When Pitts­burgh Pub­lic Schools started to “right size” in 2006, clos­ing 22 school build­ings, it aban­doned pre­dom­i­nantly Black com­mu­ni­ties, mov­ing stu­dents from their neigh­bor­hood schools to schools that were not of bet­ter qual­ity or wel­com­ing.

Many fam­i­lies with school-age chil­dren on the North­side, Ha­zel­wood, and the East End chose to sup­port the cre­ation of what they be­lieved to be qual­ity, safe, and fam­ily-friendly char­ter schools that ended up with sig­nifi­cantly larger stu­dent en­roll­ments than the schools that were closed in those neigh­bor­hoods.

But it was the school sys­tem that ef­fec­tively seg­re­gated the dis­trict when it be­gan to elim­i­nate mag­nets and move to K-8 schools.

Do­ing school dif­fer­ently

Mov­ing stu­dents to dif­fer­ent, eq­ui­ta­bly re­sourced school build­ings with the same pro­grams and school struc­tures will not ad­dress the fact that al­most two-thirds of Black stu­dents are not achiev­ing at grade level in read­ing and math by the end of third grade.

Advertise with us

PPS needs to do school dif­fer­ently if it is to hold and at­tract cur­rent and new stu­dents to the dis­trict. Here are five core rec­om­men­da­tions backed by na­tional and lo­cal ev­i­dence that will have a pos­i­tive im­pact on learn­ing and teach­ing.

First, of­fer pre-k in all el­e­men­tary schools with be­fore and af­ter school child­care. Re­search at the state and na­tional lev­els over the last 20 years has con­sis­tently shown that chil­dren ages 3 to 8 who have ex­pe­ri­enced a high qual­ity early child­hood ed­u­ca­tion be­fore en­ter­ing el­e­men­tary school show im­proved readi­ness for school, are bet­ter ac­a­demic per­form­ers in classes, show a re­duced need for spe­cial ed­u­ca­tion ser­vices, have higher rates of high school grad­u­a­tion, and dis­played im­proved so­cial be­hav­iors.

Second, have teach­ers stay with the same stu­dents for mul­ti­ple years. Loop­ing, the prac­tice of match­ing stu­dents with the same teacher(s) for two or more years has been done for de­cades in the arts, mu­sic, and sports. It’s less prev­a­lent in el­e­men­tary schools and high schools for core ac­a­demic classes like math, sci­ence, English and so­cial stud­ies.

Na­tional re­search stud­ies have val­i­dated that stu­dents who stay with the same teach­ers that choose to loop with them for 2 or more years show im­proved test scores, bet­ter at­ten­dance, and higher pro­mo­tion rates to the next grade. Na­tional re­search has doc­u­mented that loop­ing cre­ates pos­i­tive school cul­tures, fewer tran­si­tions for stu­dents, and in­creases trust in re­la­tion­ships with stu­dents and par­ents. Ef­fec­tive im­ple­men­ta­tion of loop­ing also im­proved stu­dent dis­ci­pline and staff at­ten­dance.

The three other rec­om­men­da­tions are hav­ing a full-time nurse, li­brar­ian, and so­cial worker(s) in ev­ery school; pro­vid­ing a qual­ity break­fast and lunch in each school; and hir­ing and sup­port­ing a qual­ity school leader and let­ting them stay with that school and com­mu­nity for at least five to 10 years. The ben­e­fits of these should be ob­vi­ous and have been ver­i­fied by re­search.

Advertise with us

Lo­cal proof

We know this not just from re­search but from lo­cal ex­pe­ri­ence. All five rec­om­men­da­tions have been in prac­tice in Pitts­burgh at City Char­ter High School for over 20 years, where I served as prin­ci­pal.

Since grad­u­at­ing its first class of 2006, the school ex­ceeds all na­tional/​state av­er­ages with a 93% stu­dent at­ten­dance rate, 93 to 97% stu­dent grad­u­a­tion rates with sig­nifi­cantly bet­ter teacher at­ten­dance rates than Pitts­burgh Pub­lic Schools.

The school has a di­verse stu­dent pop­u­la­tion that av­er­ages 58% stu­dents of color, 69% eco­nom­i­cally dis­ad­van­taged and 15% spe­cial needs. Over 80% of the school’s stu­dents live in Pitts­burgh.

A bet­ter ed­u­ca­tion for Black, as well as most other stu­dents, needs to be mea­sured with ac­a­demic and be­hav­ior per­for­mance mea­sures. Schools also need a met­ric that mea­sures cen­tral of­fice sup­port of qual­ity, safe, and car­ing in­di­vid­ual school cul­tures.

Another source of data to in­form what needs to change within the re­struc­tured schools in the dis­trict: Watch where par­ents send their chil­dren to school when given a choice. Par­ents do not gam­ble with their chil­dren.

Advertise with us

The dis­trict would be wise not to as well. Its very ex­is­tence de­pends upon it!

Ron Sofo was the superintendent of the Freedom area school district  and principal/CEO of City Charter High School.