I’ll admit to being a little annoyed that the most embarrassing political faceplant in recent Pittsburgh history happened when I was on vacation. In just a few days, the “No War Crimes On Our Dime” campaign — a move to divest the city from Israel by activists whose energy propelled Ed Gainey to office three years ago — made the mayor look weak while accomplishing nothing.

The campaign managed to cause the ouster of city communications director Maria Montaño; expose several more administration officials to public scrutiny; and elevate the profile of mayoral antagonist Controller Rachael Heisler. And still get excluded from the ballot because of incompetence in collecting signatures.

It was the kind of week that convinced me, as speculation swirls about possible primary challengers to Mr. Gainey, that the façade of strength erected by the mayor and the activist clique is finally crumbling. It convinced me, for the first time, that Mr. Gainey is unlikely to be re-elected.

Disastrous campaign

“No War Crimes On Our Dime” sought to place on the November ballot a referendum that would amend the city’s Home Rule Charter to ban “investment or allocation of public funds” to any organization that does business in Israel until residents of Palestinian territories are granted “equal rights.” The campaign was officially organized by the local chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America, but in practice it brought together a similar coalition of activists as the protest movements of summer 2020.

Advertise with us

But four years ago, that movement pursued tangible, local policy goals, resulting among other things in the creation of a Community Task Force On Police Reform. The Gaza referendum, on the other hand, represented a regression to student government-style politics: symbolic, impractical, narcissistic.

Singling out Israel in a world full of horrors — Sudan, Myanmar, Ethiopia, Xinjiang, not to mention Russia and Ukraine — gives the game away. This wasn’t about morality; it was about ostracizing the Jewish state and the people who support its existence and survival, including thousands of fellow Pittsburghers.

What made this effort particularly risible, however, was that the referendum language was composed with juvenile heedlessness of the law, and of reality.

As Ms. Heisler pointed out on several occasions, cutting ties with every company that does business in Israel would mean cutting ties with the company that provides electricity to city buildings, the company that produces Narcan to reverse overdoses, and every available company that sells gasoline to fill city vehicles. If passed and enforced, it would have crippled the city.

The referendum never got close to that point, however, because its organizers withdrew it before a court could quash it. The city charter requires a referendum to have the signatures of more than 12,000 registered voters residing the city to reach the ballot. “No War Crimes On Our Dime” submitted around 15,000 names, but opponents of the effort quickly identified several thousand that didn’t belong to city residents. Many more were invalid for other reasons.

Advertise with us

Referendum supporters have whined that Ms. Heisler and others who challenged their petitions created barriers to “democracy.” The only barrier was their own inability to fulfill the requirements of the charter they sought to amend.

Week of weakness

This would have been embarrassing enough for a progressive activist clique that has enjoyed far outsized influence in city politics, even while struggling to maneuver the actual levers of power. But their failure also ensnared the hapless Gainey administration, in multiple ways.

First, multiple members of Mr. Gainey’s cabinet, most prominently communications director Maria Montaño, signed the petition. While it was certainly their right to do so, their public endorsements put the administration in a bind: Any position Mr. Gainey would take would be read either as a rebuke of, or as following the lead of, his own staff. It exposed rifts in his inner circle. And it reinforced the impression of an administration more invested in activism than governing.

Still, Mr. Gainey had the opportunity to do the grown-up thing. He could have pointed out the obvious procedural and substantive problems with the referendum and joined Ms. Heisler in petitioning the courts to quash it due to its numerous legal shortcomings. He could have treated the campaign’s supporters with respect while also standing up for the law.

Instead, the mayor released a mealy-mouthed statement that signaled some weak concerns about the legality of the referendum, while declining to stand for or against it. Neither supporters of the referendum, who make up much of his political base, nor supporters of Israel, who have long harbored concerns about his leadership, received the validation they desired.

Advertise with us

And then Ms. Montaño “resigned.” It doesn’t take a genius or a cynic to see that the drama had widened existing fissures within the administration, and provided an opportunity to part ways with the staffer who, as a former SEIU flack, most visibly attached Mr. Gainey to the strident left — and who led a burgeoning communications staff that was conspicuously poor at communicating.

Time to speak up

For the mayor and the activists, the referendum debacle demonstrated the one quality every political leader and movement must avoid at all costs: weakness. The activists look vain and ridiculous. The mayor looks uncertain and impotent. His staff looks confused and fractured.

Mr. Gainey’s political strength has always been based not on actual power, but on the unwillingness of weighty and prominent voices to speak against him. The costs of doing so suddenly appear much lower than at any time in his reign — exposed by the fecklessness of the very activists who propelled him to office.

Brandon McGinley’s previous article was “Will Tim Walz solve America’s daddy problems?”