A new wave of Allegheny County property assessment appeals has resulted in more than $50 million in reductions, a sign that 2024 could be another rocky year for school districts and municipalities struggling to cope with revenue losses stemming from such cuts.
County Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review members approved the $56.1 million in decreases for 2024 at their meeting Thursday. The 804 properties are among the initial batches the board has signed off on so far for the 2024 tax year.
Board member Mike Suley said Thursday’s list was the first for 2024 to include commercial properties, whose appeals have resulted in hundreds of millions of dollars in assessment reductions in the past few years after a drastic drop in the ratio used to calculate taxable value.
Of the $56.1 million in cuts approved Thursday, $36.6 million involved commercial properties. Another $19.1 million went to residential property owners.
And they could just be the beginning.
Mr. Suley said there are hundreds of 2024 commercial property appeals still in the pipeline, including some involving high-end real estate in Downtown and elsewhere.
Read More
Many of the commercial appeals have been spawned by two factors — the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, including rising office vacancies, and the steep decline in the common level ratio.
The ratio has plunged from 87.5% just a few years ago to 54.5% this year. Its drop is due in part to widening disparities between assessed value and sales prices since the last countywide reassessment in 2012.
Mr. Suley said the same thing happened in the 1990s when he also was on the appeals board before the county reassessed all of its properties in 2001.
“What this shows is the vulnerability of the base year after 12 years,” he said, referring to the 2012 revaluation. “It’s brutal.”
The falling ratio has already fueled hundreds of millions in assessment cuts for the 2022 and 2023 tax years on buildings in Downtown, including some of its biggest skyscrapers, and millions and millions more on properties in the suburbs.
While the drop in the number is generally a boon for property owners, resulting in tax cuts, it’s anything but that for taxing bodies,
Pittsburgh Controller Rachael Heisler testified during a hearing Monday exploring the need for regular countywide reassessments that the city has issued more than $7 million in tax refunds dating back to 2019.
Ira Weiss, solicitor for the Pittsburgh Public Schools, testified that the district has doled out $22.6 million in refunds over the past few years and that eight other school systems have handed out more than $20 million.
“The pattern is clear: No school district can operate with those kinds of refunds,” he said at Monday’s hearing.
In part because of the situation with the ratio, the Pittsburgh schools has filed a lawsuit seeking to force a countywide reassessment. However, the county and Executive Sara Innamorato are fighting the attempt, urging a judge to dismiss the litigation.
Dominick Gambino, a former county assessment manager, said Thursday the assessment cuts on appeal will continue until there are regular reassessments in the county, which likely would eliminate the need for the common level ratio.
“Instead of a gradual slow burn that could have been handled more easily, the voodoo and easily manipulated common level ratio has sparked the big bang due to its miscalculations by the county and the resulting abrupt correction,” he said.
Of the reductions approved Thursday, the biggest involved a building in Bethel Park owned by Jefferson Regional Medical Center. Its taxable value dropped from $11.6 million to $10 million.
In Downtown, the assessment on a 12-story office building at 4 Smithfield Street targeted for a residential conversion tumbled by $956,200 to $2 million.
While the lower ratio has not been favorable to taxing bodies, they benefited when it was higher by challenging the assessments on recently sold properties, usually single-family houses, in a practice dubbed a “newcomers” or “welcome neighbor” tax.
In all, more than 7,000 appeals — including 1,277 on the commercial side — were filed for 2024.
But unlike the past couple years when some property owners waited more than 12 months to get results because of backlogs in hearing cases, Mr. Suley predicted most 2024 appeals should be finished in two months.
That’s due in part to a lower number of cases — 11,892 were filed in 2023 — and a law passed by County Council earlier this year that requires the board to issue a decision on an appeal within 60 days and to notify the affected parties within 30 days after that.
“This is a seismic event for Allegheny County,” Mr. Suley said. “We are now equal with other counties in getting results out quicker.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com,





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.