Mike Sullivan gave Olli Maatta a sweater and made Jack Johnson a healthy scratch for the first game of the Penguins’ playoff series with the Islanders on Wednesday. The Penguins lost 4-3 in overtime and that put the spotlight on his key personnel decision on the blue line.

Sullivan was asked about it and said that it was a difficult decision but that it came down to Maatta’s ability to move the puck. Johnson isn’t great in that capacity, and against the Islanders forecheck, there is no guarantee Johnson wouldn’t have made a few of the gaffes that Maatta did.

The decision to play Maatta over Johnson, however, raised some eyebrows when it was announced. Johnson was a major free-agent acquisition this past offseason and played in all 82 of the Penguins’ regular-season games. Maatta missed a lot of the season with an injury and has some limitations, so it seemed pretty clear that he would be the odd man out.

But it was Johnson who sat out, and Sullivan made it clear that the decision was made for the first game but Johnson will get his opportunities to play in this series and beyond.

Advertise with us

“I told [Johnson] he's going to be a big part of it moving forward,” Sullivan said. “He's such a great teammate. He took it really well. But he’s going to be ready for us and I know he’s going to help us win.”

The fires of controversy were then further fueled when Maatta played an awful game and was directly responsible for at least two of the Islanders’ goals. Maatta looked slow at times and made key mistakes at the worst times.

Maatta lost Jordan Eberle in the first period, giving him a prime scoring opportunity that he buried for a 1-0 Islanders lead. Then in the third period with the game tied 2-2, Maatta had the puck stolen by Leo Komarov who passed it to Nick Leddy, who blasted a shot past Matt Murray.

It wasn’t Maatta’s night and he certainly didn’t play well by any measure. There is no way to rationalize what he did or how he played. And if you want to say that Johnson should have been in the lineup, I might not actually argue with that.

Maatta’s play, though, and the decision to play Maatta is not why the Penguins lost. He contributed but he had a lot of help. The Penguins spent far too much of the game playing like that careless, sloppy team that we’ve seen far too often this year.

Advertise with us

The Penguins simply made far too many mistakes to win a playoff game. They turned the puck over in their zone, gave up too many odd-man breaks and failed to capitalize on prime scoring opportunities at the other end.

Brian Dumoulin said after the game that the Penguins need to “come out of our zone cleaner” and Sullivan said that the Penguins’ defensive lapses were not all on the defensemen. He said it was a “five-man effort” and that the Penguins’ forwards need to do a better job of “supporting them when they are under pressure.”

The Islanders’ game-winner was an example of the Penguins sloppy play coming back to haunt them. It wasn’t Maatta that made the key mistake, though, it was Kris Letang, who is the Penguins’ best defensemen. Letang, who also had a team-high four giveaways, essentially tried to go 1-on-3 and lost the puck.

That led to a break that ended the game when Josh Bailey — who, thanks to another Penguins mistake, had the opportunity to win the game with about four seconds left in regulation but hit the post — buried a rebound.

Letang tried to play hero and instead became the goat.

Advertise with us

Murray didn’t have a bad night in goal but “not bad” is not good enough. The Penguins need Murray to play at an elite level if they are going to win any playoff series, much less win the Stanley Cup.

All of it adds up to a bad night at the office for the Penguins. There were a few bright spots — Phil Kessel and Evgeni Malkin come to mind — but not nearly enough. The Islanders’ forecheck pressure proved to be too much for the Penguins to handle, and that was the story of the game.

But go ahead and blame Maatta for the loss if you are looking for a scapegoat. Blame Sullivan for making the decision to play Maatta instead of Johnson, if it makes you feel better. There is no defending the way Maatta played, but understand he wasn’t the reason the Penguins lost this game.

The Penguins deserved to lose this game because they didn’t play well enough to beat a good team, especially in the playoffs. That — not a personnel decision — is why they lost, and they will need to play much better Friday regardless of who is in the lineup, or they will lose again.