Pittsburgh Public Schools are blasting an attempt by Allegheny County and Executive Sara Innamorato to quash its lawsuit seeking to force a property reassessment.

In a blistering 21-page response filed this week to the county’s and Ms. Innamorato’s motion to dismiss the litigation, the district ridiculed their arguments as “bewildering,” “perplexing,” and “stunning.”

The district took particular aim at their contention that it, as a taxing body, had suffered no damages under the current “broken” system and lacked standing to pursue such a lawsuit.

It countered that it has more than 22.6 million reasons for standing — the dollar amount it estimates it has shelled out in property tax refunds since 2022 as a result of assessment appeals.

Advertise with us

“In reality, the harm inflicted on the school district by the county’s outdated 2012 assessment model is abundantly obvious, profound and disturbing,” it stated.

“These massive refund obligations have had a dramatic impact on the school district’s budget, harming its ability to provide services to students and maintain its buildings.”

The district attributed part of the problem to the steep drop from 87.5% to 54.5% in the common level ratio, the figure used to calculate taxable value at assessment appeal hearings, and “the dubious decision to retroactively reopen the property assessment appeal period for 2022.”

It argued that the vast majority of the tax refunds have gone or will go to commercial property owners, including those involving many prominent Downtown buildings, which have seen their assessments slashed by nearly half a billion dollars.

The common level ratio is used as a means to account for growing disparities between taxable values and sales prices.

Advertise with us

In its response, prepared by Solicitor Ira Weiss and his law firm, the district stated that it may need to provide a buffer in its budget to “account for this unstable assessment system, where $100M office buildings can retroactively lose more than half of their assessed value overnight based on decisions issued by defendant Allegheny County’s Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review.”

It also contended the county’s “mishandling” of its assessment system not only has led to instability and massive cuts in taxable value Downtown but has shifted the burden to residential property owners.

“By shrinking the commercial tax base for 2022 and all subsequent tax years, a significant amount of tax liability has been transferred from high-value commercial properties over to undeserving residential properties in violation of the Constitution,” it stated.

It also called the challenge to the district’s standing to file the lawsuit as “frankly bewildering” given that the assessment system “determines the school district’s tax base for financing purposes.”

“As defendants are well aware, the school district primarily funds itself through the collection of real estate taxes. If that tax base is unstable, it can result in unanticipated budget shortfalls, service cuts, employee furloughs, deferred maintenance projects on school buildings, and millage rate increases on all property owners in later tax years.”

Advertise with us

It also stated that other school districts in the state, including those in Erie and Washington County, have filed lawsuits to force reassessments and won.

The county and Ms. Innamorato, in filing their preliminary objections to the lawsuit and the motion to dismiss, maintained that the district can make up for any losses resulting from assessment appeals simply by changing its millage.

They also asserted that the district has the ability to challenge inaccurate assessments through the appeals process while at the same time claiming that the school system had failed to pursue “allegations of incorrect property assessments” through that procedure.

In its response, the district stated that none of those objections “have even a shred of merit.”

Increasing real estate taxes would result in “effectively and unfairly shifting tax liability away from larger commercial property owners over to residential property owners,” it said.

Advertise with us

And the suggestion that it should appeal and litigate the assessments of all properties within its jurisdiction “is a stunning one,” in essence involving a Pittsburgh Public Schools takeover of the county’s assessment responsibilities, the district claimed.

“Even if the school district were inclined to take over the county’s role, it cannot fix a systematic problem that permeates the entire county by simply appealing and correcting assessments within its own taxing jurisdiction,” it stated.

The state Supreme Court even acknowledged as much in the lawsuit that led to the last countywide reassessment in 2012, it noted.

In seeking to have the lawsuit dismissed, the county and Ms. Innamorato also questioned whether the asserted harms suffered by the school district would be addressed by a court-ordered reassessment.

They also said that the district made no assertions in its lawsuit that the county’s assessment system treated it any differently than it did other taxing bodies.

Advertise with us

A county spokeswoman on Friday declined comment on the district’s response. In its filing, the district is asking a judge to overrule the county’s and Ms. Innamorato’s preliminary objections.

It likely sets the stage for a ruling on whether the lawsuit will proceed.

The preliminary objections and motion to dismiss filed by the county and Ms. Innamorato also asked that the latter be removed as a defendant, arguing that suing her is the same as suing the county.

But the district lobbied in its filing against removing her as a defendant.

“In her capacity as county executive, defendant Innamorato has the responsibility of overseeing the current assessment system, and has the authority to initiate, coordinate and implement a new countywide reassessment,” it stated.

“Her involvement in this lawsuit is critical, as any final order may include directions to the county executive, or will provide instructions that must be complied with by the county executive.”