Matt Murray talks about the Penguins' loss to Islanders in Game 1
Here’s a dose of reality that might be needed right about now: When the Penguins won the Stanley Cup in back-to-back seasons in 2015-16 and 2016-17, they did so while failing to sweep a single series. Same deal for the Capitals last season. They don’t happen very often.
Far more frequently, the winner in a playoff series is decided by who makes the better and more frequent game-to-game adjustments, something at which they’ve often excelled.
While the Penguins have enough of those to stay busy after Wednesday’s 4-3 overtime loss to the Islanders at Nassau Coliseum, a Game 1 defeat that puts them in an early hole in their Eastern Conference quarterfinal series, neither they nor you should be freaking out.
It’s correctable stuff.
“We have to come out of our zone cleaner,” Brian Dumoulin said. “They established their forecheck and created a lot of turnovers. That’s something we have to get better at for Game 2. We’ll get more chances and spend more time in their zone.”
Dumoulin pretty much hit the nail on the head there, although it’s a little more nuanced than that. The Islanders were aggressive on the forecheck and had the Penguins under pressure in their own end.
Read More
It wouldn’t be entirely accurate to say the Penguins were hemmed in their own zone all night because they accounted for nearly 59 percent of the five-on-five shot attempts and peppered goaltender Robin Lehner with 44 shots on goal.
But this wasn’t a spectacular defensive effort from the Penguins, either.
“It could be better,” said Olli Maatta, whose turnover led to the Islanders’ third goal, a Nick Leddy shot from distance.
The same could be said for the entire group, in fact.
On the Islanders’ first goal, scored by right wing Jordan Eberle just 1:40 into the game, Dumoulin made a pass that lacked any shred of purpose, the aimless attempt going to defenseman Adam Pelech at the left point. Shot, rebound, Eberle stuffed it in.
Marcus Pettersson took a tripping penalty that preceded center Brock Nelson’s power-play goal later in the first period, a play on which Dumoulin failed to help out in front.
Kris Letang was charged with a team-high four giveaways, including one on left wing Josh Bailey’s overtime winner when he got a little too aggressive in the offensive zone.
“When you’re late in shifts, especially when it’s a long change from your bench, you have to make good decisions with the puck,” coach Mike Sullivan said.
“If we had numbers and an opportunity for a potential scoring chance, I think that’s a calculated risk. I’m not sure we had the awareness that we needed in that situation.”
Erik Gudbranson actually played reasonably well, but his availability for Game 2 should be something to watch.
Gudbranson was helped to the dressing room after being boarded by Islanders captain Anders Lee and was spotted after the game meeting with Penguins team physician Dr. Dharmesh Vyas.
If Gudbranson can’t go, that would likely mean Jack Johnson — a healthy scratch after playing all 82 regular-season games — would be back in the lineup, but the Penguins would have to shoehorn a lefty onto his off-side, which isn’t ideal coming off a game like this.
The good news for the Penguins is that they’ve been here before. Actually quite a bit if you trace back to certain parts of their playoff history. During the Sidney Crosby/Evgeni Malkin Era, the Penguins have now lost seven of their past nine Game 1s on the road.
It will be imperative for the Penguins to not stew too long over what transpired here Wednesday and instead channel their efforts toward fixing things at Thursday’s practice.
“You have to learn from it,” Sidney Crosby said. “Regardless of the outcome, you have to learn from every game and get better with every game. We’ll learn from this one and make sure we’re better in Game 2.”
So, what can the Penguins learn?
The takeaways from Game 1 included a terrific night for Phil Kessel, who scored in the first period and may be rounding into his typical playoff form. Kessel finished with a game-high 10 shot attempts, five that went on goal.
They also showed a ton of resilience, three times battling back from one-goal deficits. The first one could’ve been a lot worse, too, as Eberle turned this place — the NHL’s smallest arena — into an absolute nuthouse.
It should also be noted and appreciated the considerable jump with which Evgeni Malkin skated. Sort of like Kessel, if this is the Malkin that’s going to show up in Game 2, chances are the Penguins — if the defensemen can play a little better — should improve.
“If we don’t take care of the puck, they’re going to be in the right position and create chances off of that,” Nick Bjugstad said. “It was close game, and we had some chances. It was back and forth. But overall, it has to be a little bit tighter for us. Just take care of the puck a little better.”
Added Maatta, “We have to come out with the same effort. We want to be the ones playing with the puck. That’s a big key.”
Olli Maatta talks about loss to Islanders in Game 1
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.