Bill Peduto’s 2021 defeat at the hands of Ed Gainey is often chalked up to enthusiasm to elect the city’s first Black mayor, and to disapproval of the conduct of Pittsburgh police during the unrest of 2020. These are no doubt among the proximate causes of Mr. Gainey’s seven-point victory, but there’s always been a deeper explanation.
The 2021 mayoral primary was at least as much a referendum on Mr. Peduto’s particular vision of Pittsburgh as it was on a particular mayor. It was a vision that emphasized Pittsburgh’s future more than its past, and that saw that future in chasing (and, at its most ambitious, setting) social and economic trends and participating energetically in the global marketplace.
It was a vision that sometimes seemed more invested in turning Pittsburgh into something it wasn’t — an Austin or a Portland — than embracing what it is. And it was a vision that ultimately failed to find support among a majority of Pittsburghers, at least those who vote in Democratic primaries.
In other words, Bill Peduto was defeated — and Ed Gainey is sustained — by parochialism just as surely as by progressivism.
‘Bike-lane Bill’
I say this as a very parochial Pittsburgher. My mom’s from Allentown, my dad from Sheraden. My mom’s family mostly moved to the south suburbs, my dad’s to the west. My family moved to Brookline about a decade ago, and we plan to stay there forever.
I don’t like change very much, and think it’s often for the worse. I know, and value knowing, where things used to be. I think appreciating what you do have is underrated, and fantasizing about what you could have is overrated.
And so the former mayor’s grandiosity often left me cold, and I was more or less indifferent to his political fate. In fact, I thought a more humdrum, workaday approach to the job might do the city good.
Mr. Peduto lost that primary not because of Black voters or East End progressives, but because moderate voters in the south and west neighborhoods — people who thought like me — selected Mr. Gainey or longshot alternative Tony Moreno as a rebuke to globetrotting “bike-lane Bill.” For instance, the incumbent failed to reach 50%, a necessary threshold to overcome losses elsewhere, in Brookline, Beechview and Banksville.
Now, I still believe Pittsburghers’ love of the local — our neighborhoods, our traditions — is a strength, and that Mr. Peduto’s inability to reflect that in a politically compelling way was a weakness. But parochialism on its own is not a political program. And when matched with anti-growth progressivism, it smothers the city.
No-ambition coalition
The Ed Gainey coalition is a quiet partnership between people who don’t like change at all and people who only like change if it perfectly suits their ideology.
It’s people who oppose expanding Bakery Square because they like going to that McDonalds thank-you-very-much and those who are offended that the new residences will be pricey and that a private developer will profit from them. It’s people who think the mayor flying to Europe to make business contacts is a snob who wants to turn Pittsburgh into something it isn’t and those who think he’s selling out Pittsburgh to global capitalists.
It’s people who think Pittsburgh should be dingy, because it wouldn’t be Pittsburgh if it weren’t — or because the alternative is “gentrification.” They start from different first principles, but they arrive at the same conclusion: growth almost always costs too much.
Here’s the thing: I sympathize with both of these impulses. It is absolutely possible for Pittsburgh to be more prosperous in the aggregate, while overall a less attractive place to live for most people. Growth is not good in itself, but only when it serves the actual human beings who keep the city going.
The problem is that our world is not set in amber. Maintaining Pittsburgh’s distinctiveness isn’t about leaving everything the same, which in a competitive marketplace — Pittsburgh competes not just with other cities but with its own suburbs — will only mean every neighborhood declines together.
To keep Pittsburgh what it is actually requires a vision for what it, and each of its 90 neighborhoods, can be in the years to come.
And it requires the ambition to bring in enough new people and businesses and resources to make that vision a reality.
Starving for leadership
So I’ve come to appreciate Bill Peduto’s grandiosity, and the real public purpose it served, much more in his absence than his presence. The deep irony is that for Pittsburgh to remain Pittsburgh, and not a husk that was Pittsburgh, the city and its leaders must aggressively participate in the economy beyond its borders.
The current administration of progressive navel-gazers may be satisfying its anti-growth, anti-change coalition, but it’s neither improving the city nor preserving what makes it great.
Pittsburgh has gone from arguably too much vision and ambition to none at all. The city is starving for both, and for someone who can deliver them.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.