Pitt’s game Saturday night against West Virginia, the renewal of the storied Backyard Brawl, was, on paper, a Murphy’s Law of a matchup for the Panthers.

A young team with seven freshmen and nine first-year Division I players, one that has struggled with turnovers and preventing offensive rebounds for much of the season, would have to match wits with a ranked opponent that excels in both areas, so much so that its prowess for creating miscues the past several seasons has earned it the nickname “Press Virginia.”

From that pressure came not diamonds, but something far more precious than the Panthers had shown at any point over the course of the 2017-18 season — even if it came in a loss.

Ryan Luther had a team-high 13 points and 12 rebounds, and helped Pitt overcame a sizable early hole to get within two of the No. 18 Mountaineers in the final six minutes before ultimately falling, 69-60, Saturday at the Petersen Events Center in the first matchup between the two schools in nearly six years.

Advertise with us

Pitt coach Kevin Stallings on loss to WVU

“I couldn’t be any more proud of my team and their effort and how hard they fought,” Pitt coach Kevin Stallings said. “We got our butts kicked in the first half. Guys of lesser character would have put their heads between their legs and thought the night was over. But there was none of that in them, not at halftime, not at any point. I couldn’t have asked for any more out of them than they gave.”

What could have been a disaster of a game, a blowout of truly grotesque proportions, was anything but. A Pitt team that lost by 31 to Penn State 19 days earlier in a game it very easily could have easily lost by 40 or even 50 showed clear and measurable signs of progress in a game that stands as the most convincing piece of evidence yet that something may come of this group of young players.

The full-court pressure many thought may engulf a green Pitt team never fully came to fruition, as the Panthers (5-5) finished with 14 turnovers, slightly below their season average, off of which the Mountaineers (9-1) only got 15 points. Their press, if anything, backfired at times, as the physicality of it led to 25 fouls, which helped Pitt get 22 points on free throws. Additionally, Pitt largely kept its opponent off the offensive boards, as it had only eight (to Pitt’s 11).

Whether it was his struggling press or the lack of tenacity on the glass, West Virginia coach Bob Huggins noticed a central theme — a lack of energy in a game that demanded it.

“It’s hard to rebound when you don’t try,” Huggins said. “I haven’t seen very many people get one who didn’t want one. It’s amazing when you try to go get one. You usually get it. I’ve told a couple of our guys ‘If you ever get one, you might like it and you might try again.’”

Advertise with us

West Virginia's Bob Huggins 'didn't have any damn fun' against Pitt

The cumulative effect of West Virginia’s press, of which Stallings spoke earlier in the week, was evident early, though. In the first half, Pitt missed eight of its 10 dunk or layup attempts, the kind it made so easily for much of the season. They weren’t simple miscues; they were the product of playing at a faster, less-comfortable pace against a superior foe about whom it always had to worry, anxieties and pressures that built over a 40-minute game and showed themselves in what are normally routine plays.

Those scattered mistakes helped the Mountaineers build an early lead, one that rose to 10 within the game’s first seven minutes and swelled to 18 by halftime.

Something over time, however, changed. A Pitt team that looked flustered and thoroughly outmatched in the first half looked not only as though it could play with a faster, bigger and more talented opponent, but be even better than it in the final 20 minutes. What had been an uncomfortable, fish-out-of-water look early in the game quickly evolved into an unquestionable sense of aggression and confidence.

The Mountaineers led for all but 20 seconds of 40 minutes, a period in which the teams were tied at zero, but they saw their advantage trimmed to single digits, 56-47, with 10:37 remaining. As they struggled to score, Pitt took ample advantage, getting within two, 61-59, after a four-point play from freshman guard Marcus Carr with 5:31 remaining.

In those moments, and as Pitt’s spirited run unfolded, the Petersen Events Center felt as it so often hadn’t the pasts several years — alive and fully immersed in a game that mattered.

Advertise with us

“Somebody said ‘What’d you say at halftime?’ I didn’t say jack at halftime that I don’t normally say,” Stallings said. “It’s them. They believed we were going to get back in it and have a chance to win. They believed that and you could see they believed that. It wasn’t fake, it wasn’t bravado. They thought we would have a chance to win the game.”

As the game wore on, though, the skill, physicality, experience and overall talent of the Mountaineers showed out at the most crucial junctures. They closed the game on an 8-1 run, as Pitt failed to score a point in the contest’s final 3:26, sealing the game and giving their thousands of fans in attendance the opportunity to shower the building with chants of “Eat [Expletive] Pitt” and the chorus of John Denver’s “Country Roads” in the game’s closing seconds.

Pitt's Ryan Luther, Marcus Carr talk WVU loss

Those late shooting struggles were emblematic of a night in which Pitt struggled to score effectively. It shot just 34 percent from the field and 24 percent from 3-point range, putting it well behind the Mountaineers’ marks of 45.8 percent and 40 percent, respectively, a stark difference that makes the relatively close game even harder to believe.

While moral victories only carry so much weight, the Panthers believe Saturday was something of a revelation, not for themselves, but all those who track their progress. They may be young, but they believe they can be something more than what many expect them to be.

“We knew we could be this team from the time we first started practicing and assembled with each other,” Carr said. “It was just a matter of time and putting it all together into the finished product you saw today. And, honestly, we still didn’t even play our best. I think this is the hardest we’ve played in a game, but we didn’t play our best at all. It’s just another step in the right direction. We’re still building and still confident.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.