UNIONDALE, N.Y. — The Penguins welcomed back Brian Dumoulin, Kris Letang’s steady partner on their top defensive pair, for Game 1 of the Eastern Conference quarterfinals against the New York Islanders Wednesday.
Though his status remained uncertain through pregame warmups, Dumoulin’s suiting up was not a shock. But there was one when the Penguins revealed whose lineup spot he was taking.
The odd man out in the 4-3 overtime loss was Jack Johnson, one of three players to skate in every Penguins game during the regular season and a defenseman the organization previously had gone out of its way to defend.
The 32-year-old joined the Penguins in the offseason, signing a five-year, $16.25 million deal. After a rocky start to his first season in Pittsburgh, in part because the left-hander at times was asked to play on the right, Johnson turned his season around. From Dec. 1 on, he had a plus-8 rating.
In late February, general manager Jim Rutherford crowed, “From the media to the fans, nobody has given him a chance from the first day he got here. And Jack Johnson’s doing fine.”
The Penguins, with Dumoulin on the verge of coming back, presumably picked between Johnson and a two-time Stanley Cup winner in Olli Maatta for the final blue-line spot.
Read More
They got one last look at each player next to Justin Schultz in practice this week. Monday, Maatta practiced with Schultz. A day later, Johnson was back with his late-season partner.
In the end, coach Mike Sullivan chose to sit Johnson, whose steady presence helped the Penguins make the playoffs despite injuries to Dumoulin, Letang and Schultz at different points down the stretch.
“It’s a very difficult decision,” he said. “We’ve talked about it for a week. Jack’s played a lot of great hockey for us. I told him he’s going to be a big part here moving forward. He’s such a great teammate. He took it really well. But he’s going to be ready for us, and I know he’s going to help us win.”
Dumoulin, who missed the final three games of the regular season with a lower-body injury, returned to practice Monday and skated in Cranberry again Tuesday. He said Monday he was hoping to play Game 1 but wasn’t going to “rush it” and risk having a setback.
He got off to a shaky start Wednesday. He was on the ice and out of position but he had a good vantage point for the first two Islanders goals. Dumoulin, who led the Penguins with a plus-31 rating during the regular season, was also on the ice for Josh Bailey’s overtime winner.
Maatta also struggled, particularly when speedy Islanders forecheckers put pressure on the Penguins as they tried to corral the puck and get out of their zone. He was far from alone in that regard, though. Tom Kuhnhackl also danced around him in overtime before nearly scoring.
“It could be better, for sure,” Maatta said of his individual performance.
Aston-Reese ready
Zach Aston-Reese, who missed the final 13 games of the regular season with a lower-body injury, also returned to the lineup. He took rookie Teddy Blueger’s spot on the fourth line.
This series will be a bit of a homecoming for Aston-Reese, who grew up in Staten Island.
“It's nice to be close to home. It's always nice to have family around,” he said, “It would just be a little more personal for me. Growing up, I wasn't an Islanders fan. But I skated in their facilities and have been around them just growing up and playing in those rinks. So it is pretty special to me.”
Patric Hornqvist looks ahead to Game 1 vs. the Islanders
Malkin, Kessel split
It turns out Sullivan wasn’t trying to mislead with the forward lines he showed Monday and Tuesday.
Jared McCann and Patric Hornqvist started as Evgeni Malkin’s wingers on the second line. Phil Kessel, often Malkin’s wingman, played on the third with Dominik Simon and Nick Bjugstad.
With McCann on the second line, Bryan Rust was on the first with Sidney Crosby and Jake Guentzel.
Lehner gets start
In the past few days, Islanders coach Barry Trotz would not reveal whether Robin Lehner or Thomas Greiss would start in goal for Game 1. Lehner ended up getting the first crack.
“The key to getting to him is shooting from everywhere and creating a lot of traffic at the net,” Aston-Reese said before the game. “I know that sounds so cliché, but I think if you look at his numbers, that’s one of the biggest areas where he gives up goals. So getting to the net will be important.”
Aston-Reese was curious to see if the Islanders will continue to rotate their goalies like they did in the regular season, when Lehner started 43 games and Greiss 39. Both ranked in the top five in save percentage.
“I’ve definitely heard people talking about [whether it could work] on NHL Network or NHL Radio [on SiriusXM],” Aston-Reese said. “It would be interesting to see. I’m not too sure, but I could see them doing it. They’ve been doing it all year, and it’s gone well to this point.”
Considering that Lehner stopped 41 of 44 shots in Game 1, it might be hard for Trotz to hand over the crease to Greiss.
Leaning on Lee
Veteran winger Anders Lee led the Islanders with 28 goals during the regular season, often causing problems for opponents by parking his 6-foot-3, 231-pound frame in front of their goalie.
“He’s good at it. He’s a heavy body in front of the net. He’s made a career out of sitting right there, getting in that tripod [stance] and being difficult to move,” Erik Gudbranson said. “You want to get to him before he gets [to the net front] … and make it difficult for him to get there.”
Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel. Click here to subscribe to our weekly Penguins newsletter, From The Point.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.