In this day and age, it’s tough to find consensus on just about any issue. But they managed to do it at the Allegheny County Courthouse Monday — and the subject involved, of all things, property reassessments.
During a two-hour meeting in the Gold Room, local school and government officials, a county appeals board member, a realtors’ rep, an attorney and a housing advocate all pushed for the same thing: Regular reassessments, not only locally but statewide.
The calls came during a state Senate Democratic Policy Committee hearing spearheaded by Sen. Wayne Fontana to discuss Pennsylvania’s “dysfunctional property reassessment system” and the costs associated with not fixing it.
Pennsylvania is the only state in the nation that doesn’t require regular reassessments.
For those who testified, the costs are real, whether they involve growing inequities in which some homeowners pay more than they should in taxes and others pay less; school district budgets leaking revenues because of property assessment appeal refunds; or investors hesitant to make a commitment because of the chaotic nature of the system.
“The tax assessment system in this county and in Pennsylvania is broken,” said Ira Weiss, solicitor for the Pittsburgh Public Schools and a number of other districts locally.
Read More
Mr. Weiss said the Pittsburgh schools have issued $22.6 million in refunds over the past several years because of the county’s plummeting common level ratio, a number used to set taxable property value at assessment appeal hearings.
The ratio is designed to adjust for inequities in the system the longer counties go without reassessing. The last revaluation in Allegheny County was 2012.
In his testimony, Mr. Weiss noted that Pittsburgh schools aren’t the only ones suffering. He estimated that eight other school districts have issued $20 million in refunds over the past several years, including $6.9 million by Gateway and $5.3 million by Montour.
“The pattern is very clear: No school district can operate with those kinds of refunds,” he said.
Melissa Friez, superintendent of the Mt. Lebanon School District, said tax refunds have soared from $15,636 in the 2019-20 school year to more than $1.2 million, a record, last fiscal year as the common level ratio has plunged. About 75% of them involve commercial properties.
The district is projecting another $1.5 million to $1.8 million in refunds this fiscal year.
As a result of the falling CLR and commercial refunds, the district has had to raise taxes the past three years, while cutting staff, reducing allocations for supplies and services, and revising programming to be “more cost effective,” Ms. Friez noted.
“No longer should it be the sole responsibility of a school district to fix Pennsylvania’s outdated property assessment system,” she testified.
City Controller Rachael Heisler, whose office has warned Mayor Ed Gainey that Pittsburgh could be facing a “fiscal cliff” in part because of declining property tax revenues, testified that the city has issued more than $7 million in refunds dating back to 2019.
“While some of these refunds are driven by the rapid changes facing property owners in Downtown, the bigger story should be that the current system is slow, protracted and ultimately unfair as it disproportionately benefits those who have the resources to file appeals,” she said.
Ms. Heisler also maintained that the current system hinders new development at a time the city needs to be expanding its housing stock and attracting more people.
Others focused on how the lack of routine reassessments — and the reliance on appeals to increase values on recently sold properties, sometimes referred to as the “newcomers tax” — creates huge inequalities in neighborhoods and even on the same street.
John Petrack, executive vice president of the Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh, said he knows of two identical homes on the same street in Ross where one owner pays $3,800 a year in taxes and the other pays $5,700 because the school district challenged the assessment on the latter but not the first.
“Our current irregular assessment system continues to harm Pennsylvania residents,” he said.
David Vatz, chapter lead of Pro-Housing Pittsburgh, cited another example of a Bloomfield house purchased in 2018 for $220,000 and still assessed at $48,000. Meanwhile, a house purchased on the South Side for just under $300,000 in 2021 ended up being reassessed to nearly $206,000.
The second homeowner, he pointed out, pays more than six times as much in property taxes even though the house is only 36% more expensive than the first.
“It may seem obvious from this anecdote, but this is not a fair system,” he said. “Why should some people pay unfairly high taxes while others get to skate by with an assessment that’s way too low?”
Mike Suley, a county assessment board member and former assessment director, said typically residents in lower-income neighborhoods pay more than their fair share in taxes as their property values decline, while those in wealthier neighborhoods pay less as their values increase.
As for solutions, Sharon DiPaolo, a partner in the Siegel Jennings Co. law firm who specializes in property appeals, believes assessments should be updated every three years,
She urged the committee to consider adopting a system similar to Ohio, which does a full countywide reassessment every six years, with a statistical update every three years.
Mr. Weiss called for reassessments every five years, with a “trending adjustment” every three years. And Mr. Suley argued for reassessments every three years with every single property in the county reviewed every six years.
Without the will to make such changes, “reassessment on appeal will continue to offer taxpayers and taxing jurisdictions instability, confusion, and angst,” Mr. Suley said.
The question is whether the state General Assembly will go for such reforms.
Property reassessments are a political hot potato, about as attractive to local and state politicians as gum disease.
But Ms. DiPaolo said that in her travels throughout the state she senses a change in attitude among various stakeholders.
“I can tell you that more than ever right now there's something different in the air. There is the will and momentum and need for change,” she said.
A former county councilman, Mr. Fontana of Brookline is aware of the hurdles ahead of him. “We realize this can’t be solved overnight, so we have to keep working at it,” he said at the conclusion of Monday’s hearing.
He intends to hold at least one more hearing on the subject. He has won an ally in Katie Muth, a Chester County senator who chairs the Democratic Policy Committee and who attended Monday’s hearing.
“As we heard today, we know that we definitely need to change the system so that Pennsylvania has fair and equitable property tax,” she said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.