For many Allegheny County residents, the start of August brings to mind beach vacations and Steelers training camp. But this year, the county has added a new wrinkle to the calendar — the beginning of property assessment appeal season.
A ritual that typically did not take place until the dead of winter now will occur in the dog days of summer, thanks to legislation passed by County Council in June.
It moved up the deadline for filing 2025 appeals by six months to Oct. 1. The county will begin accepting such challenges on Thursday.
The new schedule is a major break from the past.
For years, the deadline for filing appeals was March 31. The window to do so typically opened in early January just after the New Year’s champagne turned flat.
That meant that assessment changes made during appeals hearings were applied retroactively for the tax year, making it difficult for property owners to predict what they would owe in taxes, and for municipalities and school districts to estimate revenues.
Read More
For example, a property owner who appealed their 2023 assessment received one tax bill at the start of the year based on the taxable value at that time, and then another once the hearing had been heard if the assessment was increased or decreased.
With the new system, the goal is to have all 2025 appeals decided by the time 2025 tax bills go out in January.
“If you’re a taxpayer there’s more consistency and stability in the tax bill for the next year if you have the [appeal] result before receiving the tax bill,” said Mike Suley, a county assessment board member who pushed to alter the schedule.
The change is intended to bring Allegheny County in line with other counties.
Virtually every other county in Pennsylvania has a spring or summer deadline for filing assessment appeals for the following tax year (2024 for 2025, for example), said Sharon DiPaolo, a partner in the Siegel Jennings Co. law firm who specializes in property appeals.
“These are really important advances ... that I think are going to be helpful to everyone,” she said.
Ira Weiss, solicitor for the Pittsburgh Public Schools and a number of other districts in the county, also supported the change. He noted that most other counties in the state have appeals resolved by the end of October for the next tax year.
“It will enable local taxing bodies to more reliably project revenues and areas of concern for appeals,” he said. “It just more aligns with the budgeting for municipalities, the county, and school districts.”
Acknowledging that the new timetable represented a “dramatic change in the way” the county handles appeals, Mr. Suley wondered how many taxpayers are clued into it.
“I’d be willing to bet that most people aren’t aware of that,” he said.
To its credit, the county has alerted visitors to its real estate website of the change. It’s also advertised on the assessment board website.
Ed Hirshberg, an attorney who handles commercial, industrial and some residential appeals, said his clients are “intensely aware” of the new deadline. But he’s not sure about the public as a whole.
“I think it’s kind of a byzantine topic to advertise to the public. It can be difficult to wrap your head around, let alone advertise,” he said.
Just how many appeals the new approach will generate remains to be seen.
Mr. Suley noted that the common level ratio, a number used in appeal hearings to calculate a property’s taxable value, will drop to 52.7% in 2025 from 54.5% this year.
That, he believes, could trigger more residential appeals since a lower common level ratio typically favors the property owner. But he’s not sure about the commercial side.
“I don’t know how many commercial appeals are left. Many of those have already gone through the system. I don’t think we’ll see as many of those, but I may be wrong,” he said.
Over the past few years, commercial appeals in Downtown and elsewhere throughout the county have resulted in hundreds of millions of dollars in reductions as property owners took advantage of the lower ratio as well as decreases in office occupancy and other fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic.
That, in turn, has caused taxing bodies to lose millions of dollars in revenues and to issue millions of dollars more in property tax refunds.
Mr. Hirshberg said he has been hearing this year from a new class of residential taxpayers — those who have learned from a neighbor how much that property owner saved by appealing their assessment and who now wants to get in on the action themselves.
“People are talking about it at their cocktail parties and barbecues,” he said. “Now that there are results and reductions, neighbors are telling neighbors.”
Ms. DiPaolo, on the other hand, is expecting a lighter number of appeals in the new season. She doesn’t anticipate the small drop in the ratio triggering as many appeals as more sizable reductions have in the past. Over the past few years, the ratio has plunged from 87.5% to 54.5%.
“I don’t think we’ll see that many,” she said, adding that it makes it a perfect time to change the appeals deadline.
Although the deadline for 2025 appeals will be Oct. 1, it will generally be around Sept. 1 in future years, based on the legislation approved by County Council. Councilman Sam DeMarco, the lead sponsor of the bill, has said it’s designed to assist municipalities and property owners.
Starting Thursday, the online form to file a 2025 assessment appeal is expected to be available on the county’s board of property assessment appeals and review website or the property assessment office website.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.