Ben Roethlisberger might never know what he did for sports talk radio Tuesday.
First, the obvious. By refusing to confirm his 2017 return, Roethlisberger guaranteed weeks and maybe months of speculation as to his motives.
Mad at Tomlin?
Sick of A.B.?
Bitter he’s not Brady?
Legitimately concerned for his health?
Read More
But there is more. Much more. More than he could ever realize.
Roethlisberger, you see, unleashed a monster not seen in these parts since 2004. Worse than Sasquatch, it’s “Pass Watch” — the never-ending discussion on who the Steelers’ next quarterback should be.
Nothing captivates a fan base like obsessing over the heir apparent. The backup-in-waiting. The prospect. The savior.
Whachoo guys think ab-aht Tony Romo?
Why ohnt ay take Pe’erman and bring in Matt Canada to replace that jagoff Haley?
Haws ‘baht Mettenberger? Ay’d only haveta change cupla letters on his jersey.
Somewhere in the glorious madness resides a legitimate question: When do the Steelers draft their version of Matt Murray, or try to?
Roethlisberger turns 35 in March. He has absorbed more hits than google.com. He has three young children at home.
Is this the year to pull the trigger in the first few rounds? What if Deshaun Watson should drop toward the Steelers at No. 30? What if a raw and talented prospect such as DeShone Kizer becomes available?
It’s tempting, because a project quarterback theoretically would ripen around the time Roethlisberger’s contract expires, after the 2019 season.
If I’m the Steelers, though, I’m only thinking quarterback if somebody high on my board sinks to the later rounds.
Two reasons for that:
• The window is wide-open right now — some Vegas books have the Steelers as the third-best bet to win it all next season — and this team needs immediate help. It could use a pass rusher, a cover guy and maybe a new toy for Ben. (How would Christian McCaffrey look spelling Le’Veon Bell and returning kicks?).
• More significantly, I don’t think Roethlisberger is anywhere near retirement. I think there’s a better chance he plays beyond his current contract than anything else.
That’s just a guess. of course. For all I know, Roethlisberger will take the Barry Sanders/Calvin Johnson route (I guess I’d quit young if I played for the Lions, too) and retire relatively healthy in his prime. Who could blame a man for that? More players than ever, seemingly, are choosing that path.
I just don’t believe Roethlisberger is wired that way. I can’t picture him stepping down while he can still play at an elite level — and it would be an almost unheard-of move for an all-time quarterback.
Look at the top 10 in quarterback wins, for example, keeping in mind that Roethlisberger’s contract would take him through his age 37 season:
Peyton Manning: Played through age 39 season.
Brett Favre: Played through age 41 season.
Tom Brady: Still going strong at 39.
John Elway: Played through age 38 season. Won Super Bowls at 37 and 38.
Dan Marino: Played through age 38 season
Drew Brees: Still going strong at 38.
Fran Tarkenton: Played through age 38 season.
Roethlisberger: Just finished age 34 season.
Johnny Unitas: Played until he was 40.
Joe Montana: Played through age 38 season.
Nearly all of the Super Bowl-era, Hall-of-Fame quarterbacks who quit in their mid-30s did so because of injuries, whether it was Terry Bradshaw (35, bum elbow), Troy Aikman (34, concussions), Bob Griese (35, wrecked shoulder), Joe Namath (34, no knees) or Jim Kelly (36, various injuries, including a concussion in his final game).
Again, if Roethlisberger decides to get out while he’s somewhat intact — the way Dan Fouts did at 36 — more power to him. He has done enough. It’s just that we’re talking about a “sick competitor,” as Mike Tomlin has described him, who is playing some of the best football of his career, barely gets touched anymore and is surrounded by elite talent.
The Steelers have planned meticulously for Roethlisberger’s mid- and late-30s. They are constantly thinking of ways to make his life easier, even if some moves haven’t worked out as planned (giving Ladarius Green big money, drafting Sammie Coates to fill in for Martavis Bryant).
So yes, I see Roethlisberger — assuming good health — still flinging footballs for a living four or five years from now. I could see the Steelers winning some AFC titles, too, with a little more help from the draft. This is no time to squander an early pick on Ben’s prospective replacement.
I’ll be happy to throw out some names, though.
Phone lines open …
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.