Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my weekly Steelers chat. Post your questions and I'll be back soon to answer them.
Guest: What's the trade value for AB?
Ray Fittipaldo: I honestly don't think there is a lot of trade value for a player entering the final year of his contract. Why would a team trade a high draft pick when they're not even sure if he'd re-sign with them? I don't think that is a serious consideration for the Steelers. I know they did it with Santonio Holmes, but Holmes had off-field problems. Brown does not. Is he a pain to deal with sometimes? Yes, but that stems from wanting to be the best. I say make him the highest-paid WR in the NFL for three years. Tie him up through his age 31 year and then reevaluate. That also coincides with Ben Roethlisberger's contract. I think it makes sense to tie them together. And if he doesn't want to do a short-term deal you can always franchise him next year.
Guest: Is Ben retiring?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes... in 2019 or later.
Guest: Any news on coaches not returning?
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: No there hasn't been. Tomlin left the door open to change. It's only been a week since the season ended. If something does happen I would expect it to happen in the next week or two.
John B: Do you think we'll pick up a veteran WR on the cheap or is DHB our vet?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think it's more likely they'll draft one fairly high -- top three or four rounds. The last time they signed a free agent WR he didn't mesh well with Roethlisberger and it wasn't a very good signing. That was Lance Moore. They'll have Brown and probably Bryant as starters with Eli Rogers in the slot. But because of Bryant's tenuous situation I think you have to draft a player that can replace him if he cannot stay clean. Yeah I know you have Sammie Coates, but he hasn't done enough for me to feel comfortable that he's ready for a starting role.
Ben: Are the Steelers expecting any compensatory draft picks?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but not a high one. I think they should get around a sixth-round compensatory pick.
Krugerrand: How crazy would this be? If a player is injured during a personal foul, the injured team could pick a comparable player from the opposing team to sit during the duration of the injury. (no longer than the game at hand) A team's #1 WR is being evaluated for a concussion after a personal foul, they can force the other team to sit their #1 CB.
Ray Fittipaldo: Nice idea, but it'll never happen. What if the player that gets injured is coming off an injury and aggravates it? Or what if that player -- let's say Ladarius Green, for instance -- is susceptible to concussions?
ERIC B: Lets say L. Green cant play next year for whatever reason, do you think they'd pick up a FA again or stick with what they have or draft high?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if they'd draft a TE high. Jesse James has proven to be a starter capable TE. But I do think they would address the position somewhere in the draft, say in the middle rounds. This is a good year for tight ends in the draft, so the Steelers might be in luck. I like Jeremy Sprinkle from Arkansas. He's a guy who could go in the middle rounds. Played second fiddle to Hunter Henry before this season. Didn't put up great stats, but he is very solid as a WR and pretty solid as a blocker.
AT: I believe that it was in the divisional round where Sean Davis took a 15 yd penalty for hitting a defenseless receiver. I watched that play a couple of times and, to me, it looked like he had to options
Ray Fittipaldo: I think you meant no options. Yes, I agree. If you let Conley catch the ball it's first-and-goal at the 2. He hit, got a penalty and it was first-and-10 at the 12 (if memory serves correct). To me, that's a good penalty. He might not like the fine, but as Antonio Brown says he can "write if off."
Breon: With the steelers always picking late, they have never truly had the chance to get a dominant edge rusher or defensive back. Do you believe the Steelers might have to eventually trade up to get that dominant defensive player they need?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but it's very hard to trade up from No. 30. It gets too expensive. The good news this year is that it's a good year for edge rushers and CBs so the Steelers should be able to land a pretty good player when it comes time for them to pick.
Steve: Is it realistic that the Steelers can keep all of it's key players signed with Free Agency & AB & Bell commanding so much $$?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think so. They're actually in pretty good shape when it comes to the salary cap. Bell is likely to be franchised for about $12 million or thereabouts. They'll pick up Shazier's fifth-year option and try to get a deal done with Tuitt, who is entering the final year of his rookie deal. If you were paying close attention last Tuesday at Tomlin's end of the year presser he said the Steelers like to recruit their own so that's where most of the money will go -- into their own players in need of new contracts.
Scott in Dallas: Who in the top 10 picks in this draft would be willing to trade a 1st and 2nd/3rd rounder for Brown (49ers)? I just think it makes too much sense to build the defense and rid ourselves of the drama no matter how much I love having Brown on the team.
Ray Fittipaldo: No team would do that for the rights to a player with only one year left on his contract.
Jake: Are the two players the Steelers brought in for visits ( safety from Minnesota and linebacker from villinova) considered early draft picks as of now?
Ray Fittipaldo: They haven't brought any players in for visits yet. What you heard about is the Steelers meeting with players at the Senior Bowl. We'll have to wait and see about those guys, but the DE/OLB from Villanova was one of the darlings of the Senior Bowl. Haven't seen him mocked in the first round, but he could be in the second or middle rounds.
Guest: Didn't watch the game, how did Shazier and Decastro do in the Pro Bowl?
Ray Fittipaldo: Didn't watch either. They're happy though. The AFC won and they'll get more money.
Chuck: Will we be practicing more man to man next training camp?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would hope so. I think they need to diversify the defense. Keith Butler needs more options. I think Tomlin alluded to that in his final news conference last week when he was asked about playing man vs. New England in 2011. He said the personnel was different back then. Well then, seems to me you might want to get some personnel in the draft that helps you in this regard and gives you options when you play the Patriots again.
Steve: Greatest QB ever, Brady or Montana or ?? IF Brady wins on Sunday?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good bar room conversation. Montana is 4-0 in Super Bowls. Brady would be 5-2 if he won. There is something special for me about Montana and Bradshaw being perfect in the game. Bradshaw was always money when the game was on the line in the second halves of those games. But still, if Brady is the only QB with five it would be hard to argue against him.
Better argument, where does Brady fall if he loses? He'd be 4-3 and there's no way I'm putting him ahead of Montana if that happens.
Chuck: What grade would you give our 2016 draft now after 1 season in the books?
Ray Fittipaldo: B+ with a chance for it to be an A. You can never rate a class after one year. We still have lots to learn about Artie Burns and Sean Davis, but they started in the second half of the season for a team that advanced to the AFC championship game. Javon Hargrave started as a rookie on the defensive line. And I think Jerald Hawkins has a future on the O-line if he rebounds well from his shoulder injury.
Johnp from Va: With the remaining restricted/unrestricted free agents left to sign, who looks like they will get a multi- year deal?
Ray Fittipaldo: There aren't a lot of them. You have a guy like Ross Cockrell, who I think they'll bring back. He started all 19 games this season. Don't know if he's your long-term answer, but he played pretty well and they're not exactly deep at CB. You also have Chris Hubbard, who is a nice reserve, but they can get by without him. Then you have a bunch of exclusive rights free agents like Roosevvelt Nix and Cobi Hamilton and Al Villanueva among others. They have no choice but to return to the Steelers if they sign them, and they'll come cheap.
JON: Ray. I think this is one of the easiest SB’s to bet in recent years. New England is only -3? I say Pats by at least 10 to 14.Are you surprised by the line? The Patriots SB experience is unprecedented. Your thoughts on how you see this game?
Ray Fittipaldo: I like the Patriots, too. The only hope for the Falcons is to outscore them. The Falcons pass defense is even worse than the Steelers so you can imagine how that matchup will go. The Falcons offense, however, is much better than the Steelers. I can see them scoring a bunch to make it close. I think it would be fairly close, something along the lines of Patriots 31, Falcons 28.
Jack of Splat: Steelers need to cut Green - too un reliable and for salary cap in order to sign 1)Bell 2)Brown 3)Tuitt in that order. Draft a TE in first 3 rounds along with OLB and CB and we are done here!
Ray Fittipaldo: Good post, but I think they'll franchise Bell. Too many questions about his off-field stuff to do a long-term deal until he proves otherwise. It just makes too much sense to franchise him.
Chuck: If we draft a TE before Rd 4, is that a possible indication that L Green could be an after June 1 release? If you had to guess, knowing no medical information, do you think he is back next year?
Ray Fittipaldo: Mike Tomlin said Green is one of their "chief medical decisions" of the offseason. That makes me think they'll seriously consider severing ties with him if their doctors think the concussions will be an issue going forward.
JON: Ray. Why is Todd Haley coming back next year? He isn’t that good of an OC in my opinion. Can the Steelers just NOT do any better or are they actually pleased with the job that he does? O don;t see them winning the SB with TODD Haley as OC
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they are pleased with Haley. Roethlisberger was only sacked 19 times or so last season. Protecting their franchise QB was a directive from the Rooneys when they hired Haley. He's done that. The offense took a step back this season, but you have to take into account that Martavis Bryant missed the entire season and Ladarius Green missed most of it. Both were expected to be key receivers for Roethlisberger. Could Haley have done a better job with the marginal talent at WR and TE in the playoffs? Perhaps, but I'd rather judge him when he has a full complement of players.
ERIC B: Do players usually take Tags as an insult or do the realize the nature of the beast?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think most realize it's part of the business.
Chuck: Should we try to also lock up Villanueva and Shazier long term this offseason? I feel their value will only continue to climb.
Ray Fittipaldo: Villanueva is an exclusive rights free agent. They can sign him for less than $1 million for this season and do a long-term deal with him next offseason. And they'll pick up Shazier's fifth year option and do the same with him next offseason. You have other players to worry about this year such as Brown and Tuitt.
Larry: Can't see drafing a linebacker that low that won't help this year. How about Roethlisberger (who wants help) kick in and get a FA LB that can get to the QB - that helps the secondary now. Draft maybe OJ Howard to help our QB - that and M Bryant's return could make them better - thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Howard will be gone by the time the Steelers draft at No. 30. He's the best TE in this class. I think they need to go defense and address their biggest needs. They whiffed on Jarvis Jones and now they have to pay the piper and address OLB again. Doesn't have to be in the first round, but they probably have to get one in the first two or three rounds.
Steve: Tic sales & process of SB are lagging prior years....do you feel NFL fans are suffering from Patriots "fatigue" as college football may be by Alabama's annual success?
Ray Fittipaldo: Perhaps, but it's not unlike the 1970s when the Steelers made it and won it four times in a six-year span. This is more spread out over a 16-year span, but it's similar.
Guest: I have no interest in the Super Bowl this year. And it's not because the Steelers just loss. I've sort of felt that way about the Super Bowl for a few years, but the feeling has been building. It's like the season ends with the championship games, and then two weeks over there's a big event that's a party/football game with two teams I don't care about. Am I alone in this?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think you're in the minority. Would you have changed your mind if Aaron Rodgers and the Packers made it?
The NFL can't pick and choose the participants.
Scott in Dallas: If you could trade to get Myles Garrett for our next OLB would you be willing to give up AB?
Ray Fittipaldo: He's the consensus No. 1 overall pick and would be tied to the team that drafts him for four or five years. Brown has 1 year left before he can hit free agency for the first time in his career. Tell me again why a team like the Browns would do that?
Zack: Do you think we will waive Green with an injury settlement, or file a grievance with the NFLPA?
Ray Fittipaldo: Those options are on the table.
Scott in Dallas: Cleveland just traded for half a year of Jamie Collins for a 3rd round pick.
Ray Fittipaldo: And they signed him to a rich (some say overpriced) contract. They knew they had to spend to the cap this year and they had to make a commitment to at least have the appearance of trying to build a winning roster.
GjSteel: Hi Ray...have the Steelers coaches looked fully at the tape of the last games and made a definate evaluation...can the compete with the Patriots with the personal they have..or must the evolve..especially on defense?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's an ongoing evaluation that will take place for the next several weeks before the draft. But if you ask me they need pass rushers and players in the secondary capable of man coverage if they want to match up with the Patriots.
Guest: Could you see us getting a WR in rd 1 this year..letting Brown play out his currant contract, tag him, then let him walk?
Ray Fittipaldo: Never say never, but I don't think in the first round. Top four rounds? Yes.
BigBenYTown: How many years do you think Big Ben has at his current playing level,(if he doesn't retire)
Ray Fittipaldo: Didn't have his best year, but I blame Bryant and Green's injury for much of that. Look at Brady and how well he's playing as he nears 40. No reason Roethlisberger can't do the same.
Scott in Dallas: Jared Allen to the Vikings on a 1 year franchise tag for a 1st and 2 3rd's. Superstar players are worth the shot over unproven rookies. The team trading for the player would have to get a contract in place to be signed upon completion of the deal but that is not a big deal.
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll see. I think it's an extreme long shot with Brown.
Guest: Lots of talk before the game of rushing the edge guys up the middle, thinking back did you see it? Incapable or just stupid not to try?
Ray Fittipaldo: They tried and failed bringing pressure up the middle with Shazier and Timmons. The Patriots picked it up and picked it up rather easily.
Steelie: Do the Steelers re-sign Landry Jones?
Ray Fittipaldo: Probably.
BigBenYTown: Do you think this is Tomlin's best coaching year so far?
Ray Fittipaldo: No.
Scott in Dallas: Any bottom of the roster players you see climbing into starting roles this next season?
Ray Fittipaldo: No they're pretty much set at almost every position. I suppose Vince Williams could step in as a starter at ILB if Timmons isn't re-signed. But that's about it.
Andrew: Is Golson in the Steelers plans next season?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would hope so. They used a second-round pick on him and they need him desperately because Will Gay got really old really fast last season.
Scott in Dallas: Is Mettenberger a viable #2? Was he just on really bad teams to start his career with too much expectation or does he have the talent to eventually be the next Berger as our starting QB?
Ray Fittipaldo: I guess we'll find out this offseason. If they really do like him they won't have any reason to re-sign Jones.
BigBenYTown: This week Bryant applied for reinstatement. If/when he returns and is able to play a full season, you thoughts how this affects AB?
Ray Fittipaldo: Doesn't really affect him. The Steelers always have to plan as if they won't have Bryant because one more strike and he's out of the NFL for good.
JohnP: Will the Steelers put up another battle between Hawkins and Villanueva?
Ray Fittipaldo: Villanueva played well this season. I don't think he'll be in a position where he has to ward off a first-year player with no experience. I do think Hawkins has potential though. And remember Villanueva is 28.
From the Poconos: We have a very good team that can't seem to solve the New England Riddle. What do you think has to happen for the Steelers to get past New England in a championship game? will they be able to do it with the current group of coaches and players?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not the current group of players on defense. That was a total mismatch. You can criticize the coaches, too, but there is a reason they didn't try to play very much man vs. Brady. They didn't believe they had the personnel to pull it off.
Jay: Are there any free agent Pass rushers steelers can sign, window is closing for Ben, isn't this the time to sign one to make it to Super Bowl
Ray Fittipaldo: I think it's more likely they'll sign their own.
Ronnie the Limo Dr...: Who do you think the kick returner will be next year? Also I'm constantly scouting all college lacrosse teams for the Steeler's next wide receiver.
Ray Fittipaldo: Good. Let me know if there are any other Chris Hogans out there.
Guest: Does Ben have some problems reading defenses and this causes some pics, ie., the audible against KC. Is it your impression that he does not work as hard with film study, etc as many other QBs?
Ray Fittipaldo: He's not Tom Brady, but Todd Haley says Roethlisberger almost always gets the Steelers in the right play. He's not the biggest problem with the offense although he should take a long look at why he's played so much better at home than on the road in recent years. That might help the Steelers get a higher seed in the playoffs. It'd be nice to play more than one playoff game at home en route to the Super Bowl.
Alan: Can you see the steelers having a draft strategy that revolves around beating the patriots?
Ray Fittipaldo: As I pointed out last week in a story it's not just Brady. The 2017 schedule also includes the Packers and Aaron Rodgers, the Colts and Andrew Luck, the Lions and Matt Stafford, the Vikings and am Bradford. In all, they'll face 5 of the top 10 QB in 2016 QB rating. Those QBs will torch the secondary if things aren't addressed.
Spirit Sniper: Ray, I still can't get over the lack of adjustments to the defensive game plan vs the Patriots. Can you explain why the Steelers didn't play man coverage at times?
Ray Fittipaldo: They didn't think Will Gay could hold up in man. And I think they had their doubts about Cockrell as well. But mostly Gay.
GB3: Can we expect a significant contribution from Justin Gilbert next season? First round talent and a year in the Steeler system, at a position that needs help.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know. He was with the team for six months and he wasn't good enough to play over an ancient Will Gay in the title game.
Larry: if he is near # 30 worth moving up to get Howard
Ray Fittipaldo: As noted earlier, it gets more expensive the lower you draft.
Guest: Would you be surprised if they kept Danny Smith as the ST coach?
Ray Fittipaldo: First off, it's not all Danny Smith's fault. But sometimes head coaches use that position as a scapegoat. Not saying Tomlin will make that move, but NFL coaches change that coach more often than any other, especially when things aren't going well. And things didn't go all that well for the special teams in 2016.
Dude_From_Cali: SB hype thus far isn't great. Steelers vs Cowboys or Greenbay would be a great match up and ENERGY. Thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: We all say how nice it would be to have new blood in the Super Bowl yet when a team like the Falcons get there we complain. I'm guilty of it too. I do think the Packers would have been a much better draw, or the Cowboys. But that's why they play the game.
B From Ohio: Seems like they were really outmatched in the AFC championship. Maybe they were lucky ot get past KC. Did the Steelers' overachieve this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: No. They were the second-best team in the AFC. I think that was clear. I also think they're farther away from the Super Bowl this year than last year at this time. I just had a feeling about that team last year after they lost to the Broncos. I don't have that same feeling this year. Maybe it's because they didn't get embarrassed by the Patriots last year. That might be a part of it, but I'm not as optimistic about the Steelers this offseason compared to last.
Lambert Lunatic: Hi Ray, I can tell by your Tweets that you are as frustrated as our fan base with The repetitive failed calls. No QB sneak with a foot to go, no FB on short yardage, throwing deep on 3rd and 1, etc. they were doing that all year, which kept games closer than they should have been, then eventually caught them in the championship. Our coaches are brilliant most of the time, but where are these common sense calls?
Ray Fittipaldo: You don't want to get your starters injured. Those collisions on special teams are some of the most violent ones in the course of a game.
Dude_From_Cali: One more strike Martavis out of the league for good. Isn't it TOO EXTREME a rule?
Ray Fittipaldo: If it's just pot, yes. But a lot of these other guys have more serious problems.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for taking part in the chat this week. We'll do it again next week.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.