The City of Pittsburgh should, argues a new activist group, be legally banned from any financial involvement with “anyone doing business with or in the state of Israel unless and until Israel ends its military action in Gaza, fully allows humanitarian assistance to reach the people of Gaza, and grants equal rights to every person living in the territories under Israeli control.”

No War Crimes On Our Dime wants Pittsburgh’s Home Rule Charter changed. The group, a “coalition of Pittsburghers” supported by the Pittsburgh chapter of Democratic Socialists of America, needed to gather 12,500 signatures from city residents by last Sunday to get their referendum on the November ballot. That’s a lot of signatures to get, especially as the people must, in a charmingly old-fashioned way, sign in person on paper.

They apparently didn’t get enough signatures, judging by the silence about the matter on their website, but props to them for trying to encourage a more moral foreign policy.

Done in our name

And for recognizing that we have some responsibility for what our government does in our name. Which has been often bloody and brutal (see for example Guatemala, Iran, Vietnam, Chile, Nicaragua). And bungling (see for example Vietnam, Libya, Afghanistan, evacuation thereof).

Advertise with us

And justified by an idea of America’s responsibilities and its privileges called “realism,” the idea that a nation may do what it has to do, within very wide and porous moral boundaries, to get what it thinks it needs. International stability, for example, or repressing threats to trade, enforcing international treaties, protecting its businesses abroad. Or even, for a while, though no one talks like this anymore, encouraging democracy in authoritarian countries.

The problem is that “realism” sounds so practical and pragmatic — so realistic — but depends on what people mean by their words and what kind of world they really want. It’s not an objective term, and not necessarily any more realistic than other ideas.

For example, no one opposes international stability, but what do the “realists” mean by “stability”? We foreign relations layman assume it means the nations get along and act predictably, and no one bullies or cheats because that would upset the others.

What American realists seem to mean is a world arranged in America’s favor, particularly America’s economic favor, in part by the suppression of smaller, weaker nations, who learn not to cause trouble, that is, instability. They can boast of creating a stable world. The smaller nations pay for it.

The late Henry Kissinger was one of the most powerful exponents of realism. He understood a “realistic” American foreign policy in a way that led him to support actions most people would call at best amoral, which almost always means in effect immoral. If you don’t care if you’re doing the good thing, you’ll usually do the bad thing because it’s easier and works better (by your definition of works).

Advertise with us

Realistic overthrows

The overthrow of the democratically elected socialist government of Chile is one famous example. Salvador Allende’s government wanted to restructure the heavily unequal economy in a way that threatened American business interests.

The American-sponsored coup led, to Kissinger’s satisfaction, to a pro-American military regime that kept the nation safe for American investments. It also led, to Kissinger’s indifference, to the horribly brutal regime torturing and killing and “disappearing” thousands of their own people, and entrenching the economy inequality even more.

When he died at 100 eight months ago, the world praised him. Maybe that just shows you can be forgiven anything if only you outlive the memories of your victims and spend your last decades serving powerful interests and being good copy for publications like Vanity Fair. I’m old enough to feel how bizarre it is that Kissinger became the feted figure he did.

Whatever you think of the coalition of Pittsburghers’ judgment about Israel, they deserve thanks for raising the question of what is being done with our money in our name. That’s not a question most people think to ask.

Foreign policy is something that happens literally somewhere else, and that most of us only notice when something very big happens, like Saudi terrorists attacking New York or America invading Iraq and Afghanistan.

Advertise with us

Even Ukraine has faded from attention, because we’re just giving them money and not (for now) doing anything ourselves. Almost everyone has forgotten our disastrous exit from Afghanistan. Had Joe Biden continued running for president, he would have paid no political price for it. Most of America, I think, was just relieved to get it over with and save the money.

Props to them

So, again, props to No War Crimes On Our Dime. Not many people, certainly not enough, think of foreign policy as a moral enterprise — outside occasional spasms of apparent altruism, like the hope of spreading democracy, which usually end badly. (See for example Iraq.)

But I have a question for the coalition: Why Israel? Or rather, why only Israel? I understand opposing the way Israel is waging its war on Gaza, and the way settlements spread across the West Bank and the whole history of Israel’s relation to the Palestinians.

But whatever criteria they apply to Israel should apply to other countries as well. China, most obviously. If they think Israel is so bad the City of Pittsburgh must break financial ties with anyone who has ties to Israel, they ought to think the same about China, for their brutal treatment of the Uyghurs and other minorities, among other sins.

A moral foreign policy is hard and costly, but it only works if it’s principled and comprehensive. It’s not moral if it’s selective in its targets. That’s just politics with moral language.

David Mills’ previous column was “You’ll never be Simone Biles, but you can definitely not be Matt Walsh.”