Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato isn’t exactly buckling to the threatened lawsuit authorized by the Pittsburgh Public school directors Wednesday to try to force a countywide property reassessment.

In a statement released Thursday by her spokeswoman Abigail Gardner, Ms. Innamorato didn’t specifically address the lawsuit.

Instead, the executive said her office is working “to gather all of the relevant data about the state of assessments in the county and engage stakeholders at the state and municipal level to create a more thoughtful and consistent approach.”

“We recognize this is a priority and are working intentionally and quickly to bring the right people and the necessary information together to make informed decisions,” she said.

Advertise with us

The statement represents Ms. Innamorato’s first comprehensive comments on the threatened lawsuit — one triggered in part by big assessment reductions that are being awarded to the owners of a number of Downtown skyscrapers and by a steep cut in the common level ratio, the number used in appeal hearings to calculate taxable value.

In the statement Thursday, the county executive — who took office in January — acknowledged that “several municipalities and school districts are concerned with dropping revenues.”

“And we need everyone to recognize that the way we’ve done reassessments has been broken for a long time. Delaying what should be a regular and revenue-neutral process into something that is avoided for a decade and then shocks the system may have massive unintended consequences for vulnerable neighbors,” she said.

City school directors voted unanimously Wednesday evening to authorize solicitor Ira Weiss to file a lawsuit in county Common Pleas Court to try to persuade a judge to order a reassessment.

They did so as they face the prospect of paying out millions of dollars in tax refunds to property owners who have won assessment reductions.

Advertise with us

In Downtown alone, assessments on 11 buildings have been slashed by $354.8 million. That could cost the three taxing bodies — the city, the county and the school district — a combined $8.1 million in refunds for just the 2023 tax year.

In addition, Pittsburgh school officials have estimated that in a worst-case scenario, the district could lose nearly $6.7 million in property tax revenue and potentially pay out $13.4 million in tax refunds for 2022 and 2023.

The losses and refunds come at a time when the school system is confronted with possible deficits of $29.9 million in 2024 and $28.9 million in 2025. Without relief, Mr. Weiss has said the district will drain its fund balance within two years.

Before filing the lawsuit, Mr. Weiss has pledged to meet with Ms. Innamorato to determine what her plans are regarding a reassessment before moving forward.

In a response Thursday to Ms. Innamorato’s statement, Mr. Weiss said the “financial peril facing the district requires more than ‘rounding up the usual suspects,’” a reference to the county executive’s pledge to convene stakeholders to develop an approach.

Advertise with us

“The district will respect the process of review by the county executive but will initiate the court action unanimously authorized by the board of public education by formal vote,” he said.

He stressed that the district will not be filing the lawsuit immediately and will “respect [Ms. Innamorato’s] process for a reasonable period of time” with no hard deadline.

But absent some agreement with the county executive, “the fact remains that under current law, the remedy which will be sought by the district is the path to a legal fair system,” Mr. Weiss said.

He added that there are anti-windfall protections that prevent the school districts or other taxing bodies from reaping more revenue from a reassessment than they received the prior year.

The school district, he continued, is “reliant on real estate tax revenue and lacks the range of tax options and revenue sources available to the county.”

Advertise with us

In her statement, Ms. Innamorato said it’s important to recognize “that behind these appeals of assessment values is more than just the urgency of a reassessment but that the economy fundamentally changed in the post pandemic recovery.”

“There has been a return of tourism to pre-pandemic levels, and other tax revenues are up. In the city of Pittsburgh building permits are up and their construction value have exceeded pre-pandemic levels. These are encouraging signs,” she said.

She also noted that there are ongoing attempts to reshape Downtown, in particular involving the conversion of older or failing office buildings into residential units.

The county has joined the city and the school district in offering one tax abatement program for such conversions and another broader one is now before city council.

Thursday’s statement added that the county budget is “in good shape” because “our budget team projected for appeals and set aside revenue accordingly.”

Advertise with us

If there is another reassessment, it would be the first in more than a decade. Mr. Weiss, acting on behalf of an individual property owner, filed a lawsuit in 2010 to force the county to do a reassessment.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com