Nearly 20 years’ worth of reports from the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority were taken down from its website, prompting calls for greater transparency in the heated mayoral race between Mayor Ed Gainey and Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor. 

Internet archives, which take randomly timed snapshots of websites, show reports dating back to 2002 on the website as of Sept. 27, 2023. By March 4, 2024, the next available snapshot of the website, the reports were gone. 

“It obviously raises some questions,” said Delaney Marsco, ethics director for the Campaign Legal Center, a Washington, D.C.-based good government group. 

Although the reports are still available upon request from the URA, their removal from the website has become a campaign talking point for the O’Connor campaign against Mr. Gainey.

Advertise with us

The annual reports detail the agency’s goals for the year and how it measured up to those goals. They show how the agency spent its money, including breakdowns for each project, how many loans the agency granted, and the overall impact its projects have had on city neighborhoods.

Without them, it’s more difficult for residents to concisely see what the URA has been doing. Much of the same information is listed in quarterly reports, but those often lack the detail and broader scope that the annual reports provide.

The URA removed the reports in February 2024 because the agency could not verify the “backup data” that was used to create them, URA spokeswoman Dana Bohince said in an email. 

“Over time, inconsistent data collection methodology, multiple reorganizations, staff turnover, implementation of new software systems, and other factors led to loss of organizational knowledge,” she wrote. 

The authority, while not directly part of city government, is a public agency that receives public funds and focuses on programs that boost economic development and assists residents with things such as homeownership. 

Advertise with us

The URA has also hired a strategic data and impact staff member who is working to standardize “how we track and report performance data and investment on an authority wide basis,” Ms. Bohince said. Those new reports are the quarterly reports published on the URA website. 

Old annual reports are still available upon request, according to the URA statement. 

“The URA is an independent agency, and the mayor does not direct how it manages its information or run its operations,” said Olga George, Mr. Gainey’s press secretary. 

While Mr. Gainey has no direct say over the authority, he appoints its board. Mr. Gainey’s chief of staff, Kyle Chintalapalli, also serves as chairman of the board. Council President Dan Lavelle, a supporter of Mr. Gainey’s re-election campaign, is vice chair. 

Former URA chair and current board member Sam Williamson also is vice president of the 32BJ branch of the Service Employees International Union. The union was an ardent supporter of Mr. Gainey’s first mayoral campaign and has donated at least $5,000 to Mr. Gainey’s re-election. 

Advertise with us

There appears to be no major leadership changes in the agency during the period of time that the reports were removed from the website. State Rep. Lindsay Powell, D-Allegheny, was appointed to the board to replace now-county Executive Sara Innamorato, but the other four board members remained the same.

The 2022 report — the most recent available on the website — shows the agency’s investment in affordable housing, the amount of business loans and grants distributed and money invested in programs for things like improving accessibility and legal assistance for renters and homeowners, among other things. 

“Transparency is essential to building and maintaining public trust in government,” said Lauren Cristella, the president and CEO of the Committee of Seventy, a Philadelphia-based good government group. “Making data publicly accessible — and keeping it accessible — helps residents understand how decisions are made and whether promises are being kept. 

“Government can only improve when it’s honest about both progress and setbacks, and that starts with a commitment to open data and transparency,” she said. “The removal of data without a clear explanation is especially concerning as it undermines the public's trust.”

Quarterly reports dating back through 2021 are still available, and board meeting minutes dating back to January 2019 and annual audits dating back to 2011 are still on the website.

Advertise with us

The removal came to light as Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor spar over affordable housing at candidate debates. 

Last week, the mayor’s administration unveiled a new data tracker showing affordable housing units in the city. The tracker shows what units have been completed, are under construction, have closed financing and others that are likely but haven’t secured funding yet. 

But the tracker only shows projects that have closed funding under Mr. Gainey’s administration, and it doesn’t differentiate between projects that were initiated under the prior administration and ones that his team facilitated entirely. 

The administration used data from the URA and other agencies, such as the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh, to create the tracker. 

A large part of Mr. Gainey’s re-election campaign has been what he refers to as 1,600 units of affordable housing that his administration has “delivered.” 

Advertise with us

The tracker shows that 500 affordable units have been completed, about 200 of which were new construction and there are about 1,000 units currently under construction. There are also about 100 units “in process,” which means the project has secured funding but construction has not begun. 

Mr. O’Connor has been critical of the tracker and Mr. Gainey’s claims on how many units have been put online during the mayor’s tenure. 

Most of the criticism boils down to how the units are being described. At some points during the campaign, Mr. Gainey has described the 1,600 units as “new,” although some were existing affordable housing units that needed rehabilitation.

More recently, Mr. Gainey has switched his claim to say the 1,600 units have been “delivered,” which refers to the completed, under construction and in process projects on the tracker.

“Mayor Gainey regularly claims he’s achieved the highest rate of affordable housing creation in 20 years,” Mr. O’Connor said in a video posted on social media. “But sometime between late 2023 and the release of his tracker, the Urban Redevelopment Authority, which oversees the majority of the housing he’s counting, deleted their last 20 years of housing reports from their website.” 

Advertise with us

The erasure of the reports removes “a comparison point,” for voters, Ms. Marsco said. 

“It prevents voters from seeing how this administration has fared with this agency versus past administrations,” she said. 

The URA said that the removal of the reports “is in no way associated with the current election season.”

“The URA’s projects and investments have always spanned across mayoral administrations,” a statement from the agency said. 

Similar transparency concerns have been raised at the federal level, as agencies like the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Department of State have had their websites scrubbed to comply with orders from President Donald Trump. 

Advertise with us

Although the URA’s removal happened before Trump was in office, it still creates the same kind of distrust among voters, according to Ms. Marsco. 

“It’s bad for democracy when governments at any level are reducing transparency,” she said. “Voters have a right to information about how their government operates.”