The Backyard Brawl returned Saturday and with a combined 42 fouls between Pitt and West Virginia, it certainly lived up to the name.

Amid that torrent of whistles, though, were some markers of growth and signs of hope for a Pitt team that can use both those things. It came in a 69-60 loss, sure, but it still stands as a moral victory. Which is both a good and a bad thing. Given how it could have gone, though, the Panthers have to feel good about themselves.

Turning point: Pitt cut what had been an 18-point halftime deficit all the way down to two after a four-point play from Marcus Carr with 5:31 remaining. Unfortunately for Pitt, that would be the last field goal it would make for the rest of the night. The Panthers missed their final six shots and scored just one point over the final 5:30, and no points in the final 3:25, to lose by the final nine-point margin.

Game ball: Ryan Luther. The senior was as strong and steady as he’s been this season, particularly on a night in which he was almost always the tallest player on the court for an undersized Pitt team. He finished the night with 13 points and 12 rebounds, leading the team in both categories. It was his fourth double-double of the season and the fifth time he has had at least 10 rebounds in a game this season.

Advertise with us

Notable stat: Three, the margin of offensive rebounds between Pitt and West Virginia, as the former finished with 11 and the latter with eight. Going into the game, Pitt was averaging just 7.6 offensive rebounds per game and was among the bottom-third of Division I teams in offensive rebounding percentage defense at 32.6 percent. West Virginia, meanwhile, was averaging 14.9 offensive boards per game and was grabbing 37.4 percent of its misses, ranking it among the top 20 teams in Division I.

The Panthers, perhaps most impressively, were able to do this on a night in which forward Kene Chukwuka sat with an illness, meaning that Pitt had just one player taller than 6-foot-6 who entered the night averaging more than eight minutes per game (the aforementioned Luther, who had four offensive rebounds). Yet it was still able to improve on one of its biggest weaknesses while quelling one of its opponent’s bigger strengths.

Pitt coach Kevin Stallings on loss to WVU

What it means: There’s a myopic way of looking at this result and a more optimistic way. We’ll start with the first, which isn’t an entirely unreasonable argument. The logic behind a more cynical view of Pitt’s close loss is that West Virginia, which was already without its second-leading scorer from last season in Esa Ahmad, saw its press neutralized by a group of officials who called the game extremely tightly, resulting in 25 team fouls. From those fouls, a number of key players, namely Jevon Carter, had to be taken off the court for stretches, and Pitt, in turn, got 22 points off free throws on a night in which it struggled offensively, shooting just 34 percent. It wasn’t so much that Pitt played well; it’s that West Virginia wasn’t close to the best version of itself, due in some part to the officiating.

There’s some merit to that argument, or at least some things that need to be taken under consideration. But there’s also little question about this: that’s the best Pitt has looked this season. A team made up almost entirely of freshmen and junior-college players in their first year of Division I basketball not only was within two points of a top-20 team with almost five minutes remaining, but it was in that position after being down 20 points in the first half. We hear so often from Kevin Stallings about how much he loves his team, about how hard they compete and how much they care. At some points this season, it has been some of the only praise we can find for this team after a game. “If nothing else, at least they’re trying,” some of us may say, whether it’s fans or media. This time, though, it wasn’t a gratuitous flash of positivity in a sea of negativity – it was something that kept them in a game against a much older and more talented team to the point where, had more shots fallen late, it could have very well won.

With a team this young, games are always their own creatures and, at least this early in the season, aren’t part of a continuous stream. But a game like this, even though it was a loss, is something we may look back on with this team and say, “That moment right there, that was when we knew there may be something to this group, that the rebuilding process may come with a somewhat savory result and Kevin Stallings may be able to win support from large factions of a fan base that seemed to be against him from the moment he arrived on campus.” It may stand as the game when Carr, Shamiel Stevenson, Kham Davis and others showed they could compete against a top team and look almost as good as they do during some of the softer portions of the Panthers’ non-conference schedule. It may, in short, be a turning point.

Advertise with us

That, or Pitt will come out and look terrible in six days against a McNeese State team coming off a 38-point loss to North Texas. We shall see.

Pitt's Ryan Luther, Marcus Carr talk WVU loss

What’s next: The McNeese State Cowboys, who are 3-5 on the season and ranked 326th of 351 teams by KenPom. Pitt has a 91 percent chance of winning, according to KenPom, with a projected final score of 76-62.

Notable quotables: “We just had to keep chipping away. We kind of got it to where we wanted it. At the under-four timeout, it was a very winnable game for us. We kind of did the job all the way up until then and couldn’t finish it out.” – Pitt guard Carr

“I kind of live for games like this. I would hope this game shows the fans we can play basketball at a high level. I hope they’ll come out to support us in the rest of our games this season, no matter who we’re playing, because tonight, I think we showed a big step and progress from our team. It also showed their support makes a difference in a game.” – Carr

“We knew the game was a little closer than what the score was. They made some tough shots, we missed some layups. We kind of settled down at halftime and realized if we did what we needed to do, we’d be right there in the last four minutes.” – Pitt forward Luther

Advertise with us

“If you would have told me we would have had 14 turnovers to start the game, I would have taken it.” – Pitt coach Stallings

“If halftime hadn’t have come, we might have died on the vine.” – Stallings

“I call it competitive character. I think their competitive character is very, very high. That’s what allows you, when you’re getting your butt kicked by 18 at halftime, to come back and have a chance to win.” – Stallings

“I don’t take any consolation in losing. I really don’t. I’m heartbroken I couldn’t have done a little bit more to help them get over the top in this game. It’s all about us continuing to get better.” – Stallings

“It’s fun for the fans and for you guys. For me, it’s work. I’d be a [expletive] liar if I told you I had any fun. I didn’t have any [expletive] fun at all.” – West Virginia coach Bob Huggins on the renewal of the Backyard Brawl

Advertise with us

“They played four guys who can handle the ball. That’s tough for the press. The officiating is tighter. I don’t mean today; I mean it’s just tighter. They want it tighter. It’s hard for an official. If I bring the ball up the floor and I run into you, did I run into you or did you run into me? You know what I’m saying? The cylinder thing. Does anyone understand that? I’ve been working like crazy to try to understand it and I keep getting different interpretations.” – Huggins on West Virginia’s struggles with its press

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.