Last season, Dan Muse took a team pegged for the NHL lottery to 98 points and the playoffs. His impact was clear all over the ice.
“[The Penguins] maybe surprised a bunch of people with the season they had last year. But when you watched them play, or you were prepping for them, or when you played against them, you understood why they were having success,” Colorado Avalanche coach Jared Bednar said recently.
Muse’s team ranked top 10 in both power play and penalty kill. They played fast and racked up goals. They got contributions from up and down the lineup. The rookie coach was a finalist for the Jack Adams Award.
“I thought that Dan and his staff did an incredible job last year and into this year,” Florida Panthers coach Paul Maurice said. “... Taking what that team was good at, inspiring them to play that well, but doing it consistently every night. They were a very, very consistent team.”
That consistency has eluded the Penguins this season. They haven’t been able to replicate several aspects of their 2025-26 success. Let’s take a look at some of the most notable differences.
Cost of playing fast
Opposing coaches recognized an obvious identity for the Penguins in Year 1 under Muse.
Read More
“With Muse, his style of playing fast and playing that transition game, it was clear to see last season,” Boston Bruins coach Marco Sturm said.
The Penguins are again one of the top teams on the rush this season. But it’s come at a much greater cost.
Last season, they were more disciplined with the puck. Turnovers could be a problem, but they weren’t catastrophic. Puck management has been disastrous this season.
The Penguins have allowed the fourth-most odd-man rush goals at even strength per game, according to HockeyStats.com. They’ve surrendered the fifth-most giveaways per game, as well.
“Sometimes, being on that rush part of it, if you don’t have success on the rush, you give up rush back, so it can be a bit of an up-and-down game,” Vegas Golden Knights coach Ryan Craig said.
The Penguins are determined to maintain their up-tempo identity this season. It’s been one of their only reliable sources of offense. But the aggressive style is burning them just as often.
Powering down
Muse revived the Penguins’ special teams last season. They converted 24.1% of power plays, good for seventh in the league.
This season, they rank 21st at 20%. But the raw stats don’t capture their true ineptitude in that key phase.
They rank last in expected goals per 60 minutes on the power play, according to HockeyStats.com. They also rank last in power-play shots per 60 minutes, roughly averaging one per two-minute minor.
It’s a miracle that they have yet to give up a shorthanded goal. But opponents are often flipping the momentum by stymying the Penguins’ power play.
The structure doesn’t look entirely different in Muse’s second season. He’s tinkered with the personnel, but both units are largely comprised of familiar faces. They just seem to be much more stagnant.
And a bad defensive team has little hope if it can’t capitalize on power plays.
Not finishing the job
Much of it is clearly out of Muse’s hands.
Last season, the Penguins scored the third-most goals in the league. They ranked seventh in expected goals per game, according to MoneyPuck, meaning they were converting more than their fair share of chances.
A 21.7% shooting season for Anthony Mantha had a lot to do with that. Eighteen goals in 43 games for Egor Chinakhov didn’t hurt. The Penguins found offensive lightning in a bottle from several players.
That electricity isn’t crackling this season. The Penguins have generated the fourth-most expected goals per 60 minutes at 5-on-5, per MoneyPuck. But they rank 16th in actual 5-on-5 goals per 60 minutes.
There’s not much a coach can do about that. He’s putting his team in positions to be successful offensively. They simply aren’t finding the back of the net.
Out of their depth
Perhaps Muse’s greatest impact last season was instilling role players with confidence and leading them to career years.
“His positivity is second to none. They allow you to make mistakes. They allow you to play your game,” Ryan Shea said at locker clean-out day after tallying 35 points and leading the team with a plus-30 rating.
Players have given similar quotes so far this season. But it hasn’t translated to the ice.
The bottom six is not scoring at the same rate. It doesn’t help that the third line has been a revolving door.
The blue line also hasn’t gelled like last season. While newcomer Kaedan Korczak has played well on the right, the left side is sorely missing Shea and Parker Wotherspoon.
The Penguins will still have some players hit career years. But there doesn’t appear to be a Mantha- or Shea-esque breakout season coming.
Losing the magic mix
Multiple coaches noted the Penguins’ potent mix of savvy veterans and energetic young players.
Bednar compared them to some of his early seasons in Colorado, when the Nathan MacKinnon-led young core joined forces with veterans to push the Avalanche back to the playoffs.
“We got a lot of young guys in, and their excitement, their skill level, their pace kind of rejuvenated some of our veteran guys to sort of play the same way and get back on top of their game,” Bednar said.
The Penguins’ veterans, particularly Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Erik Karlsson, were clearly rejuvenated by the team’s resurgent 2025-26 campaign.
While Malkin has played similarly this season, Crosby is struggling, with just 13 points in 20 games. Karlsson is at essentially a point per game but has been far less responsible defensively.
Muse unlocked something for the veteran core last season. The results haven’t been the same in 2026-27. That’s probably more about the aging curve than the coach.
Muse’s opportunity
The Penguins’ struggles this season aren’t on Muse. He hasn’t been perfect — some of the lineup decisions have been suspect and the power play needs a reboot.
But this is the inevitable bottoming out that most predicted last season. Muse was a huge part of why they fought it off then. He hasn’t been able to work the same magic with one of the smallest, least physical and most mistake-prone rosters in the league.
Yet this challenging season should allow Muse to showcase his strengths. He’s coached in high school, college, the USHL and the U.S. National Team Development Program. His track record for developing young players was a major reason why the Penguins hired him.
As the trades likely start coming and more prospects get their shot in Pittsburgh, Muse can help them establish themselves in the NHL like Ben Kindel, Chinakhov, Shea and more did last season.
Muse probably won’t be getting any Jack Adams votes this season. But if he can help players such as Rutger McGroarty, Ville Koivunen and Avery Hayes grow into consistent NHL difference-makers, Year 2 of the Muse era can be just as impactful for the franchise long term.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.