Pittsburgh’s mayoral primary campaign has reached its final month, with voters heading to the polls May 20.

The Post-Gazette has covered every moment in the highly competitive race, from Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor announcing that he would challenge Mayor Ed Gainey in the Democratic primary, to Tony Moreno and Thomas West entering the Republican primary, to the many debates and candidate forums since.

Because of the voter registration advantage Democrats have in the city, a win in the November general election for Mr. Moreno or Mr. West is unlikely. Mr. O’Connor and Mr. Gainey are locked in a tightly contested primary that has featured significant fundraising efforts and pointed verbal jabs.

Read the PG’s coverage of the race over the last five months below.

Advertise with us

May 8, 13: GOP candidates spar, attack Democrats in final two debates

Tony Moreno and Thomas West, the Republican candidates for Pittsburgh mayor, participated in two debates in the lead-up to the primary election, taking jabs at each other’s campaigns while also railing against Democratic policies.

In the May 8 debate, they outlined their visions for the city. Mr. West criticized Mr. Moreno for having switched parties after losing in the Democratic primary in 2021 against Mayor Ed Gainey, and Mr. Moreno clapped back that Mr. West wouldn’t have been on the debate stage if he hadn’t run in 2021.

In the debate May 13, the GOP candidates said the city’s long history of Democratic leadership has failed when it comes to public safety, economic development, business innovation and other issues.

———————————————

May 1: Outside influences in the race for Pittsburgh mayor

Running a successful campaign for office often requires the use of a dirty word in politics: coordination.

Advertise with us

Candidates and staffers have to be on the same page as active supporters or messaging get lost on their way to the undecided voters. But all that coordination can be a slippery slope into violating election laws. 

Read Hallie Lauer’s PG Politics newsletter for more on redboxing and outside influences in the race.

———————————————

April 29: Candidates tackle transit funding, climate change at forum

All four candidates for mayor of Pittsburgh took the stage Tuesday for a forum where they touched on topics ranging from public safety to climate change.

It was one of the few times the Republican candidates — retired police officer Mr. Moreno and small business owner Mr. West — appeared on the stage and in front of voters together. But Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor have been appearing regularly in debates and forums together for the past few months.

Advertise with us
Tony Moreno and Thomas West made a rare appearance on the same stage at the forum. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The two Democrats appeared more cordial than at previous debates that have recently aired.

Amid proposed service cuts to Pittsburgh Regional Transit due to budget deficits, the candidates were asked what they would do to help the county-managed agency.

Ed Gainey and Corey O’Connor appeared more cordial at the forum than they had been at recent debates. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Mr. Gainey, who attended a rally Tuesday afternoon protesting the proposed cuts, cited his history of working on transportation bills when he was a state representative. He also said that he has been in touch with state delegates to try and find ways to fund mass transit.

Mr. O’Connor also promised to fight for money from the state to maintain PRT.

Read more about what all four candidates said at the forum.

Advertise with us

————————————————

April 25: No endorsement from Gov. Shapiro — yet

Pennsylvania’s popular governor Josh Shapiro has been noticeably silent on Pittsburgh’s mayoral race. When directly asked by the PG in March about who he would support, he didn’t answer.

Gov. Josh Shapiro has not made an endorsement in the race for Pittsburgh mayor. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Mr. Shapiro has made many endorsements in the past, but political experts say there are various reasons why the state’s highest-ranking Democrat might stay out of the primary between Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor — whether because he’s not sure who will win or because he doesn’t want to unduly influence a race between two members of his party.

Read the story.

————————————————

Advertise with us

April 22: Debate touches on affordable housing, public safety

Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor sparred in two debates within a week. The first was highly contentious, with both men talking over one another and the moderator. The second was calmer, with both candidates remaining more measured in their responses — indicating they were given advice to tone it down.

In the more subdued of the two mid-April debates, the candidates still traded barbs over topics including affordable housing, public safety and nonprofit payments.

Mr. Gainey has often cited the 1,600 new affordable housing units he claims have either been completed or are in the pipeline. During a debate the week prior, Mr. O’Connor had asked to take a walking tour of those units. Mr. Gainey proposed a time, but Mr. O’Connor posted on social media that he would not be attending just before the debate.

Ed Gainey and Corey O’Connor were calmer during their second debate in the span of a week. (WTAE)

“Last time, my opponent asked me to go on a tour to see [the affordable housing units],” the mayor said during the debate. “Now he won’t be there. Why? Because we have an affordable housing plan and he doesn’t.”

“I will not attend a campaign rally for the mayor,” the Allegheny County controller said. “Why would I go see one building?”

Advertise with us

Read more from the debate.

————————————————

April 17: Candidates clash in fiery debate

Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor traded accusations, interrupted each other and at times shouted in a debate that put both on the defensive.

Mr. O’Connor quickly set the tense tone in his opening remarks, criticizing the mayor for what he said was a lack of transparency about the grim state of the city’s finances, a point he reiterated several times throughout the debate.

The mayor refuted this claim and said his administration was doing an “incredible job” to ensure a strong city budget.

Advertise with us

When the topic shifted to affordable housing, tensions reached their highest.

Mr. Gainey repeatedly touted that his administration built more affordable housing units than any other in the past two decades.

Several times, Mr. O’Connor interrupted the mayor and questioned the credibility of his statements.

Read more from the tense debate.

————————————————

Advertise with us

April 9: Mr. O’Connor outraises Mr. Gainey for the third month in a row

Mr. O’Connor brought in about $257,000 during the month of March, while Mr. Gainey brought in just under $143,000. It was the third straight month the Allegheny County controller outraised his incumbent opponent.

Since January, Mr. O’Connor has raised over $1 million — most of which has come from donations of $250 or more. At least 33 donors — lawyers, doctors, business leaders — have contributed the maximum amount of $3,500, and dozens more have given close to that amount.

Those large donations, which include $16,500 from executives associated with Walnut Capital, have earned Mr. O’Connor criticism from Mr. Gainey and his supporters.

Since January, Mr. Gainey has raised a total of about $275,000, and about 5% of Mr. Gainey’s total funds come from people giving $50 or less. For Mr. O’Connor, only about 0.7% of his funds come from that category.

An increase in small donations is typically indicative of a motivated voter base and bolsters Mr. Gainey’s claim that they are a “grassroots campaign.”

Advertise with us

Read more analysis of the candidates’ campaign finance.

————————————————

April 6: Where candidates stand on taxing the city’s ‘Big 5’ nonprofits

The conundrum of getting Pittsburgh’s large tax-exempt nonprofits to pay into city services has plagued mayors for years and with no deals inked yet, it’s likely to be a problem for whoever wins the upcoming mayoral election.

City officials tend to refer to them as The Big Five: the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Highmark Health, the University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon University and Duquesne University.

Each of the Big Five has indicated that they are willing to work with the city to support the region, but still a deal remains elusive.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gainey made it a key point of his first mayoral election campaign that he would get the nonprofits to “pay their fair share.”

Earlier this year, he said he had reached a deal with UPMC where they would pay $12.5 million a year for 10 years, but UPMC said no such deal existed.

He also claimed he nailed down a deal with Highmark Health, the parent company for Allegheny Health Network, that said if all the other nonprofits agreed, they would also chip in.

Highmark Health officials maintain that this is the stance they’ve taken since before Mr. Gainey was in office.

Mr. O’Connor has advocated for directly asking the nonprofits to pay for things that align with their mission statements — for example, asking hospitals to purchase new ambulances for the city.

Advertise with us

Read more about where all four candidates stand on taxing the Big Five.

————————————————

April 2: Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor meet with Jewish community at forum

The two Democratic candidates for mayor answered questions at an event hosted by the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh.

The organization and Mr. Gainey have been at odds over a few issues in recent years and tackled those differences head-on during the event.

Mr. Gainey was pressed on why he chose not to file a legal challenge against two efforts to force the city to divest from Israel. He said that he had consulted with the city’s legal team, who assured him that it wouldn’t make it onto a ballot, and if it did, “it could not be implemented.”

Advertise with us
Ed Gainey and the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh have been at odds over a few issues in recent years and tackled those differences head on at the forum. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

He was also asked about a joint statement he released along with U.S. Rep. Summer Lee and Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato last October, recognizing the one-year mark of the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel. 

Leaders from the federation said they were “devastated” reading the statement. 

“There’s mistakes that the letter made,” Mr. Gainey said. “And I apologize for those mistakes.”

Some of the attendees were very clearly in support of Mr. O’Connor. The Allegheny County controller’s portion of the event took a more jovial tone than Mr. Gainey’s.

Read more from the forum.

Advertise with us

————————————————

March 29: Impact of Trump and D.C. politics on race for Pittsburgh mayor

On a balmy March morning, Mr. Gainey gathered with workers in Mellon Square to accept the endorsement of one of the state’s largest service employee unions. The main focus of his nearly five-minute speech wasn’t his Democratic opponent, Mr. O’Connor, or the union members crowded behind him.

Rather, it was President Donald Trump.

When voters visited Mr. Gainey’s campaign website, they were greeted with a large pop-up ad that reads in bold letters, “Trump’s advisers and MAGA operatives are working to elect Corey O’Connor.”

It’s all part of a larger pattern playing out across the country — instead of campaigning on such local issues as garbage pickup and public safety, candidates are citing national issues despite the fact that they have scant control over national policies and its local implications.

Advertise with us

Time and again, Mr. Gainey has claimed “MAGA operatives” are “trying to buy the mayor’s office” via contributions to Mr. O’Connor’s campaign, something Mr. O’Connor has constantly pushed back on.

Read more on the shadow cast by D.C. politics.

————————————————

March 27: All four candidates present campaign pitches at forum

For the first time during the primary election season, all four candidates for Pittsburgh mayor appeared on the same stage.

Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor, along with the two Republican candidates — retired police officer Tony Moreno and small business owner Thomas West — all attended a mayoral forum hosted by the National Pan-Hellenic Council of Pittsburgh.

Corey O’Connor speaks at the National Pan-Hellenic Council forum. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Read more about what they said at the forum. 

————————————————

March 20: What 2021 turnout could tell us about the 2025 primary

In 2021, just 29% of registered voters cast a ballot in the mayoral primary. Remarkably, the 57,000 votes were a high-water mark for the city’s municipal elections.

Local pundits attributed the 2021 spike in turnout to a number of things: a desire for change among the electorate after civil unrest spurred by the murder of George Floyd, easier voting systems with the proliferation of mail-in ballots and record-high turnouts in the 2020 election.

Higher-than-normal turnout is likely to continue this year, which is good for democracy at large but doesn’t necessarily give one candidate an advantage. 

Read more about voter turnout in PG city government and politics reporter Hallie Lauer’s weekly newsletter.

————————————————

March 16: Key endorsements offer windows into how Pittsburgh mayoral candidates might govern

Mr. O’Connor won the endorsement from the Allegheny County Democratic Committee over incumbent Mayor Ed Gainey by just four votes — a margin so close the committee decided to do a recount.

The Allegheny County controller’s win held up during the recount but it’s unclear if the endorsement will sway voters beyond bragging rights for the candidate.

In the past, election winners often could be predicted based on their endorsements. Party and union leadership were the deciding factors in how people would vote. Now endorsements more commonly signal how a candidate will govern. 

The endorsement itself isn’t the important part, according to Democratic strategist Mike Butler. “It was a signal of the candidate's values.”

Unions have been picking sides in the hard-fought contest between Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor. The United Steelworkers have thrown their weight behind Mr. Gainey, while Mr. O’Connor racked up a number of labor endorsements in February, including local units of the Teamsters and Steamfitters. 

Read more about the endorsements for each candidate and what they might mean.

————————————————

March 13: Impact of inclusionary zoning and affordable housing on race for Pittsburgh mayor

If there’s one thing the two Democratic candidates for mayor agree on, it’s that there isn’t enough affordable housing in the city.

The city itself is the largest owner of condemned houses, and Pittsburgh has struggled for years to convert those dilapidated buildings into livable homes.

The day before making his re-election campaign official, Mr. Gainey announced a massive overhaul to the city’s zoning code with a focus on affordable housing — some aspects of which have become hotly contested.

Residents line up to speak during a city Planning Commission hearing regarding inclusionary zoning. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The inclusionary zoning proposal, which would require a portion of new development to be set aside for low-income renters, has drawn the most attention and criticism, including from Mr. O’Connor.

It’s the main issue the two men disagree on. Mr. Gainey is for a citywide inclusionary zoning program. Mr. O’Connor thinks it should be decided on neighborhood by neighborhood.

Read more in Hallie Lauer’s weekly newsletter.

————————————————

March 6: Analyzing candidates’ comments on campaign donations

With less than three months to go until the high-stakes mayoral primary, a news conference hosted by Mr. Gainey in early March was the latest effort to try and sway voters to his side by outlining funds Mr. O’Connor got from Republican-affiliated donors.

The mayor promised to “stand against” the “meddling in our Democratic primary” by Republicans.

Mr. Gainey’s own finance reports, however, show he’s taken at least thousands of dollars from Republican contributors, including some of the same donors he singled out at the campaign event for giving to Mr. O’Connor.

The Allegheny County controller responded by outlining those similar donations that Mr. Gainey has received.

The back-and-forth between the two candidates begs the question: Do voters care about donors? The candidates sure hope so.

Read more in Hallie Lauer’s weekly newsletter.

————————————————

March 2: Where candidates stand on public safety, crime

Pittsburgh, much like other major cities across the U.S., has been grappling with fluctuating crime rates and strained relationships between the police and community members.

Pittsburgh’s next mayor will inherit a police force where recruitment can’t match the amount of officers leaving the force and despite a decrease in homicides, some residents still feel that areas of the city are unsafe.

Homicides dropped from 71 in 2022, when Mr. Gainey took office, to 42 in 2024. In recent talks, the mayor has attributed that drop in homicides to concerted efforts at the city level to increase patrols in neighborhoods such as the South Side and Downtown and a greater focus on non-police responses to calls for people dealing with addiction or mental health problems.

Pittsburgh’s next mayor will have to contend with an understaffed police force. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

But the bureau remains significantly understaffed. The city historically budgeted for 900 officers, but over the past two years has lowered that to 800. In early January, there were about 760 sworn-officers.

Mr. O’Connor was highly critical of Mr. Gainey’s record on public safety when he announced his campaign in December.

If elected, the Allegheny County controller has promised to “adequately” fund and staff public safety services and further develop the co-response program, where social workers go on calls with police where the individual is experiencing a mental health or behavioral crisis. 

Read more about what all four candidates have said on public safety.

————————————————

Feb. 23: Where candidates stand on affordable housing

The city is short thousands of housing units for its lowest-income renters. That has contributed to an increase in the number of unhoused people and also has forced people to leave Pittsburgh, further reducing the city’s population.

Affordable housing has been a large component of Mr. Gainey’s administration.

In September, he introduced legislation to amend the city’s zoning code in an effort to get more housing built. The main driver — and the most hotly contested part of the package — is an inclusionary zoning overlay. That would require any development of 20 or more units to set aside 10% of them for households that make at or below 50% of the area median income. For a family of two in Pittsburgh, that’s about $40,500 a year.

While on City Council, Mr. O’Connor voted to approve the inclusionary zoning districts in Lawrenceville, Polish Hill and Bloomfield. But he has reiterated multiple times that he doesn’t believe it is something that should be required of every neighborhood because of their vast differences.

He also said creating tax incentives and waiving certain fees could help spur the development of affordable housing “but right now we aren’t having that conversation.”

Read more about what all four candidates have said on affordable housing.

————————————————

Feb. 10: Mr. O’Connor raises nearly half a million dollars in January

Mr. O’Connor, who announced his bid for mayor in December, raked in about $465,000 during January, while Mr. Gainey’s campaign brought in just under $24,000, according to campaign finance reports.

Mike Butler, a Democratic strategist who has worked on local, state and federal campaigns, was surprised by the amount Mr. O’Connor had raised. 

”That’s just, wow,” he said. “I’ve never seen a challenger locally have a month like this. That is about a big a thumping you can give someone in fundraising.” 

Read the story.

————————————————

Pittsburgh mayoral race could be test for progressive movement

Mr. Gainey’s ascension to Pittsburgh mayor was significant for a number of reasons. 

He was the first Black man elected to the job in the city’s 261-year history; he unseated an incumbent for the first time in nearly eight decades; and he was another notch in the belt of the region’s growing progressive movement. 

The city’s Democratic mayoral primary this year could be a litmus test for how much that progressive movement has grown, or whether city Democrats remain split between a more moderate way of governing, exemplified by Mr. Gainey’s challenger, Mr. O’Connor. 

The potential division in the party comes at a time when Democrats are particularly vulnerable.

Read the story.

————————————————

Feb. 9: Huge early fundraising hauls set up fierce battle 

If Mr. Gainey’s 2021 upset victory was a David-versus-Goliath election, this year’s contest was shaping up to be a slug fest between two heavyweights.

His challenger, Mr. O’Connor, had all but erased the massive fundraising advantage that incumbents usually enjoy in re-election campaigns.

Mr. O’Connor began the year with a quarter of a million dollars in his political committee, just $18,700 less than Mr. Gainey. Both candidates came into the race with tens of thousands of dollars more than former Mayor Bill Peduto had at that time in the last election, and 10 times as much as Mr. Gainey had at the start of that race.

Read more about the early fundraising surge.

————————————————

Feb. 2: Candidates meet in first debate of primary

Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor traded verbal blows on COVID-19 relief fund spending, how the city has administered core services, economic development and more at a mayoral debate at Eddy Theatre on Chatham University’s campus in early February.

At multiple points during the debate, Mr. O’Connor said he was concerned about the financial conditions of the city. He said Mr. Gainey’s administration had gone on a “hiring spree” with more than $340 million of federal money received in response to the coronavirus pandemic, adding more than 100 people to the city’s staff when those funds could have been better spent on economic development in neighborhoods citywide and maintaining infrastructure. 

Mr. O’Connor said that unless city officials become more transparent with state funds, the city will again fall under the receivership of the state when it comes to finances, known as Act 47.

The first debate between Corey O’Connor and Ed Gainey foreshadowed the issues they would spar on throughout the campaign. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

But the mayor refuted that the city was anywhere near falling under Act 47. The city has had two lean years of budgets in order to account for declining revenues in property taxes, and he questioned whether Mr. O’Connor, as county controller, was fully transparent when he took office about the financial state of county finances.

Mr. O’Connor raised the alarm last summer on a looming structural deficit, but Mr. Gainey appeared to question that timing, as it was in the first half-year of Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato taking office. 

Read more from the debate.

————————————————

Jan. 28: Thomas West enters GOP primary

For the first time in nearly a century, Pittsburgh will see a competitive Republican primary election in the race to be the city’s next mayor.

In late January, Lawrenceville business owner Thomas West, 48 of Highland Park, became the second Republican to announce his mayoral candidacy when he launched his campaign in East Liberty.

Mr. West described himself as a “fiscally conservative, socially liberal” type of politician and focused much of his announcement on public safety.

Thomas West focused much of his candidacy announcement on public safety. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

He said a few years ago he and his partner, Adam Childers, were assaulted while walking from a parking garage to their home when they lived in Downtown. That incident opened his eyes to some of the problems in the city, he said.

Mr. West, the owner of TRIM Pittsburgh, a men’s clothing store in Lawrenceville, is the first gay candidate to run for mayor in Pittsburgh.

Read the story.

————————————————

Jan. 23: Tony Moreno announces campaign

Retired Pittsburgh Police officer Tony Moreno announced that he will once again be running for mayor as a Republican.

He announced his campaign with a message to voters: “I told you so,” he wrote in his announcement. 

“With crime rates soaring, homelessness worsening, and businesses fleeing the city, Moreno is calling for change in the wake of what he describes as a failure of leadership in Pittsburgh’s current administration,” the announcement said. 

He officially launched his campaign the next day while standing outside the Jack Stack swimming pool in Brighton Heights.

Tony Moreno called Ed Gainey and Corey O’Connor “the same person” during his official campaign launch. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

He ran as a Democrat in the 2021 Democratic primary and lost, but he garnered enough write-in votes to appear on the Republican ticket in November, ultimately losing to Mr. Gainey.

During the event, Mr. Moreno attacked Mr. Gainey and his Democratic primary opponent, Mr. O’Connor. To Mr. Moreno, there’s no difference between the candidates.

Read the story.

————————————————

Jan. 5: Pittsburgh neighborhoods south of the rivers could be pivotal to election

The more than two dozen neighborhoods south of the Monongahela and Ohio rivers could play a pivotal role in electing the city’s next leader.

Mr. O’Connor had already started looking south as a potential area to expand his voter base. When he announced his candidacy in December, he hosted a small campaign party at a coffee shop in the West End.

In a competitive primary, every vote counts — and neighborhoods that feel left behind are good areas for incumbents to see where they can do better and show challengers where they might be able to make inroads with voters, according to Mike Butler, a Democratic strategist who has worked on election campaigns in Allegheny County.

“The South Pittsburgh neighborhoods have always been quote, unquote, forgotten because they’re really viewed more as a suburb than an entity of the city,” said Caitlin McNulty, president of Brookline Together, a nonprofit that focuses on improving the neighborhood.

Read more about how neighborhoods south of the rivers could impact the election.

————————————————

Dec. 10: Mr. O’Connor announces candidacy

Along the banks of the Monongahela River in the shadow of what used to be one of the region’s most productive steel mills, Mr. O’Connor formally announced his intent to run for mayor of Pittsburgh in 2025.

“Pittsburgh, we cannot afford another four years of this administration,” he said in early December.

Corey O’Connor officially launched his campaign at Hazelwood Green in December. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Two weeks before, Mr. O’Connor indicated that he was “strongly considering” running, and the week prior, flyers with the banner “Corey O’Connor for Mayor” began circulating. In summer 2024, when asked about his intent to run, Mr. O’Connor never outright said he wasn’t going to run, just that he would decide after the November presidential election.

Mr. O’Connor, 40, is a Pittsburgh native and lifelong Democrat. He graduated from Central Catholic High School and received his bachelor’s degree from Duquesne University. He started his political career working for the former U.S. Rep Mike Doyle before running for a City Council seat in 2012.

Read the story.