The hits keep coming to the Downtown Pittsburgh tax base.

Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review members approved $14 million more in cuts to the 2024 taxable value of seven pieces of Downtown real estate Thursday.

The reductions continue a trend that has seen the assessments on a number of Golden Triangle properties, including some of its biggest skyscrapers, slashed by nearly half a billion dollars for the 2022 and 2023 tax years.

At work are two big factors — high office vacancy rates and a steep reduction from 87.5% to 54.5% over the past few years in the number used to calculate taxable value during assessment appeal hearings.

Advertise with us

In many cases, the new taxable value is significantly lower than what the owners paid for their properties.

The biggest reduction approved Thursday involved the 22-story 20 Stanwix Street office building on Stanwix Street. The $25.8 million assessment was slashed by nearly $11.2 million to $14.6 million. The owner, M&J Wilkow, paid $38.1 million for the property in 2015.

Several Wood Street buildings also received sizable cuts in their 2024 assessments. The taxable value of a building at 419 Wood St. owned by the Italian Sons and Daughters of America plunged from $2.1 million to $272,500, a reduction of roughly 87%.

Downtown buildings owned by the Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation at 435 Market St. and 413 and 417 Wood received a total of $812,600 in decreases.

The $14 million in cuts Downtown could cost the city, the Pittsburgh Public Schools, and the county $323,513 in tax revenue. That’s on top of more than $9 million in combined losses last year based on $409.9 million in reductions awarded to 15 buildings in the central business district alone.

Advertise with us

In a court filing, the district has estimated that since 2022, it has had to refund $22.6 million in taxes because of appeals decisions.

While the $323,513 might not seem like much given the prior losses, “it’s just piling another log on the fire,” said Ira Weiss, Pittsburgh Public Schools solicitor.

By contrast, the assessment board on Thursday approved one increase in taxable value totaling $162,700 for a building at 965 Liberty Ave. in Downtown. The hike brought the taxable value to $381,500 — still far less than the $700,000 owner 965 Liberty Ave Downtown LLC paid for it a year ago.

Mr. Weiss said the cuts will continue until the county conducts a reassessment of all property. The city schools filed a lawsuit in April to force such a revaluation, but the county and Executive Sara Innamorato are fighting it.

“The trend is continuing because of the underlying cause of this, which is the failure to reassess,” Mr. Weiss said. “The resulting decline in the common level ratio will continue in a free fall until that reassessment occurs.”

Advertise with us

Even if the district wins its lawsuit to force a reassessment, it will take a couple of years to complete one, he noted.

“That’s why the delay in getting this moving is so frustrating. Everyone agrees a reassessment is necessary except the one person who can make it happen and that is the county executive. I mean, denial is a terrible thing,” he said.

In asking the judge to throw out the lawsuit, the county and Ms. Innamorato have argued that the district lacks standing to pursue such litigation. It contended that any revenue losses could be rectified through tax increases. But the district has countered that none of the arguments possess “even a shred of merit.”

The fact that some new taxable values awarded through appeals are falling well below the sale prices of properties is “contrary to common sense,” Mr. Weiss said. While the plunging common level ratio is part of the reason for that, he also blamed the assessment board in part.

“It’s pretty clear that this assessment board views almost every case in a light most favorable to the property owner. That’s the reality of it,” he said.

Advertise with us

Assessment board member Mike Suley took issue with that, saying that he and his colleagues were just doing their job based on the evidence.

He said Mr. Weiss never objected when the district filed appeals to increase the value of under-assessed properties when they were sold, a practice sometimes derided as a “newcomers” or “welcome neighbors” tax.

“The shoe’s on the other foot. For the last 20 years, his office engaged in sales chasing when there were under assessments. He was able to jack up taxes 20% to 40%. He wasn’t complaining about the results of the appeals board then,” he added.

But Mr. Suley stressed that he and Mr. Weiss agree on one thing — the need for a reassessment.

The $14 million in reductions approved for Downtown properties Thursday represented more than 10% of the $112 million in cuts for 2024 awarded countywide. The decreases involved 419 properties in all.

Last month, the board approved $56.1 million in reductions involving 804 properties countywide.