Brandon Lowe was the Pirates’ best player last season.

He led the team in most offensive categories and was a great leader in the clubhouse.

The Pirates should absolutely want Lowe back next year. But whether that happens or not, there are other areas that need to be addressed — ones that should rank as higher priorities.

On Tuesday, Lowe officially rejected the Pirates’ qualifying offer, a one-year deal worth $23.15 million. The entire league can now bid for his services. He won’t come cheap, nor should he.

Advertise with us

The Pirates can still make a push to re-sign Lowe, something they’ve said they intend to do. But as they proceed, they must keep the big picture in mind.

There’s no denying that having Lowe around will help the Pirates win games in 2027. He provides plenty of power from the left side, capable defense at second base and everything you could hope to get from a veteran off the field.

Yet, with or without him, the club still has plenty of weaknesses.

The flaws of last year’s Pirates team were not easy to miss. In order to truly improve, they’ll need to add more power from the right side of the plate, reinforce their left-handed pitching depth and play better defense at third base and in the outfield.

Signing Lowe to a long-term deal would solve none of those problems. And if Lowe is going to cost what many assume, it’s worth wondering if enough resources will remain to address everything that actually needs fixed.

Advertise with us

Life without Lowe might seem painful to some fans. But the Pirates have players who can provide what he does, albeit to a lesser degree.

Nick Gonzales would be a capable replacement at second base, someone with a much lower ceiling but a steady floor. He hit well enough last season to deserve an everyday spot in 2027.

Playing him one more inning at third base would be a bad decision for all involved. Moving him back to his natural position makes the most sense.

Even without Lowe, the Pirates’ lineup still has plenty of left-handed pop.

Ryan O’Hearn, Oneil Cruz and Bryan Reynolds will likely be three of the top four hitters on the team. Konnor Griffin must be included in there, as well.

Advertise with us

Cruz and O’Hearn suffered injuries last season, ones that forced both to miss extended time. If they can remain healthy in 2027, their production will replace a chunk of what the Pirates will be missing should Lowe sign elsewhere. Getting a platoon player to make up the remaining difference seems like an easier task than signing perhaps the best infielder on the market.

It’s worth saying again that I think the Pirates should make a push to sign Lowe.

I’d love to see him back in Pittsburgh next year.

What I don’t want to see is the same surrounding cast.

The Pirates simply can’t run it back in 2027. Trotting out the same lineup as last year is begging for similar results.

Advertise with us

Additional commitment from ownership would allow the Pirates to avoid these types of problems. More money would allow them to make a legitimate push to address both areas.

But we’re talking about Bob Nutting’s Pirates, so the budget must always remain in mind.

If signing Lowe would limit the Pirates from fixing their defensive woes and inability to hit left-handed pitching or from further addressing depth in the rotation and bullpen, then perhaps they’d be better off without him.

It’s unfortunate that they can’t have it all — but that’s likely the reality they’ll have to choose from.

So while, yes, Lowe should certainly remain a goal, fixing the things that prevented this team from winning games in 2026 should come first.

If there’s not enough money remaining to retain Lowe after those boxes are checked, then that’s a reality the Pirates must live with.