Tony Dungy feels Mike Tomlin’s pain. He’s been on the wrong end of the NFL catch rule, and he knows how it can turn a team’s Super Bowl fortunes.
With the Steelers still fuming about the overturned touchdown against the Patriots last week that could keep them from getting the No. 1 seed and home-field advantage throughout the AFC playoffs, Dungy has an even more demoralizing story to tell.
An overturned catch played a big part in his 1999 Tampa Bay Buccaneers being denied a chance to earn a trip in the Super Bowl. The NFL’s catch rule has reared its ugly head many times over the years, but you’d be hard-pressed to find a bigger controversy in a bigger game.
Trailing 11-6 late in the fourth quarter of the NFC championship, Tampa Bay quarterback Shaun King appeared to
complete a pass to Bert Emmanuel at the St. Louis 23-yard line. Emmanuel dived for the ball, and as he pulled it in toward his body, part of the ball hit the ground. Emmanuel did not bobble the ball, but referee Bill Corolla overturned the call on the field after looking at it in slow-motion on replay review.
Two plays later, Tampa Bay’s season was over, and the Rams represented the NFC in the Super Bowl.
Read More
“Our guys in Tampa still wonder what might have happened,” Dungy said over the phone this week.
Dungy said the controversial ruling was one of the “unintended consequences” of the NFL implementing replays reviews again for the 1999 season after a seven-year hiatus from it. The cruel irony for Dungy and the Buccaneers is the play was so universally disliked by people in the NFL that the Bert Emmanuel Rule was adopted over that offseason to prevent other officiating gaffes in big games.
Only it has not. Just ask Steelers tight end Jesse James.
James caught a pass from Ben Roethlisberger at the New England 1 with 28 seconds remaining Sunday night. After he caught the ball, his knee hit the ground. He turned his body and stretched the ball across the plane of the goal line.
It’s a touchdown in another NFL era. But in 2017, because the ball moved when he went to the ground, it’s not a catch.
Dungy said the James play is yet another unintended consequence of video review the NFL never anticipated. The rule was never intended for plays when receivers remain upright, or partially upright with control of the ball as James was.
“It was put in for diving catches,” said Dungy, who is now an analyst for NBC.
The rule has been conflated over the years to the point where common sense rulings are overturned by letter of law interpretations by the senior vice-president of officiating of the NFL Alberto Riveron, who reviews all touchdowns from the NFL offices in New York.
“If I catch a ball and become a runner then the ground cannot cause a fumble,” Dungy said. “The sticking point is if you are in the process of going to the ground. You can take three or four steps, but if you’re going down you have to survive the ground.
“When do you catch the ball? The rule says you haven’t caught the ball until you survive the ground. It’s not what any 11-year old would say is the case. ‘Well, OK he never caught the ball because three steps later when he hit the ground the ball moved a little bit.’ My 11-year-old would say that’s ridiculous. In simpler times, we’d say the ground can’t cause a fumble. Now it’s an incomplete pass so we can make it easy to call on replay.”

Catch rule origins
From the early days of the NFL until 1982, the catch rule was much simpler than it is now. The original rule, which first appeared in the rulebook in 1938, stated the receiver had to possess the ball and “perform an act common to the game.” It remained unchanged for more than four decades.
The NFL’s slippery slope on the catch rule began in 1982 when the rule was rewritten for the first time to state the receiver must possess the ball “to the ground.”
In recent years, the league has rewritten clarifications to the rule in an attempt to make it easier for officials to judge plays. There is the oft-cited language by referees for the receiver having to “complete the process of a catch.” Or the receiver has to be “making a football move.” Or the receiver “must clearly become a runner.” Or as we first heard Sunday night “the receiver must survive the ground.”
When the rule was originally put into the rulebook in 1982 it was done because NFL owners didn’t like so-called cheap fumbles that rewarded defenses when offensive players lost the ball when they hit the ground.
The rule has taken those fumbles out of the game, but it has opened up a whole new can of worms. One retired NFL official who wished to remain anonymous said the league can make things much simpler by ruling a player is down and the play is over once the ball comes loose.
Obviously, as Dungy noted, diving catches would remain reviewable, but catches when players make obvious football moves before the ball comes loose would simply be down at the spot of the ball hitting the ground. Just as the ground cannot cause a fumble for a running back when he hits the ground, it would not cause a fumble for a receiver in the same way.
Steelers coach Mike Tomlin, who is a member of the NFL competition committee, said this week the catch rule will be examined again.
“I think that we all can acknowledge that all of this needs to be revisited,” Tomlin said. “It’s not just that play. We’re having similar discussions week in and week out, so as a member of the committee I acknowledge that we’ve got our work cut out for us this offseason regarding a number of those things.”
Taking power away from Riveron also might be in play for the league. He has been the center of several controversial rulings and has been accused of overstepping.
NFL officials, former and current, agree replay reviews have become problematic because high-definition television and other technology can capture the things unseen by on-field officials.
In short, they’re micromanaging and taking skillful plays out of the game.
“Does the ball move sometimes? Yes,” former NFL referee Jim Daopoulos, now ESPN’s rules analyst, told the Post-Gazette last year. “But you can do whatever you want in New York to make it a catch or not make it a catch by slowing it down or not slowing it down. With high-definition TV now, you can slow it down so much that you’re going to see the slightest bobble.
“Now they’re looking to see if the laces move. We’ve become so technical. We’ve made it too difficult on the officials. I would try to make it as simple as possible. Don’t micromanage the catches. I used to teach the [officials] that these players can make these catches. Don’t micromanage the game with bobbles and all this stuff. Let the players decide the game on the field. We have to quit going to replay so much. We can’t let it be determined by a TV shot.”
Many Steelers fans are wondering why the James play was overturned and a similar play by Brandin Cooks of New England was not in Week 3. Cooks caught a touchdown from Tom Brady with 23 seconds left to give the Patriots a come-from-behind victory.
There are several well-circulated GIFs on social media that detail the play. Cooks got both feet in bounds, but in the process of going to the ground the ball came loose from his hands, and he trapped it against the ground before regaining control.
There was little, if any difference, between Cook’s touchdown and the touchdown that was taken away from James.
The inconsistency with the rule is why the NFL was in damage control this week. The NFL refused an interview request from the Post-Gazette for Riveron to explain the difference between the two plays. A league source said Cooks’ touchdown was not overturned because there was no camera angle that showed him losing control of the ball when he hit the ground.
It’s also worth noting Riveron immediately posted a video and distributed it via NFL social media Sunday night in an effort to explain his decision. In Week 3, Riveron examined three disputed calls for video distribution from that week’s games. The Cooks touchdown was not among the three plays he discussed.
But beyond Riveron’s inconsistencies are other issues with replay reviews. Dungy said coaches now have to instruct players what to do on those questionable plays rather than what comes naturally to them.
“You have to coach that into your player,” Dungy said. “You can’t stretch. You have to go against your instincts.”
Does that create problems for coaches?
“Yes,” he said. “You don’t get that much practice at it. How much do you do it? What kind of drills do you do? It’s all a product of replay, one of the unintended consequences that they never thought about.”
The Steelers don’t have specific instruction for receivers regarding the catch rule. When Tomlin was asked this week what he tells his players he was blunt: “Catch the ball.”
The Steelers don’t teach their players how to fall after a catch, but it is something they address during the offseason.
“We do more talking about what you need to do, things you can be conscious of,” receiver Darrius Heyward-Bey said. “Really, it’s just knowing what you need to do. In Jesse’s situation, or anyone else’s situation, you’re going to try to make a play.
“I’d rather have a guy who’s trying to make a play than the guy who gets the first down and gets out of bounds, and we’re all like, ‘Hey, you could have scored a touchdown.’ I’d rather have my guys who can make plays and try to make plays, and we deal with the consequences later.”
Mike Tomlin talks about the Steelers' final play against the Patriots
What’s next?
The Steelers aren’t alone in their misery with the catch rule. There have been many other controversies since the Bert Emmanuel play. The two most recent examples are the Calvin Johnson and Dez Bryant catches that were overturned in 2010 and 2014. Johnson, a former All-Pro with the Lions, leapt and caught a touchdown. He only lost control of the ball as he was getting up after falling to the ground.
In a playoff game after the 2014 season against the Packers, Bryant caught a pass, took three steps and reached the ball across the goal line. The ball came loose after the ball hit the ground near the goal line.
If the competition committee didn’t change the rule after it compromised a playoff game then there is little chance a regular-season game will affect change. The only way Dungy sees change coming is if there are more controversies in the playoffs.
“It blew over with Dez and Calvin Johnson,” Dungy said. “It’ll probably blow over in this case unless we have another one. If you have another one then there might be some momentum for it.”
If you coach or play long enough in the NFL, these controversial plays tend to even out. Six years after the heart-wrenching NFC championship loss, Dungy got a favorable call in a 2005 AFC divisional-round game against the Steelers.
A Troy Polamalu interception was overturned when Dungy challenged a ruling of an interception on the field. After making the interception, Polamalu rolled over and bobbled the ball as he was trying to get up to run. The Colts almost came back to win the game because of the overturned call.
“I knew he caught the ball,” Dungy said. “It was an interception and a great play. We got the ball back because of a stupid rule. We got the ball back and had a chance to win the game. I mean, it was ludicrous. But I was on the competition committee and knew the rule. You have to challenge it.”
Now the NFL reviews all scoring plays as well as change-of-possession plays in the final two minutes of the game. And whether it makes sense or not to coaches, players and fans, the league continues to apply illogical interpretations of a rule that has been mired in controversy for years.
“I hope they do revisit it,” Heyward-Bey said. “I hope they try to figure it out, bring some guys in to figure out how to make the game better for us. At the end of the way, we’re the players. We should have input on the game we play.
“I would rather have guys know what the rule is than not know the rule at all. You have to understand what happened to Dez Bryant, what happened to Jesse, what happened to Calvin Johnson, is only happening because of technology. Are we going to start reviewing holding calls? Are we going to start reviewing everything? If we’re going to do that then cool, but pay me more money if that’s the case, if you want me to do the impossible.”
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.