Chuck Noll was dead set against using instant replay to overturn calls. His reasons were many, from slowing down the game to making on-field officials tentative.
“The answer is people, not machines,” Noll once said, via Sports Illustrated. “We have some good officials, but they have to have that other stuff [all the distractions that accompany replay] out of their way.”
He’s been proven correct.
Another of his concerns was this: What if replay got it wrong? What if the officials made the correct call on the field and then it was overturned?
It happens, and mostly because guys such as Alberto Riveron, the NFL’s senior vice president of officiating, do not follow the rules on instant replay. Calls are supposed to be overturned only when there is clear evidence they were not ruled correctly on the field.
Instead, Riveron’s rulings have been anything but. Jesse James was not in control of the football? He caught it, went down on one knee, pulled the ball in and then lunged over the goal line before replay showed he might have lost it.
Read More
The problem with replay is that Riveron — and some of those before him — look at plays as a lawyer might; they look for the fine print.
The original intent of using replay to overturn calls was to overturn the OBVIOUS wrong calls — whether a player clearly was out of bounds while making a catch or if a player did not truly fumble what was ruled a fumble or if the ball crossed the goal line.
Noll felt that a confusing replay call by supervisor of officials Art McNally cost his team the playoffs in the final game of 1987. The Steelers recovered a Bernie Kosar fumble at the Cleveland 2; that’s how the officials on the field ruled. McNally concurred but inexplicably gave the ball to the Browns at the 4 even though the Steelers clearly recovered it. The Steelers lost 19-13 to go 8-7, costing them a wild-card playoff berth.
And 30 years later, replay officials continue to overturn plays that should stand.
Using replay is here to stay in all of sports, but perhaps they should go back to the original intent of the rule and use it only on obviously wrong calls. There are plenty of reasons for the NFL’s tumbling television ratings. Turning off fans with these kinds of calls may be one of them.
It’s about preparation
• Mike Tomlin talked about all the scenarios presented to the Steelers while they waited 3 minutes and 22 seconds from the end of what was ruled a touchdown on the field by James to Riveron’s replay review that overturned the call last Sunday.
Really, there were only two scenarios the Steelers had to think about: Will the ball be third down at the New England 1 with 18 seconds left, or third down at the 10 with 28 seconds left?
The only other scenario was a confirmed touchdown, and the Steelers did not have to prepare for their next offensive play if that were the call.
They were faced with two scenarios with more than three minutes to work out what they wanted to do. Tomlin said they prepared for what they were told would be the most likely scenario, placing the ball at the 1. Surely, someone in his coaches’ booth could have told him James was never close to being touched down. That would leave one scenario they had to worry about — the TD catch would be overturned and ruled incomplete, and the Steelers would have third down at the 10 with 28 seconds to go.
Either way, they had more than three minutes to decide a plan of action. Apparently, they planned little. Even Ben Roethlisberger said that while he waited for the call, he knelt on the sideline and prayed. Maybe they were too confident the touchdown would stand.
Home or away?
• Getting the AFC championship at Heinz Field would have been advantageous for the Steelers and the city of Pittsburgh, which would have reaped economic and public relations benefits from such a game.
But the Steelers have won AFC championships on the road before. Most famously in 1974 in Oakland, which was considered a superior team at the time. They also became the first team to win three playoff games on the road, in the 2005 season, and win the Super Bowl, earning that berth with a victory in the AFC championship at one of the toughest venues in the NFL for visitors, Denver.
Let’s not forget they have lost AFC championships at home — in the seasons of 1994 (San Diego), 1997 (Denver) and 2001 and 2004 (both to the Patriots). Before they ever won a Super Bowl, they lost the AFC title game in 1972 to Miami at home.
Winning another one in New England won’t be easy — especially if they haven’t figured out how to slow down Rob Gronkowski. But to begin and end with a Chuck Noll quote, if it were easy, anyone could do it.
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com
Want in-depth Steelers coverage all season long?




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.