There is a good case to be made that Steelers receiver Antonio Brown should win the NFL’s MVP award, even if he misses the Steelers’ final two games with a calf injury.
But is Brown the Steelers’ MVP? There is some evidence mounting that he isn’t.
The answer to that question depends on how you define an MVP. If it is the most outstanding player, then Brown wins, hands down, for this season. But if it is the most valuable — as in least replaceable player — I’m not sure Brown is in the top three on the team.
Obviously, the Steelers can’t replace quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, so he could be considered the team’s most valuable player every year. The drop from him to backup Landry Jones is significant, and without him, they have zero chance at getting to the Super Bowl.
The Steelers have also discovered what life without cornerback Joe Haden has been like, and it is clear they have nobody — either one player or a committee — who can replace him. As Ed Bouchette pointed out, the Steelers have been a much different defense in the five games Haden has missed with a broken fibula.
With Haden healthy, the Steelers allowed an average of 181.8 yards per game and gave up only eight passing touchdowns. In the five games since he has been out, the Steelers have allowed 251.6 yards per game and nine passing touchdowns. Cam Sutton and Cody Sensabaugh filled his spot, and the drop in production was easy to see. His absence also forced Artie Burns to become the No. 1 cornerback, and he struggled against opponents’ top receivers.
Read More
Haden will return Monday when the Steelers play the Texans, and that will move Burns away from the pressure of being the primary cornerback. It will also move Sensabaugh and Sutton back to the bench. That should go a long way toward fixing most of what has ailed the defense in recent weeks.
Along with Haden, the Steelers have also discovered that life without inside linebacker Ryan Shazier is going to be rough. Shazier is excellent stopping the run, and even better in coverage. Without him, the Steelers are not nearly as good covering running backs and tight ends out of the backfield, nor have they been as effective stopping the run.
Brown leads the NFL in receptions (101) and receiving yards (1,553), and he is third in receiving touchdowns (9). His absence will certainly change the offense and the way teams have to defend the Steelers, but it doesn’t mean they won’t be explosive and capable of putting up big numbers.
“A.B., you can’t replace him with one man,” Roethlisberger said Wednesday. “A.B. is not human. So we will have multiple guys trying to fill that spot.”
Roethlisberger is correct that the Steelers can’t replace Brown with just one player. But unlike Haden and Shazier, the Steelers have other players capable of replacing Brown’s production. They also have the ability to change the way they play. Le’Veon Bell is the NFL’s leading rusher, and he is quite capable of carrying the load in Brown’s absence.
The absence of Brown does mean that teams won’t have to focus their attention in coverage on him. But with the emergence of JuJu Smith-Schuster and Martavis Bryant coming off his best game, the Steelers still have two explosive receivers to challenge defenses. Tight end Jesse James has become a weapon as well.
This offense should still be dominant without Brown. Without Haden and/or Shazier, however, the defense has clearly not been close to the same.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.