If Mayor Ed Gainey’s 2021 upset victory was a David-versus-Goliath election, this year’s contest is shaping up to be a slug fest between two heavyweights.

His challenger, Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, has all but erased the massive fundraising advantage that incumbents usually enjoy in re-election campaigns.

Mr. O’Connor began the year with a quarter of a million dollars in his political committee, just $18,700 less than Mr. Gainey. Both candidates came into the race with tens of thousands of dollars more than former Mayor Bill Peduto had at this time in the last election, and 10 times as much as Mr. Gainey had at the start of that race.

In that election, Mr. Gainey was a lesser-known state representative taking on a two-term incumbent in a city where sitting mayors rarely lose to primary election challengers from their own party — and haven’t lost to Republican candidates since the 1930s.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gainey, Pittsburgh’s first Black mayor, stormed to victory amid widespread social upheaval driven by the still-raging COVID-19 pandemic, racial justice protests across the country and a progressive wave that swept new leaders into offices throughout the region.

Four years later, he faces a well-known opponent from a politically prominent family. The son of a beloved former mayor, Mr. O’Connor spent 10 years as a Pittsburgh City Council member before being appointed to the county controller’s office by former Gov. Tom Wolf. He went on to easily win a full term in 2023.

For Pittsburghers, the O’Connor name has been a fixture on ballots for more than 30 years.

“Corey is not your traditional challenger,” said Mike Butler, a Democratic strategist who has worked on campaigns at the local, state and federal levels.

For Mr. O’Connor, trailing Mr. Gainey by less than $20,000 in cash is “a really good report,” Mr. Butler said. For Mr. Gainey, it’s “a little underwhelming.”

Advertise with us

“One of the big powers of the incumbency is being able to rack up fundraising,” he said.

The big donors

High-powered executives, business owners, contractors and union leaders who do business with the city all clamor to get the ear of a sitting mayor and will pay thousands to get into intimate fundraisers.

Mayors can also raise that money throughout their years in office, while challengers typically decide to run just months before the election, Mr. Butler said.

Mr. O’Connor started his fundraising in mid-November, and by Dec. 31 had almost matched Mr. Gainey’s cash on hand.

Advertise with us

Typically, challengers are in “pretty good shape” if they can raise 70% of what an incumbent has, Mr. Butler said. Mr. O’Connor’s haul adds up to 93% of Mr. Gainey’s total.

The money fueling the unusually large fundraising totals comes from some of the most prominent names in the region. Unlike presidential campaigns, which have access to millions of donors giving $5 or $10 apiece, mayoral candidates rely more heavily on a smaller number of wealthy donors cutting larger checks.

Mr. Gainey received thousands of dollars from people associated with the Pittsburgh Steelers, including $3,000 from owner Art Rooney II and $1,000 from executive vice president David Morehouse. He also received $5,000 from the North Side Good Government Committee, a political committee whose treasurer is Doug Stuver, vice president of finance for the Steelers.

The donations came shortly after the mayor backed the team’s bid to host the 2026 NFL Draft — and committed $1 million in city money to the event.

For Mr. O’Connor, money has flooded in from major developers including Todd Reidbord, president of Walnut Capital, who gave the challenger $3,300 — the maximum an individual can donate under city law.

Advertise with us

The real estate industry relies heavily on city agencies that approve building permits, inspect work sites and even help finance some of the largest and most expensive projects. For years, some of the region’s most prominent builders have clashed with the Gainey administration over affordable housing mandates and delays to long-planned projects.

Part of what has allowed Mr. O’Connor to keep pace with Mr. Gainey’s is that the incumbent is spending his campaign cash at a far higher rate — a potential red flag for the mayor’s re-election campaign, Mr. Butler said.

Mr. Gainey raised $432,000 last year, but spent more than $163,000 — none of which went to television ads or campaign mail pieces.

“That’s a lot of overhead for not a ton of direct communication with voters,” Mr. Butler said. “That’s an alarming burn rate.”

With the amount of money Mr. Gainey brought in, Mr. Butler said spending even $85,000 would be concerning.

Advertise with us

“You always want to be as lean as possible,” he said.

Surging donations

While these numbers “should be alarming” for the Gainey campaign, it’s still early in the race, Mr. Butler said. And the mayor has deep-pocketed supporters who have come to his aid in the past with huge amounts of outside spending.

In the 2021 election, Allegheny County Justice for All, a political committee associated with powerful Service Employees International Union, spent $350,0000 on Mr. Gainey’s behalf — making them his largest single supporter.

And Mr. Gainey has proven to be a prolific fundraiser as his political races wear on. At the start of 2021, Mr. Gainey had just $2,600 on hand to Mr. Peduto’s $186,000, but would go on to raise more than $870,000 — most of it before his win in the primary.

Advertise with us

This year, Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor have already hit fundraising numbers other candidates weren’t seeing until a few weeks out from the election — and they still have three months to go. The primary election is May 20.

The surge in donations follows a national trend of local races that are becoming ever more expensive, said Lauren Cristella, president and CEO of the Committee of Seventy, a Philadelphia-based non-profit focused on civic engagement and election issues statewide.

Voters could start seeing the effects of that flood of money in their mailboxes and on their televisions far sooner — and more frequently — than in previous years as the campaigns pour funds into political advertising, Ms. Cristella said.

While aggressive advertising hasn’t started yet in the mayor’s race, Mr. Gainey’s team has been following the playbook Democrats used in the presidential election, relying heavily on email and text banking to solicit dollars from supporters.

In a campaign email Thursday afternoon, Mr. Gainey’s team warned that Mr. O’Connor was “trying to buy the mayor’s office.”

Advertise with us

The email also noted that “fundraising numbers are neck and neck — meaning we need to gain momentum right now.”

“I think what we're seeing is that local campaigns are getting more sophisticated and doing a better job of capturing the attention that our national elections get,” Ms. Cristella said.

For mayoral candidates in Pittsburgh, raising so much money early in the race can be crucial because of the election’s tight timetable. In a city where Democrats outnumber Republicans five to one, the winner of the Democratic primary has determined who will lead the city in every election dating back almost a century.

Republicans are likely to generate more interest this year, as candidates battle for the GOP nomination in the party’s first contested mayoral primary in decades, but the November election will still be heavily tilted in favor of whichever Democrat wins in May, said Joseph DiSarro, a political science professor at Washington & Jefferson College and a Republican.

“I don’t know that a Republican will have much impact on this race,” he said. “The votes just aren’t there to have a Republican win this election.”

Advertise with us

So far, two Republicans have announced their candidacies: retired police officer Tony Moreno, of Brighton Heights, who ran against Mr. Gainey in the Democratic primary in 2021 and lost, but earned enough write-in votes to run as a Republican in the fall; and political newcomer and small business owner Thomas West, of Highland Park.

Neither Mr. Moreno nor Mr. West is required to submit campaign finance reports yet because they announced their campaigns after the first of the year. Their first reports — and the next glimpse into Mr. Gainey’s and Mr. O’Connor’s finances — will come at the next filing deadline, April 8.

Editor’s note: This story was updated to correct the maximum amount of money strategists suggest candidates should spend based on the amount of money raised.