PG Politics is written by Hallie Lauer, the Post-Gazette's city government and politics reporter. Each Wednesday, she'll take readers inside the halls of Grant Street and deliver unparalleled reporting on Pittsburgh City Council and the race for Pittsburgh mayor. You'll also see dispatches from our reporting teams all across Western Pennsylvania, Harrisburg and Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C.
To get this content exclusively a day earlier, use this link to subscribe to the newsletter.
In the last seven days, incumbent Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey and Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor debated each other twice. While much of the content of the debates was the same, the demeanor of the men had changed significantly between the two events.
Last Thursday, WPXI-TV hosted a debate moderated by longtime anchor Lisa Sylvester. The first question of the night about the city’s finances had both men on the defensive. By the second half of the debate, they both had raised their voices and talked over one another and Ms. Sylvester.
Tuesday evening’s debate, hosted by WTAE-TV, was a bit different. During the debate, the candidates were cool and measured in their responses — even when instead of answering the questions, they hit their regular campaign talking points.
So what changed between Thursday and Tuesday? It’s hard to say exactly, but advisers for both sides likely told their candidates to tone it down.
Read More
Tuesday night’s debate had the candidates using mainly smaller quips and digs rather than outright criticisms of each other — though that also was present.
Instead of outright blaming Mr. O’Connor for underfunding the Public Works Department during the decade he was on council, Mr. Gainey turned the question around on his opponent.
“[Public Works] hadn’t been funded for like 10 years,” Mr. Gainey said during the WTAE debate. “My opponent can explain that.”
When discussing how to get payments from the city’s largest nonprofits, Mr. O’Connor threw a jab at Mr. Gainey’s announcement earlier this year about an agreement from Highmark Health that said they would be on board with a payment in lieu of taxes if the other major nonprofits also agreed. Highmark later said that was the same stance they’ve held for six years.
“We have to hold our nonprofits accountable, but you need a leader who’s going to be direct, sit down and meet with our nonprofits,” Mr. O’Connor said. “Not come up with a press release after press release saying ‘Oh, we’re close.’”
Debates typically are less about the policy and more about swaying public perception of the candidate. It’s not so much what they’re saying, but how they’re saying it.
Look at the first televised presidential debate in 1960, which many believe helped Richard Nixon lose the race because of his performance against John F. Kennedy. Nixon was sweating profusely underneath the television lights, and the black-and-white television screen highlighted his facial hair and caused his gray suit to blend into the background and match his skin tone.
Kennedy, on the other hand, looked cool as a cucumber, people said. Nixon recovered part of his image in the three subsequent debates but lost the election that year.
As for the Pittsburgh debates — and the race broadly — there isn’t a clear front-runner. The candidates are so similar on so many topics, and even in how they presented themselves.
If you ask supporters of each of the men, they’ll claim their candidate “won” the debate, which in a perfect world would mean they articulated their policy points in a way that showed voters how exactly they would govern.
In reality, neither Mr. Gainey nor Mr. O’Connor strayed from their previously outlined campaign points. Even in the question about why they loved Pittsburgh, if voters have watched any other debate or candidate forum, they’ve heard all these answers already.
So “winning” the debate most likely means people liked the way the message was delivered, regardless of what was said.

Fetterman, Duckworth lead letter blasting Trump admin's ban on transgender military service
WASHINGTON — U.S. Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania continues to pressure the Trump administration on transgender policy, joining more than a dozen Democrats in a letter to the Pentagon on Tuesday condemning an executive order banning transgender Americans from military service.
Mr. Fetterman and Sen. Tammy Duckworth of Illinois led the letter, directed to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, calling the ban a blatant violation of servicemembers’ rights and a move that could jeopardize military readiness and national security.
While the ban is held up through a court injunction, the lawmakers pressed Mr. Hegseth on whether the Pentagon is complying with the injunction and called on the administration to disclose whether transgender servicemembers “have been wrongfully dismissed.”
“This policy insults the service of brave Americans who believe that all people, regardless of differences, are equal and have a right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness,” the Democrats wrote.
The Joint Force faces “a recruiting crisis amid a staggering attrition rate for new troops,” the lawmakers said, with almost a quarter of Army recruits failing to complete their initial contracts since 2022.
“Our nation cannot afford to expel several thousand troops serving honorably on a baseless, hateful whim,” they added.
Just seven days after taking office, President Donald Trump issued an executive order that claimed “adoption of a gender identity inconsistent with an individual’s sex conflicts with a soldier’s commitment to an honorable, truthful, and disciplined lifestyle, even in one’s personal life.”
The order, which sparked multiple lawsuits along with many other administration policies, went on to suggest that transgender Americans lack the “humility and selflessness required of a service member.”
While Mr. Fetterman has made headlines for supporting some of Trump’s Cabinet nominees and the administration’s push to strengthen the border and deport pro-Palestinian protesters, he has remained outspoken in his critique of Trump’s efforts to erase transgenderism from the government.
“I am unapologetically pro-military — I believe in a strong, lethal military,” he said in a video after Trump’s initial executive order. “But I am also unapologetically pro the LGBTQ community. I am calling on President Trump to rescind this executive order — to allow and honor the inherent dignity of our servicemembers regardless of what their race is, what their gender is, who they love, or how they identify. A military that respects and supports all of its members is fully capable of being lethal and winning wars.”
— Benjamin Kail
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.