Pennsylvania’s infrastructure has improved in several areas in the past four years, but its overall grade from the American Society of Civil Engineers remains a C-.

The grade, which is issued every four years, is the same as it was in 2018 and 2022, despite massive national investments in infrastructure as a result of former President Joe Biden’s $3 trillion economic recovery program.

The Pittsburgh chapter of the society released the report card Tuesday during a news conference at Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission’s headquarters in the Strip District. Chapter President David DiGioia said the national investment didn’t produce as many benefits as expected because inflation increased the cost of projects as much as 25%.

“With that amount of money, I thought we might do better,” DiGioia said after the news conference. “Because of inflation and the cost of materials, that money didn’t do as much as we thought it would.”

Advertise with us

For the past year, a group of 56 civil engineers across the state rated performance in 17 categories. The grades remained the same in nine categories, went up in four and down in one. There were three new categories — broadband (C-), inland waterways (C-) and schools buildings (D) — and one category was eliminated, solid waste.

DiGioia said the categories in the study vary each review cycle based on whether a team of experts is available to do the analysis.

The state received no grades of A or F, the lowest grade was D (drinking water, stormwater, transit, wastewater and school buildings) and the highest grade was B- (Aviation, energy and hazardous waste). The grades mean: A ((exceptional, fit for the future); B (good, adequate for now); C (mediocre, requires attention); D (poor, at risk) and F (failing/critical, unfit for purpose).

The biggest increases came in energy, the condition of ports in Pittsburgh, Erie and Philadelphia, and wastewater.

In energy, the study said the state continues to be among the national leaders in natural gas, coal and nuclear power production. That led to its grade increasing two notches from C to B-, but the rating came with a warning.

Advertise with us

“Decisions made over the next five years will determine whether Pennsylvania’s energy infrastructure can overcome aging while keeping pace with a rapidly changing economy, increasing energy demands from data centers and vehicle electrification, and economic growth,” the study said.

The grade for ports also rose two spots from C- in 2022 to C+, the same grade as 2018.

“In Philadelphia, port operators are initiating regional growth with the development of a new cruise terminal and the Destination 2040 strategic plan to triple container capacity over the next 15 years,” the study said. “State and local funding is critical for maintenance and rehabilitation, as well as future growth, and is anticipated to continue into the foreseeable future.”

The condition of the state’s wastewater system, which improved from D- to D, is “slowly trending in the right direction” but there remains a $9.7 billion funding gap statewide to address all of the needed improvements, the report said.

In this area, the Allegheny County Sanitary Authority began work last month on a $1.03 billion tunnel under the Ohio River to catch stormwater and expects future tunnels under the Monongahela and Allegheny rivers to prevent sanitary sewer overflows, said Kim Kennedy, director of engineering and construction for the authority.

Advertise with us

Evaluators downgraded the state for the second straight year for the condition of its parks. The rating stood at B- in 2018 but fell a notch each of the next two times, to C+ in 2022 and two spots to C- this year.

In their report, engineers said that, “Despite increases in funding across the state, demand for both the creation of new facilities and maintenance of existing facilities is not being met.” DiGioia said staffing cuts to the federal parks system and the lack of dedicated funding for parks in general have led to the downgrade.

In other major categories, the state’s grades for roads (C-) and bridges (D+) remained the same.

For roads, the study said the state received $14 billion from the Biden infrastructure program and some projects are continuing. But overall, the state’s unmet need for road funding has increased from $8.1 billion four years ago to $17 billion.

Despite decreasing the number of bridges in poor condition every year since 2021, the state still has the sixth highest amount of poor bridges, 12.1%, which is double the national average. Engineers praised the state for using innovative construction methods such as building the new Commercial Street Bridge on the Parkway East adjacent to the old one and sliding it into place to reduce traffic disruption.

Advertise with us

Speakers including DiGioia, Pittsburgh Mayor Corey O’Connor and Rich Fitzgerald, CEO of the regional planning commission, said they are optimistic that the strong Democratic showing in state and national elections two weeks ago will lead to more transportation funding. Federal officials are facing a December deadline for reauthorizing the Surface Transportation Act, which is under a continuing resolution from September that cut about $30 billion for public transit and passenger rail service.

If a new authorization isn’t done before the end of the year, the hope is that when Democrats take control of Congress early next year a reauthorization will take place quickly with more funding.

Similarly in Pennsylvania, Republicans in the state Senate have been unwilling for the past two years to pass a complete transportation funding bill that would increase the state subsidy for public transit because about 87% of the money goes to Philadelphia and Allegheny County.

Democrats took control of the Senate in the election and now control both chambers, which should lead to a new transportation funding bill.

The ASCE study also had five recommendations for the state to improve its grade:

Advertise with us

— Provide long-term funding for roads, bridges and public transit as part of an overall mobility system;

— Increase funding for drinking water, stormwater, and wastewater to improve the water system;

— Develop and implement better routine maintenance to extend the life of infrastructure;

— Expand training programs, improve wages and working conditions, and educate the public about infrastructure careers to cover expected workforce reductions due to retirements;

— Incorporate greater use of technology such as artificial intelligence to improve performance.

In its national report card last year, ASCE gave the country’s infrastructure a C, the second straight cycle in which the grade improved. That was the first time for two straight improvements since the assessment began in 1998.