Pittsburgh’s school district pressed its case Friday for a property reassessment in Allegheny County, claiming that it is losing millions of dollars because of a “broken” and “unconstitutional” system.
But the visiting judge presiding over the district’s lawsuit to force a revaluation raised pointed questions about whether the taxing body had the right to bring the litigation — one of the chief arguments made by the county in seeking to have the complaint thrown out.
The nearly 90-minute argument before visiting senior Judge Kenneth Valasek of Armstrong County in Common Pleas Court played out in the heart of Downtown, where taxable property values have plunged by more than $500 million as a result of assessment appeals.
That has forced the district, the city, and the county to shell out millions of dollars in tax refunds and to finds ways to cover revenue shortfalls in the years ahead.
School attorneys noted that one of those reductions occurred just two weeks ago, when the taxable value of BNY Mellon Center a block from the courtroom was slashed by $90.2 million.
Such cuts, school district lawyer Lee Dellecker told Judge Valasek, are having a “devastating multimillion impact that keeps snowballing.” He estimated that the Pittsburgh Public Schools has had to issue $22 million in tax refunds over the past three years because of appeals and plunging property values.
Read More
Those refunds and value cuts are the result of an unconstitutional and inequitable assessment system and it’s one the county has a duty under the law to fix, the district argued Friday.
“The system is broken,” declared Megan Turnbull, another school district lawyer.
Whether the lawsuit advances could turn on whether Judge Valasek determines that the district had standing, or the right, to bring the litigation.
In filing preliminary objections to dismiss the complaint, the county contended that the school system, as a taxing body, did not have legal standing to demand a reassessment.
It maintained that the district can account for any budgetary shortfalls resulting from assessment appeals and refunds by raising taxes. It also has asserted that the current assessment system is equitable in the sense that it treats all taxing bodies the same.
Judge Valasek himself raised the question of standing. He also asked whether the state constitution’s uniformity clause as it relates to property assessments was designed mainly to protect taxpayers.
At one point he asked who would have standing to bring a lawsuit to force a reassessment. “A taxpayer?” he wondered.
“Exactly,” replied Virginia Scott, a county assistant solicitor. “But we don’t have that here.”
In advancing the county’s case, Ms. Scott pushed the argument that the district has the means to rectify revenue lost because of assessment challenges through tax increases or other means, including the appeals system.
“It’s not up to Allegheny County to fix their budgetary problems,” she said.
She also said that the district’s main quibble is with the massive reductions building owners in the central business district have received. Downtown accounts for nearly a quarter of the city and district tax base.
That one sector shouldn’t be the basis for a countywide reassessment, she said, adding that it’s “speculation” as to whether the district would even be in better shape financially with a countywide revaluation.
“That can’t be the basis for requiring a property reassessment,” she said.
But Ms. Turnbull argued that the district’s lawsuit was “more noble” than just an effort to generate more revenue. It involved holding the county accountable to live up to its obligations under the state constitution’s uniformity clause and equal protection provisions in the U.S. Constitution to provide a fair and equitable assessment system.
“The county does not have the right to operate an unconstitutional system,” she said.
The district, she added, spends thousands of dollars a year filing or fighting assessment appeals in a bid to correct inequities. But she stressed that it shouldn’t fall on the shoulders of taxing bodies to fix the assessment system when that’s the county’s job.
Furthermore, the district shouldn’t be required “to work around an unconstitutional system,” she said.
The commercial property reductions, the plunging common level ratio used to calculate taxable value, and other inequities are manifestations of a system that has grown “stale” since a court-ordered reassessment in 2012.
“It doesn’t work anymore,” Ms. Turnbull said.
She and Mr. Dellecker maintained that the district is also a victim of a “double dip,” with building owners Downtown getting massive reductions not only because of declining property values resulting from high vacancy rates but also because of a steep drop in the common level ratio.
The number is used in appeal hearings to account for growing inequities in the property assessment system.
But Ms. Scott countered that whatever issues the district is dealing with in terms of declining property values Downtown is more the result of the COVID-19 pandemic and its effects on the office market than the assessment system.
As for standing, Ms. Turnbull noted that taxing bodies in several other counties have sued to force a reassessment and won.
However, based on inquiries by Judge Valasek, it doesn’t appear as if anyone in those cases questioned whether those taxing bodies had the right to bring the litigation, as the county is doing in this situation.
Judge Valasek gave the county and district until Nov. 6 to file supplementary briefs in support of their arguments. He is handling the case because all Allegheny County judges recused themselves from hearing it.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.