When Pittsburgh Public Schools started to “right size” in 2006, closing 22 school buildings, it abandoned predominantly Black communities, moving students from their neighborhood schools to schools that were not of better quality or welcoming.
Many families with school-age children on the Northside, Hazelwood, and the East End chose to support the creation of what they believed to be quality, safe, and family-friendly charter schools that ended up with significantly larger student enrollments than the schools that were closed in those neighborhoods.
But it was the school system that effectively segregated the district when it began to eliminate magnets and move to K-8 schools.
Doing school differently
Moving students to different, equitably resourced school buildings with the same programs and school structures will not address the fact that almost two-thirds of Black students are not achieving at grade level in reading and math by the end of third grade.
PPS needs to do school differently if it is to hold and attract current and new students to the district. Here are five core recommendations backed by national and local evidence that will have a positive impact on learning and teaching.
First, offer pre-k in all elementary schools with before and after school childcare. Research at the state and national levels over the last 20 years has consistently shown that children ages 3 to 8 who have experienced a high quality early childhood education before entering elementary school show improved readiness for school, are better academic performers in classes, show a reduced need for special education services, have higher rates of high school graduation, and displayed improved social behaviors.
Read More
Second, have teachers stay with the same students for multiple years. Looping, the practice of matching students with the same teacher(s) for two or more years has been done for decades in the arts, music, and sports. It’s less prevalent in elementary schools and high schools for core academic classes like math, science, English and social studies.
National research studies have validated that students who stay with the same teachers that choose to loop with them for 2 or more years show improved test scores, better attendance, and higher promotion rates to the next grade. National research has documented that looping creates positive school cultures, fewer transitions for students, and increases trust in relationships with students and parents. Effective implementation of looping also improved student discipline and staff attendance.
The three other recommendations are having a full-time nurse, librarian, and social worker(s) in every school; providing a quality breakfast and lunch in each school; and hiring and supporting a quality school leader and letting them stay with that school and community for at least five to 10 years. The benefits of these should be obvious and have been verified by research.
Local proof
We know this not just from research but from local experience. All five recommendations have been in practice in Pittsburgh at City Charter High School for over 20 years, where I served as principal.
Since graduating its first class of 2006, the school exceeds all national/state averages with a 93% student attendance rate, 93 to 97% student graduation rates with significantly better teacher attendance rates than Pittsburgh Public Schools.
The school has a diverse student population that averages 58% students of color, 69% economically disadvantaged and 15% special needs. Over 80% of the school’s students live in Pittsburgh.
A better education for Black, as well as most other students, needs to be measured with academic and behavior performance measures. Schools also need a metric that measures central office support of quality, safe, and caring individual school cultures.
Another source of data to inform what needs to change within the restructured schools in the district: Watch where parents send their children to school when given a choice. Parents do not gamble with their children.
The district would be wise not to as well. Its very existence depends upon it!
Ron Sofo was the superintendent of the Freedom area school district and principal/CEO of City Charter High School.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.