Liberty Elementary school in Shadyside has hosted a parent-organized before-and-after school care program, the Liberty Extended Day Program, for over 40 years. While it’s staffed by professionals with all their certifications, the board of directors are primarily parents with children enrolled at Liberty.

Liberty is a magnet school in the Pittsburgh Public School (PPS) system, focused on bilingual Spanish education. Students from across the district register for a lottery to attend it, or one of the other nine K-5 magnet schools.

The parents who run the program do so with love. They care for their children, of course, but also for the teachers and staff at Liberty. The Liberty PTA reimburse educators for out-of-pocket expenses, raise money and create school-wide Latino-focused cultural events like Cinco de Mayo and Day of the Dead.

A new proposal before PPS would turn Liberty Elementary back into a neighborhood school. Most of the parents who make up the Liberty Extended Day Program and PTA would no longer have students at the school. The program might survive, but not as the program it is.

Advertise with us

All of this is being done in the name of equity.

Magnetic attraction

Magnet schools have always been controversial. Initially, they were created as places where students who wished to specialize in their K-12 education could find particular courses. STEM-focused academies train students in science, mathematics and engineering. Performing arts schools encourage artistic development.

Effectively, though, magnets became segregated spaces, where select people could escape school districts that were failing everyone else.

Pittsburgh’s magnet system was created in 1979 to retain families who were fleeing the school district for suburban, private or charter schools. The hope was to create educational equity for everyone by keeping those likely to flee as well as providing new opportunities for those who would never have left in the first place.

Yet, consider one of the facts raised at the district’s education committee meeting on Tuesday. Montessori, one of the two elementary magnet schools with a significant wait list, is roughly 70% white in a school district that’s over 60% Black. Did the magnet programs solve a problem or create an entirely new one?

Advertise with us

But Montessori is an outlier. Liberty Elementary is approximately 90% minority students. Dilworth, the other elementary magnet with a wait-list, is 70% non-white.

Hiding behind equity

Still, that didn’t stop representatives of the Massachusetts-based education consulting firm Education Resource Strategies from using Montessori’s demographics to claim magnet schools had failed. The firm suggested closing 16 schools, changing the grade configuration of another 14 and eliminating six magnet schools in favor of neighborhood-based ones. That included Liberty.

The plan might not be a bad one — though not for equity reasons. The truth is that PPS has massive financial issues looming ahead, as well as too many outdated buildings and lowering enrollments. School consolidations and closures will help with bussing costs as well as redundancy issues. Some of the moves under consideration might be necessary and unavoidable.

But in framing them as issues of “equity,” the board is gaslighting parents. “Liberty is listed as an ‘underused’ facility,” a Liberty parent told me. “But I’ve walked up and down those halls. It’s simply not the case. What do they want? 35 to 40 kids in a classroom?” he said. “My kid’s music teacher currently has to share a space with the science lab. But there’s too much space according to their reports.”

The consultants and board members at Tuesday’s meeting refused to clearly answer questions about the proposal’s impact on class sizes.

Advertise with us

School board President Gene Walker dismissed families who choose to leave the district. He sees their departures as a done deal. “I don’t think we have to consider that as we are trying to make decisions, because folks are already leaving.”

This riled up many parents who know that retaining families is a huge part of actually achieving education equity. It also felt like the new plan is the same as the old plan — we’re moving back to the discussions the district was having in 2007 about closures and consolidation, instead of seeing the positives the magnet school system has created.

Keep the families

The same firm that held up Montessori as an example of why equity failed, later in the same meeting proposed moving it to a new building that’s been renovated. Instead of figuring out how to bring more Montessori-like programs to other schools, they are misdirecting parents about why other magnets need to be cut. PPS is protecting white spaces while consolidating minority ones in the name of equity, and the parents know it.

“I wish that PPS saw ‘underutilized’ facilities as an advantage, keeping small teacher-to-student ratios and developing richer educational models. What’s working should be replicated,” another Liberty parent told me.

“Instead of pushing people away, PPS should be honest, and make us allies in fixing our schools. Liberty’s parent groups prove it. Getting parents on your side is good for everyone.”

Previous column: “Donald Trump’s running the race in his head, and that’s a good way to lose.”