The Steelers are in a strong position to make another run toward the Super Bowl next season, and that has a number of fans thinking about what immediate needs they can fill in the upcoming draft.
It’s clear they have obvious needs at defensive back, outside pass rusher and even defensive line, and they may even want to take a look at some wide receivers. But a key that is seemingly being ignored is that this roster returns pretty much intact, so just about any player drafted will be a backup initially and perhaps a starter in the future. That’s why they absolutely should look at getting a quarterback — not just one to provide an extra arm for camp but one that can be developed to be their starter in the future.
If there is a quarterback available Kevin Colbert and Mike Tomlin have graded high when the Steelers pick at No. 30, they need to select him and groom him to take over when Ben Roethlisberger retires.
My colleague and friend Joe Starkey took the opposite view in Monday’s paper, and I understand his point of view. I just don’t agree with it.
If DeShaun Watson or DeShone Kizer drops, the Steelers would be fools not to at least think about selecting him, especially if he is the top-rated quarterback on their board and higher on their board than other players at other positions. This team has the luxury of taking the best available player this year, and if that means grabbing a quarterback to develop for a few years until Roethlisberger decides to retire, they need to do it.
Roethlisberger’s discussions about needing time to decide if he will return is going to be an annual song and dance. One day, he might actually decide to walk away. He isn’t over the hill yet, but he isn’t young either. He has been sacked 455 times in his career and has been hit a lot more often than many quarterbacks because of his style of play. This also is the second year in a row he missed games due to injury, and he has had some nagging nicks and bruises that aren’t as easy to recover from for athletes in their mid-30s. Roethlisberger also is a father of young kids and seems to relish that role. It seems to have given him a different perspective on life and football. He’s also made enough money to last him several lifetimes and by all accounts has done a good job of keeping it. So, he doesn’t need to keep playing in order to support his life or lifestyle.
Read More
I’m sure Roethlisberger is fueled by the thought of trying to win at least one more Super Bowl to cement his legacy, but that could happen as soon as next year. If that happens, who knows, he may decide to walk away while he is on top.
This doesn’t mean the end is inevitable or near for Roethlisberger, but it does mean the Steelers need to at least entertain the idea that it could be. They need to take a serious look at a plan to groom his replacement. The Steelers need help at cornerback, but Ross Cockrell and Artie Burns are young, and a younger guy — Senquez Golson — is waiting in the wings to take over Willie Gay’s slot position. They also have Martavis Bryant to fill a big hole at wide receiver, and I’m fairly certain Cam Heyward returning will be a solution to some of what ails the defensive line. And if they resign Lawrence Timmons, and James Harrison returns for another season — two things that appear likely to happen — I really don’t see a starting position that needs to be filled in this draft.
Let’s also remember the Steelers have been pretty good at filling holes with mid-level and inexpensive free agents and will tap into that market again this year. They probably will end up with a player or two who is more ready to contribute in 2017 than anyone they draft.
Again, I get it: The Steelers have a chance to win the Super Bowl next year, so the argument goes they should draft players who can help them immediately. But from where I sit, I don’t see an immediate need they can’t fill in other ways. That leaves the door open for a players like Watson or Kizer, who are highly rated and graded by some as future starters. If the Steelers have a chance to take a top quarterback, they need to go with the best player available and take him instead of reaching for a depth player at a position of need.
It could turn out that the Steelers’ highest-rated quarterback is a fourth-round talent. If that’s the case, they need to take him in the fourth round, or the fifth round, or the third round if it looks like he is about to be taken off the board by another team.
The Steelers are loaded and ready to win, and that’s precisely why they have the luxury of taking a quarterback to develop. Roethlisberger has a few great years left in him, but he could walk away at any time. The Steelers need to accept that reality and have a plan in place to move forward.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.