Johnathan Morris appeared surprised to learn from Allegheny County homicide detectives that he’d killed a police officer on Feb. 6, 2023.

Morris — still hospitalized three days after the deadly shooting in McKeesport that killed Officer Sean Sluganski and wounded Officer Chuck Thomas Jr. — was polite, often calling lead detective Patrick Kinavey “sir.” He told the detectives he’d been having a good day.

“Johnathan, I mean, whether you know or not, you know you shot one of the police officers, right?” Kinavey asked.

“I’m sorry about that,” Morris said.

Advertise with us

Kinavey continued: “And you know you shot the second officer as well — you shot two officers. One of the officers died.”

“Whoa,” Morris said, and then continued in a rush: “There’s no way I could have shot any officers, literally, because I shot at the car twice.”

“And then you fired three more times,” Kinavey said. “I’m telling you what’s up — there’s video.”

Morris crossed himself, and sat with his head in his hand for several long seconds.

“There would be no way possible that I shot a cop — no way possible, no way,” he said. “There’s absolutely no way possible that I shot anybody.”

Advertise with us

The roughly half-hour interview was among the final pieces of evidence prosecutors in the homicide case against Morris presented to jurors on Tuesday, the sixth day of testimony in the case. In it, Morris recounted what he believed happened the day, noting that he’d “blacked out” several times throughout the incident.

Defense attorney Carmen Robinson focused her cross examination of Kinavey on what he thought of Morris’ mental state during the interview. He told her that Morris was responsive and coherent.

Sluganski and Thomas had initially responded that afternoon to a domestic violence call from Morris’ mother, former McKeesport officer Candace Tyler. She said he was being violent and suffering from PTSD. She asked for medics to assist with obtaining an involuntary commitment, but the call taker told her police had to respond to such calls.

In the interview with detectives, Morris said he had no idea anyone called 911, and he claimed that his mother was the one who attacked him as he searched for a satchel he believed she’d stolen.

Morris said he shrugged off the officers when they asked him to come with them. Then, he said, he blacked out. When he came to, he was at the bottom of a hill, and police were still following him.

Advertise with us

“I black out again, and whenever I come back to life, I’m on top of that damn police getting dragged by a police car,” he said, noting that he looked inside and saw a cop who’d been following him “for some time.”

When he tried to run away, he said, Thomas tried to “smash him” between the car and the small hillside in front of 1300 Grandview Ave. Morris said he pulled out his pistol because he saw “the other officer pull out his pistol.”

“I’m scared man, I’m like, ‘what the [expletive]?’ When I looked up and I pull out my pistol —” he paused mid-sentence, then continued: “Actually, my brother was there, too. … Actually, I [saw] all three of them.”

He said he believed his brother would help him. Instead, he alleged, they cheered for the police to “get him.”

Morris referred to Thomas throughout the interview as “the Black officer” and Sluganski, who was on foot for the tail end of the pursuit, “the white officer.” He alleged he saw Sluganski pull his gun, at which point, “I fired mine, just warning shots, like ‘Hey dude, I’m [expletive] scared.’”

Advertise with us

Kinavey asked him if he fired anymore at either Thomas or Sluganski.

“No, I’m not trying [to] hurt nobody,” he said.

After that, Morris said, he ran, realized he’d been shot, and collapsed in a parking lot a block away. He encountered two men who’d come out of the adjacent auto shop and were trying to help him when another officer pulled up to the scene.

Morris claimed he could tell from Lt. Robert Eastman’s demeanor “that he wasn’t hearing [expletive].” When Eastman pulled his gun, he said, he thought, “Damn bro, this is it for me.”

“So I had to start firing at the cop,” he said, then rolled away as Eastman continued to fire.

Advertise with us

Later, Kinavey asked how many times he shot at Eastman. Morris said he thought twice.

“If it wasn’t one, it was two.”

About 17 minutes into the interview is when Kinavey informed Morris he’d shot Thomas in the car and killed Sluganski on the hillside.

“I didn’t shoot at him. I did not shoot at him. I literally shot two bullets at the officer —” Kinavey cut him off and told him he shot five times.

“I didn’t shoot five,” Morris said, and Kinavey told him, “100% you shot five.”

Advertise with us

“I did?” Morris asked. “Damn. I must have blacked out for real. Damn.”

After a few more questions, the detectives ended the interview. Morris was quiet.

“I’m sorry for that cop’s family,” he said.

Defense attorneys moved for a judgement of acquittal from Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer on all counts, which is a normal move for the defense after the prosecution rests its case. He denied the motion.

Robinson called just two brief witnesses Tuesday afternoon, both of whom had already testified: Kinavey and ACPD Det. James Fitzgerald. Defense testimony is expected to continue Wednesday morning.