January 2022, former Mayor Ed Gainey’s first month in office.
A series of reports by consultant WSP Inc. finished in 2024 determined that city bridges needed $471.6 million worth of work over the next 32 years: $135.4 million for nine bridges that needed immediate work; $276.3 million for 98 bridges that needed extensive work by 2039; and $59.4 million for long-range projects that should be completed before 2056.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.