Allegheny County and the county executive won’t submit to a county-ordered property reassessment without a fight.

In an 18-page filing in Common Pleas Court, the county and Sara Innamorato are urging a judge to throw out a lawsuit filed by the Pittsburgh Public Schools seeking a reassessment, claiming the district doesn’t have standing to pursue such litigation.

The preliminary objections and motion for dismissal mark the county’s first formal response to the lawsuit, which was filed in April. Since then, Ms. Innamorato has sent mixed signals about her intentions regarding a countywide reassessment.

In the lawsuit, the district maintained that the base year system for assessing property in place since the last countywide reassessment in 2012 was plagued with inequities and violates the uniformity clause of the Pennsylvania constitution.

Advertise with us

However, the county and Ms. Innamorato took aim at that contention in their response, arguing that the school district, as a taxing body, doesn’t have standing to challenge the uniformity of valuations.

Despite the lawsuit’s contention that assessment reductions involving Downtown skyscrapers could cost Pittsburgh Public Schools more than $10 million in refunds for the 2022 to 2024 tax years, the county maintained that the district has suffered “no damages” under the current system.

It and Ms. Innamorato pointed out in their response that the district can adjust the “tax burden on property owners within its jurisdiction through changes in its millage.”

The district also can file appeals to challenge property assessments it believes are inaccurate, the response stated. It contended that the district failed to pursue “these allegations of incorrect property assessments through” the appeals board “as required by law.”

“To the extent the school district is ‘harmed’ by Allegheny County’s current assessment system, it is pure speculation that any court-ordered reassessment would address this claimed harm,” it added.

Advertise with us

The county and Ms. Innamorato also asserted that the lawsuit was “overly broad” in the sense that it is seeking a countywide reassessment when the district’s “only legal interest can be properties within the limits of the city of Pittsburgh.”

They also insisted that the district makes no assertions in the lawsuit that the county’s “assessment model treats it any differently than any other taxing bodies.”

“The effect of the school district’s request that the county conduct a reassessment of all properties within all of the county’s 130 municipalities is an abstract interest akin to a request for general compliance to the law no greater than an ordinary citizen,” the filing stated.

Ira Weiss, the school district’s solicitor, said in response to the county and Ms. Innamorato’s filing that it “is beyond dispute that the assessment system is broken in this county and this will only delay the necessary relief that is owed to all stakeholders in the assessment process.”

As for the question of standing, Mr. Weiss said the relevant assessment laws contain specific provisions that both property owners and taxing bodies have “an equal right to participate in the appeals process.”

Advertise with us

He added that the district “has been injured and will continue to be injured by the plummeting common level ratio, which is due to the failure to reassess.”

In Allegheny County, the ratio, used to calculate taxable market value at assessment appeals hearings, has plunged from 87.5% to 54.5% over the past few years. Because of that, the district has issued $22 million in refunds over that time, Mr. Weiss said.

“So we think we have 22 million reasons to have standing,” he said.

In terms of using assessment appeals to address inequities, Mr. Weiss said it is “very well settled that you cannot appeal your way to uniformity.”

“It is rich irony that the county of Allegheny County is telling the school district it should be raising taxes when the county itself has not raised taxes and the county controller calls out the fact that the refunds the county has been making causes him concerns,” he said.

Advertise with us

The county and Ms. Innamorato also maintained the lawsuit was defective because the district did not file notice with the state attorney general that it was legally challenging a Pennsylvania statute.

The filing also stated that Ms. Innamorato should be removed as a defendant, arguing that suing her in her official capacity is the same as suing the county itself.

Mr. Weiss said the attorney general notice isn’t a “significant issue” and that the district will provide notice “to the extent required.”

“The issue is the failure of this county to have a reassessment in a timely manner,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.