Making good on its threat, the Pittsburgh Public Schools has gone to court to force a reassessment of all property in Allegheny County.
In a lawsuit filed in the county Court of Common Pleas, the district argued the base year system that has been in place since the last reassessment in 2012 is plagued with inequities and violates the uniformity clause of the Pennsylvania constitution.
Without any change, the lawsuit said, that system is “inherently regressive and inequitable in nature,” forcing property owners in areas where values are stagnant or declining to pay more than their fair share in taxes while those in areas where values are soaring pay less than they should.
“The inherent flaws of Pennsylvania’s broken assessment system are nationally recognized. Without any sort of statutory trigger compelling routine countywide reassessments, the task typically falls to the judiciary to order these reassessments,” the lawsuit stated.
The lawsuit was filed against the county and Executive Sara Innamorato, who so far has resisted calls for a reassessment in the midst of plunging commercial property assessment values in Downtown that have the potential to upend the city’s tax base.
In a statement issued Tuesday, Abigail Gardner, spokeswoman for Ms. Innamorato, declined comment on the litigation itself.
Read More
But she added that the county executive is “gathering data to analyze the implications of countywide reassessment.”
“Any reassessment must be revenue neutral and not a backdoor tax hike for the people of Allegheny County and should protect seniors and low-income homeowners in the process,” Ms. Gardner said.
“Ideally reassessments would be state-mandated, mundane, regular occurrences and not once-per-decade shocks to the system. Our preference is to work with stakeholders to build a more predictable system for everyone.”
’No choice’
In its lawsuit, authorized by the school board last month, the district maintained that the massive assessment reductions being received by building owners in Downtown could result in more than $10 million in refunds for the 2022 to 2024 tax years.
Those refunds could “significantly increase” as more appeals are decided by the county’s property assessment board, it stated.
“The erosion of the commercial tax base through the appeal process unfairly shifts tax liability over to residential property owners, who may end up experiencing service cuts and higher tax rates if the situation is ignored,” the lawsuit added.
In a statement issued Tuesday after the lawsuit was filed, PPS solicitor Ira Weiss said that the school district had “no choice but to take this action given the perilous financial circumstances that have been created” because of reductions ordered through appeals.
Those cuts in part are the result of a steep drop from 87.5% to 63.5% in the common level ratio, the number used to calculate taxable value at assessment appeal hearings.
“The bottom line is that the district cannot pay tens of millions of dollars in refunds. It also cannot sit idly by and watch the tax base literally disappear every time there is a wave of reductions and refunds due to the collapse of the assessment system in this county,” Mr. Weiss said.
Before filing the lawsuit, Mr. Weiss said the district had provided Ms. Innamorato with “a reasonable time” to consider its request to order a reassessment on her own.
“She has replied with the same general statements about more ‘review and study.’ The time has passed for that,” he contended.
Before Tuesday’s statement from her spokeswoman, Ms. Innamorato had said that her office was working “to gather all of the relevant data about the state of assessments in the county and engage stakeholders at the state and municipal level to create a more thoughtful and consistent approach.”
“We do not file suit against another government entity lightly,” Mr. Weiss said. “However, desperate times call for serious measures. The district needs relief and stability now.”
The district is asking a judge to immediately order the county to commence a reassessment and to set a realistic timetable for its implementation.
’Substantial inequities’
Its lawsuit is the third filed over the past 25 years to force reassessments in Allegheny County. The last two, most recently in 2009, led to court-ordered revaluations.
While both of those lawsuits were filed by individual property owners, the district stated that it has standing to bring the new litigation as a taxing authority — one directly affected by the county’s “unconstitutional assessment scheme.”
“A revenue neutral, countywide reassessment will equitably redistribute the tax burden so that everyone pays their fair share of the cost of government,” the lawsuit stated.
Mr. Weiss took issue with Ms. Gardner’s concerns about the potential for backdoor tax increases.
“To suggest that making the assessment system in Allegheny County fair and legal is a backdoor tax hike is simply misleading. School districts in Pennsylvania are limited in the year following a reassessment to the revenue level they had in the year prior to the reassessment,” he said.
The lawsuit further stated that anti-windfall statutes prevent reassessments from being used as “a vehicle for a clandestine tax increase.”
It also contended that the disparities in assessed property values throughout the county are now as bad or worse than they were when the last reassessment was ordered.
To help make that point, it cited a 2022 University of Chicago study that found 72% of the lowest valued properties in the county were over-assessed, meaning they were paying more than they should in taxes, while 53% of the highest valued homes were under-assessed, or paying less than they should.
Such disparities are contrary to the state’s constitution’s uniformity clause, which “does not tolerate the substantial inequities currently existing in Allegheny County.”
In addition, the lawsuit stated that school districts and municipalities are “facing alarming budgetary crises due to a rapidly shrinking commercial tax base,” one caused in part by high office vacancies resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic and hybrid work.
“The school district also believes, and therefore avers, that the county’s shrinking commercial tax base will shift a substantial portion of the tax burden over to unsuspecting and undeserving residential property owners in 2025 and beyond,” it asserted.
Not a quick process
Ed Hirshberg, a lawyer who specializes in real estate litigation, called the district’s lawsuit “the best option available to reset the assessment system” in the county.
He said the drop in the common level ratio and the subsequent reductions in the assessments on Downtown office buildings totaling nearly half a billion dollars has shifted the tax burden to residential property owners.
“In other words, under the current system, skyscrapers see massive tax cuts while the government props up those losses on new homeowners,” he said. “The disparate treatment of two types of property owners is simply unconstitutional.”
Should the lawsuit be successful, Mr. Hirshberg and Mike Suley, an assessment board member and former county assessment director, predicted that it would probably be two to four years before a reassessment is implemented based on past experiences.
Mr. Suley said Ms. Innamorato will be hard pressed to mount an effective strategy in court to prevent a reassessment.
“The county has no defense. The county executive has already said the system is broken. That will be used as evidence in court. I’m not a gambling man but I would say [the lawsuit’s success] is pretty much a slam dunk,” he said.
“You can go up and down any street in Allegheny County and there’s no rhyme or reason for how the properties are assessed. That comes after 12 years of neglect.”
Mr. Suley, who has overseen a countywide reassessment in the past, said that because it has been such a long time since the last one, there will be “winners and losers” among property owners with some paying more in taxes than they are now and others paying less.
“It’s painful but it has to be done,” he said.
One class of property owners that could benefit, he said, those who purchased homes only to have taxing bodies — the Pittsburgh school district being one of the most aggressive — to file appeals to raise the assessment, a practice decried as a newcomers or welcome neighbors tax. He predicted many of those homeowners will see their taxes come down.
Both he and Mr. Hirshberg said the long-term solution is to establish a system for regular, routine reassessments, as is the case in just about every other state. State Sen. Wayne Fontana, D-Brookline, is considering legislation calling for a state takeover of the reassessment function.
But Mr. Weiss said the district needs relief now.
“We cannot rely upon the mirage of future state legislation providing for state supervised reassessments or future studies,” he said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.