On a balmy March morning, Mayor Ed Gainey gathered with workers in Mellon Square to accept the endorsement of one of the state’s largest service employee unions. The main focus of his nearly five-minute speech wasn’t his Democratic opponent, Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, or the union members crowded behind him.
Rather, it was President Donald Trump.
“We made sure we stood together, particularly when Trump was talking about ICE, DEI, Department of Education,” Mr. Gainey told the crowd. “We want to make sure we continue to do that as Trump’s operatives want to mingle in the Democratic primary.”
Mr. Gainey referred to Trump, billionaire Elon Musk or MAGA nearly a dozen times in the brief address. In the past month, more than a quarter of Mr. Gainey’s posts on his personal account on X have mentioned either Trump, Mr. Musk or MAGA, or a combination of all three.
When voters visit Mr. Gainey’s campaign website, they are greeted with a large pop-up ad that reads in bold letters, “Trump’s advisers and MAGA operatives are working to elect Corey O’Connor.”
It’s all part of a larger pattern playing out across the country — instead of campaigning on such local issues as garbage pickup and public safety, candidates are citing national issues despite the fact that they have scant control over national policies and its local implications.
Read More
“The mayor has an intra-party fight happening, and what he’s trying to do by nationalizing the race is to mobilize voters to his side,” said Berwood Yost, director of the Floyd Institute for Public Policy and Center for Opinion Research at Franklin & Marshall College, who has also written a book about the nationalization of local politics.
Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor will face off in the May 20 Democratic primary – the outcome of which likely will decide the next mayor of Pittsburgh, as city Democrats have a significant voter registration edge over Republicans.
Time and again over the past month, Mr. Gainey has claimed “MAGA operatives” are “trying to buy the mayor’s office” via contributions to Mr. O’Connor’s campaign, something Mr. O’Connor has constantly pushed back on.
Mr. Yost said it made perfect sense for Mr. Gainey to try to nationalize the race to get voters to think more about Mr. O’Connor’s alleged ties to Trump — which in many people would spark an emotional response — rather than have them analyze Mr. Gainey’s record.
“It’s a mobilizing tactic,” Mr. Yost said. “He’s also trying to reach voters — other Democrats — who would be concerned about having someone in office that doesn’t share some of their values … that’s really what he’s signaling, that this other candidate doesn’t share the party’s values.”
Mr. Gainey’s campaign clearly has been trying to paint Mr. O’Connor as someone who holds the same values as Trump supporters.
Most of the nationalization in the race started when Mr. Gainey held a news conference in early March to discuss campaign finance contributions Mr. O’Connor had received from Republicans.
“We are in a media ecosystem where politicians know that voters don’t have a lot of information about what’s going on at the local level,” said Dan Hopkins, a political science professor at the University of Pennsylvania. “So sometimes the best strategy for them is to connect themselves, very clearly, to a national political movement or a national political figure that can help them build their brand.”
The opposite is also true, Mr. Hopkins said. When there are particularly polarizing figures in Washington, like Trump, painting an opponent as someone who aligns with that person also sends a signal to voters.
Mr. O’Connor, at a news conference Thursday, argued again that he did not have Republican values, pointing to his “progressive” voting record, including passage of the paid sick leave act while he was a member of Pittsburgh City Council and an attempt to enact gun control laws in the wake of the 2018 synagogue shooting in Squirrel Hill.
“It shows that they’re desperate and don’t have a message,” Mr. O’Connor said, noting that Mr. Gainey had also taken money from Republican donors.
“One of the real challenges is … if voters are casting their ballots for the mayor of Pittsburgh or even the governor of Pennsylvania with an eye toward Washington, D.C., they may not actually be responding to local conditions,” Mr. Hopkins said.
It’s also the argument Mr. O’Connor has been making. Thursday, he said Gainey’s campaign efforts were simply theatrics that didn’t focus on “what the city actually needs.”
Other than rebutting claims that he has ties to Republicans, Mr. O’Connor rarely speaks of national issues. In a campaign ad, he briefly promises to “stand up to the chaos in Washington to protect Pittsburgh.”
Beyond mobilizing voters, nationalizing a local race can also be a diversion tactic, Mr. Yost said, explaining that if that’s the incumbent’s best strategy, then there are likely holes in that person’s record.
Fighting back against Trump
Mr. Gainey has often touted his record on the campaign trail, but in the past month, most of it has focused on what he’s done to “fight back” against Trump policies.
In a fundraising email Thursday, Mr. Gainey’s team highlighted the mayor’s actions “blocking Trump’s attacks on immigrants, continuing diversity initiatives, supporting our union brothers and sisters, fighting for affordable housing, and more.”
Both Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor have pledged to not work with the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency. In a time when references to diversity, equality and inclusion have been scrubbed from programs, Mr. Gainey has not taken that step at the city level. While no new diversity programs have been implemented recently, none has been removed, either, and Mr. Gainey maintains that diversity is a key part of his goals.
He recently hosted rallies with a longtime ally, U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, to push back against Trump and Musk’s plan to significantly cut the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
On Friday, Mr. Gainey signed two executive orders aimed at fighting housing discrimination.
“Trump and the MAGA machine are using executive orders to move fast and break the federal government and produce an enormous amount of human suffering in the process,” he said. “I’m using the executive orders to strengthen our own safety nets and protect our civil rights.”
The issues of immigration, diversity efforts and housing all are topics that evoke strong feelings among tuned-in voters, and that plays right into the strategy of nationalizing a local campaign.
This tactic often focuses on “hot button, emotive, sometimes identity-tinged issues,” rather than “tangible, pothole politics,” Mr. Hopkins said.
Over the past few decades, this has become more common in local elections, he added, including in Allegheny County.
When Sara Innamorato was running against former PNC executive Joe Rockey for the Allegheny County executive position in 2023, she often invoked the topic of abortion, saying she was the candidate who would protect reproductive rights.
There are few things a county executive can do to protect reproductive rights, but Ms. Innamorato was running for executive about a year-and-a-half after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade. The full impact of that decision was still unknown at the time, and it was a topic hot on the minds of voters.
Despite the growing popularity of running campaigns based on what’s happening in D.C., it also jeopardizes political accountability, according to Mr. Hopkins.
“I think in moments nationalization can provide clarity, but it also risks distorting the core issues that may lead to a world in which candidates are evaluated on issues that they don’t actually have control over,” Mr. Hopkins said.
While it might be helpful for some voters to quickly identify local candidates based on whom they align with at the federal level, not everyone is convinced.
Assata Thomas, 52 of Stanton Heights, attended a mayoral forum Thursday night, the first time she had heard from Mr. O’Connor and the two Republican candidates, retired police officer Tony Moreno and small business owner Thomas West.
The focus on Trump and federal policies by the Democratic candidates didn’t appeal to her.
“My focus is locally,” she said. “I want to know what are you going to do for the city. What’s happening at the federal level, that’s out of my hands now. I want to know what’s being done for Pittsburgh.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.