Amid the turmoil engulfing Allegheny County’s property assessments, a state senator is launching his push to require routine revaluations in a bid to eliminate many of the inequities now plaguing the system.

Sen. Wayne Fontana, D-Brookline, plans to host the first of at least two Senate Democratic Policy Committee hearings on Monday to discuss the state’s “dysfunctional property reassessment system” — as an invitation to the hearing puts it — and ways to fix it.

Mr. Fontana is hoping to use the hearings as a platform to craft legislation to require regular reassessments in each of the state’s 67 counties.

“This will be about why we need it and why we should do it.” the senator said of the first hearing, which will be held in the Allegheny County Courthouse Gold Room at 1 p.m.

Advertise with us

He will be joined by Katie Muth, a Chester County Democrat who serves as chair of the policy committee.

Mr. Fontana first pitched the idea of requiring counties to do routine reassessments in March after the Pittsburgh Public Schools announced plans to file a lawsuit to force Allegheny County to do a revaluation amid plunging property values in Downtown.

At the time, he urged the district to hold off to allow local and state stakeholders to craft short- and long-term solutions to address the assessment tumult in the county.

Although the district ended up filing the lawsuit in April, Mr. Fontana still believes one of the keys to reforming the system not only here but statewide is regular reassessments.

The invitation to next week’s hearing stated that 50 of the county’s 67 counties have not done a reassessment in the past 15 years. The last one in Allegheny County was done in 2012.

Advertise with us

“Pennsylvania has become the example of how not to administer a reassessment system. This hearing will explore how the commonwealth’s dysfunctional property reassessment system is burdening local government, complicating school district budgets, and costing taxpayers money,” the invitation stated.

In an interview, Mr. Fontana said that Pennsylvania is the only state in the country that does not have a mandate for regular reassessments.

He noted that in a perfect world, he would like to see counties required to do reassessments every three years. But he’s also aware of the political realities, with most legislators treating reassessments like poison ivy — something to be avoided.

“To get the state to do it legislatively, it’s a major mountain to climb,” he acknowledged, adding that one issue the hearings will explore is how other states made routine reassessments the norm.

Mr. Fontana said the first hearing next week will focus on why regular reassessments are needed. The second one, likely in Harrisburg this fall, will concentrate on how to get it done and how to help counties pay for it.

Advertise with us

The committee at some point may also explore possible alternatives to property taxes — such as the income tax or users fees — an age-old topic that never seems to get anywhere in the General Assembly.

Among those expected to testify at the first hearing are Mike Suley, a county assessment board member and former assessment director; Ira Weiss, solicitor for the Pittsburgh Public Schools; realtors; and officials with the state tax equalization board, or STEB.

STEB is the agency that annually sets for each county the common level ratio, the number used in assessment appeals hearings to calculate the taxable value of a property.

The ratio has become a big issue in Allegheny County. It has dropped from 87.5% to 54.5% in recent years, triggering thousands of appeals by property owners on both the commercial and residential side looking to lower their tax bills.

Downtown, the reductions have totaled nearly half a billion dollars and have cost the school district, county, and city of Pittsburgh more than $8 million a year in tax revenue. The declining tax base was a big factor in prompting the district to sue for a reassessment.

Advertise with us

Mr. Fontana said there is no doubt in his mind that regular reassessments will help to restore fairness and equity in the system. The current flaws end up creating concerns about spot assessing and requiring the use of the common level ratio to equalize values, he argued.

“If we do reassessments consistently, you don’t have spot assessments. You don’t have the common level ratio. That goes away,” he said.

After gathering information at the hearings, Mr. Fontana said he’s hoping to introduce legislation next year to require regular reassessments. He said he would use the hearings as a guide in determining what approach to take.

He noted that if the legislature itself is reluctant to order them, he may look for some other means — perhaps by giving STEB or another entity the authority to require them on behalf of the state.

“We need to do it. We should do it. It costs us not to do it,” Mr. Fontana said of regular reassessments.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.