For the first time in a long time, a Pitt basketball game felt like an event.

A team that Panthers fans love to hate was in town and so were its fans, as the West Virginia faithful did their best Saturday night to make Petersen Events Center a makeshift Morgantown. The two factions cheered and booed on top of each other, Pitt athletic director Heather Lyke made the rounds and even chatted with the evening’s most high-profile guest, Pirates owner and Wheeling, W.Va., native Bob Nutting, though no word if the two bonded over their current lots in the Pittsburgh sports realm.

Indeed, most everyone did their part to make this feel like the renewal of a rivalry that it was, from the Oakland Zoo all the way down to the decided underdog Panthers, who clawed back enough to make a 69-60 loss to the 18th-ranked Mountaineers surprisingly respectable.

But given the time gone by, the seasons passed and the changes not just for these basketball programs but for their athletic departments, did it all feel a little … strange, maybe? After all, this was the first time the Backyard Brawl enemies faced off in football or men’s basketball since 2012, when each went their separate ways to the ACC and Big 12 conferences.

Advertise with us

Pitt coach Kevin Stallings on loss to WVU

“Pretty much no one in this game had played each other before, so there wasn’t that familiarity, but I thought the atmosphere was great,” said Pitt senior Ryan Luther, a Hampton native who grew up watching this series. “Obviously, we knew they were gonna have a lot of people here just because they’re right down the road, but I think it was pretty awesome. I thought both teams played hard.”

The 7,748 who packed into all but the upper corners of the building were perhaps half-comprised of those trying to make it feel like the WVU Coliseum, alternating chants of “Let’s Go Mountaineers” with a vulgar instruction for the University of Pittsburgh and its constituents.

Pitt coach Kevin Stallings praised his student section unprompted and called it “really great to have the atmosphere in here that we had,” adding later that it “uplifted” his inexperienced team.

“I had heard for years how great the home-court advantage was here, and it certainly exists on certain nights,” Stallings said. “Tonight was one of those nights.”

Football coach Pat Narduzzi and nearly his entire staff paraded about with recruits visiting campus before and after halftime, while the gridiron Panthers had their all-conference selections honored at midcourt in the first half. When point guard Marcus Carr hit a 3-pointer and a whistle blew to indicate a four-point play that could cut a once-wide West Virginia lead to just two points late in the game, a Pitt crowd that has been sparse for the early part of this rebuilding season hit a fever pitch.

Advertise with us

West Virginia's Bob Huggins 'didn't have any damn fun' against Pitt

“I thought it was refreshing to have that support behind us,” Luther said.

He was echoed in that by Carr, a freshman who never experienced what Pitt home games were once like, but took the opportunity to give his plea to those who doubt the good old days will ever return. And really, his message might just suggest that he and his teammates care more about the dour feel around the program than they or their coach would ever publicly admit.

“I would hope this game showed the fans that we can play basketball at a high level,” Carr said. “I hope that they would come out to support us the rest of the season no matter who we’re playing, because tonight we showed a big step in progress for the team. I think it also showed that their support makes a difference in the game.”

About the only person who came away unimpressed was an old standby in this matchup, one who not only recalls the Pitt-West Virginia clashes of old, but also coached in them. In fact, if all was right with the world in terms of a frenzied fray between the Panthers and Mountaineers, plus an excitable crowd to see it, even a surly Bob Huggins was on hand afterward to round out the feel from a bygone era.

“It’s fun for the fans and for you guys,” he told reporters. “For me, it’s work. I’d be a damn liar if I sat here and told you I had fun. I didn’t have any damn fun at all.”

Advertise with us

He also wasn’t much for comparing Saturday’s environment to the ones that surrounded his many memorable Big East meetings with Jamie Dixon-led Pitt teams, the ones that had much higher stakes than a non-conference game in early December.

“We used to walk in here an hour and a half before the game and the students were jumping up and down,” Huggins deadpanned. “The place was full. … That’s the truth. This was one of the harder places in the Big East to play, if not the hardest.”

Huggins isn’t wrong, but at least for one night, “The Pete” was loud again. There will be at least three more of these, next year going to Morgantown, and then the football teams will rekindle things for four years starting in 2022 at Heinz Field.

Pitt's Ryan Luther, Marcus Carr talk WVU loss

In the waning moments Saturday, with the Mountaineers having successfully dodged an upset bid and going home with what they came for, a small group of Pitt students began chanting “13-9!” as one last parting shot.

It quickly fizzled, but like the rest of the evening’s proceedings, at least it was there at all.

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.