UNIONDALE, N.Y. — Don’t want to suggest that Islanders fans were the least bit overeager for this playoff series to start, but not only were the first tailgaters rolling out of the RV’s eight-and-a-half hours before puck drop, they were a solid half hour early for the puck drop of the morning skate.
That’s right, the NHL playoffs began on Long Island, which is an arrangement of subject, verb, and predicate that haven’t lined up sequentially since the night Michael Dukakis beat Jesse Jackson in the Wisconsin primary — April 6, 1988 you’ll remember.
By the other side of 10 p.m., the 13,917 who’d made it inside sounded like 93,171 when Nick Leddy’s shot from the high slot brushed some Penguin feathers and darted into the Pittsburgh net to give the Islanders a 3-2 lead that lasted all the way to the final 89 seconds.
But just as they’d tied it 1-1, and tied it 2-2, the Penguins tied it 3-3 when Justin Schultz whistled one to the net from the far arc of the left circle. Not only was that more ties than any Penguin probably packed for this trip, it was a precise prescription for overtime in Game 1.
The Islanders, as it happens, have the best overtime record in the history of the NHL playoffs, winning 33 of 49. This probably wasn’t among Penguins coach Mike Sullivan’s observations as the Penguins convened prior to a fourth period.
But make it 34 of 50.
Read More
Four minutes and 39 seconds into overtime, New York’s Josh Bailey steered the puck past Matt Murray to win it 4-3 and put the home team up 1-0 in the series.
It appeared Mathew Barzal interfered with Murray on the winning play, but no interference was called, probably because Barzal looked to have been knocked into the Penguins goaltender by Kris Letang, the decorated defenseman desperately trying to atone for a needless gamble up ice.
Asked if it looked or felt like interference to him, Murray was as quick as he’d been all night.
“Yeah!”
Mike Sullivan talks about the Penguins' OT loss to Islanders
Fittingly, Game 1 was a very long game that foretold a very long series, a difficult slog for the solidly favored Penguins against the winningest Islanders team in 35 years.
“We knew they’d come hard because they’re a very good team,” said defenseman Olli Maatta, something of a surprise starter in lieu of Jack Johnson, who’d played all 82 regular season games. “It’s going to be a long series so we just have to get ready for Game 2.”
There is plenty of sports and cultural history inside the battered-but-face-lifted Nassau Coliseum, including four Stanley Cup championship banners from the early ’80s, but what there isn’t plenty of is space. The Penguins locker room for the road portion of this first-round collision makes the typical LaGuardia Airport lavatory seem almost cavernous.
More pointedly, if Murray thought it was cumbersome getting dressed amid of playoff horde of media at midday Wednesday, he found it even more suffocating on the ice surface down the hall.
Two minutes into Game 1, Murray had already fetched two pucks from his own net, and only a laboriously replayed offside question on the first one saved him from being down 2-0. Phil Kessel collected a loose puck in the slot and beat New York’s Robin Lehner to tie the score four minutes later, but Islanders center Brock Nelson whacked a power play goal past Murray at 15:46 to both reclaim the lead and send the Coliseum crowd instantaneously to the derisive Murrrrr-ay Murrrr-ay chant.
Not the postseason start Sullivan had imagined probably.
“Experience helps, and we understand we have a lot of (playoff) experience to draw on, but it’s not the only thing,” Sullivan had cautioned earlier in the day. “We’ve been a forward thinking group. We’re not trying to dwell on the past. We’re trying to earn our way in the present.”
Which was precisely what the Islanders had in mind — making them earn it.
Sidney Crosby spent the first hours of the Eastern Conference quarterfinal like a frustrated commuter on the Long Island Expressway, boxed in by high-traffic back checkers, accelerating only in fits and starts.
It was only when defenseman Ryan Pulock pulled The Captain down near the goal line that the Penguins were invited back into Game 1, an invitation Evgeni Malkin heartily accepted on their behalf by sending a slapper from the left point past Lehner to make it 2-2.
The even more positive indicator for Pittsburgh as the 2-2 tie held until the second intermission was that Murray appeared to have stabilized himself. His stop on Adam Pelech late in the middle period was No. 30 at his finest. Multiple stops on Islanders sharpshooter Barzal appeared to confirm his reassurance.
You should look for a demonstrative Penguins bounce-back for Game 2. Or at least you may hope as much.
“They’re dangerous all the time,” said Islanders coach Barry Trotz, who beat the Penguins from behind the Washington Capitals bench last spring. “It doesn’t look like anything’s happening, and then they’ll bust someone free. You just gotta stay with it and understand that they can strike quickly. They’ve got some world class players.”
Yes, so I hear.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.