In the summer of 2022, Pittsburgh’s South Side neighborhood had a public safety problem.

An uptick in shootings and an increase in general unruliness from visitors concerned residents, who came together to plead with the city for help.

Ultimately, after months of community meetings and calls to the mayor’s office, they received the help they wanted. The city created a patrol program, and the results have been promising.

But without that initial push from the residents, Jacky Kaiser, president of the South Side Community Council, doesn’t believe anything would have changed. “It was us making relentless requests,” she said. “I don’t think it would’ve gotten done unless we stood up and told them we needed help.”

Advertise with us

As Mayor Ed Gainey prepares for a competitive Democratic primary election in May, the more than two dozen neighborhoods south of the Monongahela and Ohio rivers could play a pivotal role in electing the city’s next leader.

Ms. Kaiser said the residents were thankful for the help and happy with the resulting decrease in crime, but she believes the results were mostly because the residents united and urged the city to step in.

It’s just one example of how people who live in those neighborhoods feel that progress doesn’t happen for them without heavy involvement from community groups, which are largely run by volunteers.

Mr. Gainey’s challenger in this year’s mayoral race, Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, has already started looking south as a potential area to expand his voter base. When he announced his candidacy in December, he hosted a small campaign party at a coffee shop in the West End.

“He understands that the south and southwest have been neglected for far too long,” City Councilman Anthony Coghill said at the event. Mr. Coghill represents Beechview, Brookline and other communities in that area.

Advertise with us

In a competitive primary, every vote counts — and neighborhoods that feel left behind are good areas for incumbents to see where they can do better and show challengers where they might be able to make inroads with voters, according to Mike Butler, a Democratic strategist who has worked on election campaigns in Allegheny County.

About 47,000 people live in Pittsburgh neighborhoods south of the rivers, according to recent census data. The city has about 166,500 registered voters total, but turnout in off-year elections tends to be low. In the 2021 primary, about 57,000 votes were cast in the mayoral election citywide.

“The South Pittsburgh neighborhoods have always been quote, unquote, forgotten because they’re really viewed more as a suburb than an entity of the city,” said Caitlin McNulty, president of Brookline Together, a nonprofit that focuses on improving the neighborhood.

Because those neighborhoods “don’t bring in a lot of revenue” and aren’t “problematic in a lot of ways,” city officials tend to focus their efforts and attention on other areas, she said.

It’s a problem the residents have lamented for years, spanning mayoral administrations. But with an election on the horizon and promises made by the current administration that residents feel haven’t come to fruition, people seem to be more frustrated with the years of city impassivity.

Advertise with us

“We don’t get a lot of funding or resources, support from the city, and that’s been the same for all time,” Ms. McNulty said. “In the current administration, that has gotten worse.”

Unfulfilled promises

In the 2021 primary, Mr. Gainey beat former Mayor Bill Peduto in only two wards south of the rivers — the 30th and 18th that include the Beltzhoover and Knoxville neighborhoods. In some areas, like the 19th Ward, Mr. Gainey trailed by more than 12%, while in the 30th Ward, he led with about 51% of the votes to Mr. Peduto’s 31%.

The 19th Ward stretches from Mount Washington through Beechview to the edge of city limits. In the 2021 election, the 19th Ward had the second highest voter turnout, behind only the 14th Ward in the East End.

If voter turnout this year is similar to 2021, winning the wards in South Pittsburgh won’t give a candidate enough of a cushion to carry the election, but it could give him a boost.

Candidates have to determine “which wards really move the needle,” Mr. Butler said. “That’s where you want to concentrate resources.”

Advertise with us

In the South Pittsburgh neighborhoods that were unfavorable to Mr. Gainey in his first mayoral election, residents this year think he has ground to make up.

“There were a lot of promises made to have things be better and nothing has improved,” Ms. McNulty said.

Some of those promises include having all 90 neighborhoods represented equally and getting equal attention from city officials, Ms. McNulty said. Mr. Gainey in both elections and throughout his time as mayor has often referred to his administration’s goals as “building a city for all.”

But other promises, such as improving snow removal, infrastructure and general city services, are problems that still plague residents city-wide, Ms. McNulty said.

Though she helps run Brookline Together and works in Brookline, Ms. McNulty lives in the East End and says some of those same issues are on that side of town as well.

Advertise with us

“There are big problems and it’s not just because of this administration. It’s years and years of neglect,” she said. “This is not a new problem, it’s just that people are more frustrated when somebody says, ‘We’re going to come in and change something,’ and no change is happening.”

Warrington Avenue in Allentown is seen Thursday, Jan. 2, 2025. As Mayor Ed Gainey prepares for a competitive Democratic primary election in May, the more than two dozen neighborhoods south of the Monongahela and Ohio rivers could play a pivotal role in electing the city’s next leader. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Even if some areas, such as Downtown, are seeing a boost in development and a renewed focus on issues there, public safety and economic development problems don’t stay within neighborhood borders.

South Side is just a mile from Downtown and deals with many of the same issues, “but without the same support,” Ms. Kaiser said.

She pointed to the $600 million investment Downtown will get as part of a 10-year revitalization plan. The money is coming from a variety of sources, including state and city funding and contributions from local foundations and all three professional sports teams.

There’s some level of public and private partnership in South Side, but much of it is driven by community organizations.

Advertise with us

South Side Community Council applied for and received a grant from the Hillman Family Foundations to help fund a main street manager who will be tasked with helping to bring — and keep — businesses there.

“If we weren’t doing this, nobody would,” Ms. Kaiser said. “I would love to see money coming back into all these [South Pittsburgh] neighborhoods for things like public safety, trash pickup and more entertainment opportunities.”

Mr. Gainey’s campaign did not respond to request for comment.

Winning over voters

All three City Council representatives from the southern neighborhoods attended Mr. O’Connor’s campaign event, but haven’t formally endorsed yet.

The campaign event at Cafe 412 in East Carnegie was likely a strategic decision, according to Mr. Butler.

Advertise with us

“People typically use their announcement as kind of a symbolic choice,” he said. “If he’s picked a geographic [area] that he thinks is ripe for him to gain in, that could be where they see a real pickup opportunity for themselves.”

Despite winning the majority of the South Pittsburgh wards, Mr. Peduto lost the 2021 primary. But Mr. Gainey won with less than 51% of the vote. He took 46.4% of the vote to Mr. Peduto’s 39.2%. A third Democrat, Tony Moreno, received the rest of the votes.

That shows the O’Connor campaign that there are votes to be had, in South Pittsburgh and across the city, Mr. Butler said.

Many of those who attended the coffee shop announcement — ranging from current and former city employees to residents just curious to hear more from a new candidate — lauded Mr. O'Connor for starting his campaign there.

“I want to acknowledge how important it is that we have a mayoral candidate announcing his candidacy here, south of the river,” City Councilman Bob Charland said at the event. “[Mr. O’Connor] understands that Pittsburgh is all 90 neighborhoods.”

Advertise with us

The visibility of candidates in these neighborhoods could go a long way when it comes to the May primary.

To get their vote, candidates need to “show up. Show that you care,” Ms. Kaiser said. “Talk to people and actually listen, don’t just tell them what they need.”

Ms. Kaiser said that personally, she wants a mayor who forges connections with the communities and understands their problems.

“For South Pittsburgh, a candidate needs to get out here and listen to the issues,” she said. “The problems here are not the same as the East End or the North Shore.”