The sound of silence spoke volumes for Matt Sullivan.

On Nov. 19, after the Penguins squandered a three-goal lead to lose for the ninth time in 10 games, Matt remembers riding home from PPG Paints Arena with his father, Mike, the team’s head coach.

Normally during these late-night drives, the game is discussed and dissected, win or lose. Not this time.

“He didn’t say a word,” Matt Sullivan said. “That was definitely a tough time for him. I knew he was so frustrated, and I didn’t know what to say.

Advertise with us

“It’s the only time we’ve never talked about the game on the ride home.”

This year has been a tremendous challenge for Mike Sullivan, from having to defend his relationship with Phil Kessel over the summer (then again in-season) to losing his father in September, then losing a bunch of games during a brutal start.

But as difficult as it may have seemed at the time, it also offered a few lessons learned for the 51-year-old, two-time Stanley Cup-winning coach — about the difficulties of the job and relating to players and the importance of balance and support when things go awry.

If it’s taught Sullivan’s players and Penguins fans anything, it’s that they’re lucky to have this guy behind the bench, someone who’s incredibly smart but also patient and persistent, willing to put in the work and understanding of what it takes to navigate a long NHL season.

“It’s been a challenging year,” Sullivan told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Monday during a post-practice interview inside his office at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex. “We’ve gone through a lot of adversity as a team. Injuries are one thing, but put those aside; the inconsistency of play has been a challenge in and of itself. It’s hard because we have such high expectations, as we should. I think we’ve got a good team. I think we have a competitive group, but nothing’s inevitable.

Advertise with us

“I know some of our players probably roll their eyes at why this coaching staff harps so much on practice habits, but it’s because we believe strongly in them. We believe in the process and the daily endeavor associated with being at your best. We’re trying to push these guys every day to raise the bar.”

The Penguins begin the Stanley Cup playoffs Wednesday against the Islanders at Nassau Coliseum. They closed the regular season with the fifth-most points in the NHL behind the Presidents’ Trophy-winning Lightning.

Optimism abounds. But it’s easy to forget that it certainly didn’t start out that way.

‘Lucky to have him’

Sullivan’s frustrating year actually began at the NHL draft in Dallas.

Advertise with us

About six weeks after a loss to the Capitals in the Eastern Conference semifinals, Sullivan found himself at American Airlines Center, passionately defending his relationship with one of the team’s stars in Kessel.

“A lot of what’s been written, from my standpoint, has been false,” Sullivan said back then. “I know where my relationship is with Phil, and I certainly have a comfort level with it. I think Phil does, too.”

Kessel endured a prolonged goal-scoring slump this season, at one point going 16 games without one and eventually 29 between goals at even-strength. Sullivan and Kessel, the coach would admit, have certainly butted heads on a few occasions.

But hardly enough to qualify the relationship as strained.

“I’m not going to sit here and say I haven’t had my share of challenging conversations with Phil,” Sullivan said. “We’ve had a handful over the time that we’ve been together. But by no means have I ever walked away saying, ‘I don’t like this guy.’ ”

Advertise with us

“I have so much respect for Phil, what he’s contributed to this team and the success that we’ve been able to enjoy together. But that doesn’t mean I’m going to stop coaching.”

Let’s pause for a minute and think about all Sullivan has had to endure this season, the difficult situations through which he’s had to guide the Penguins.

In addition to Kessel, he has navigated extended scoring slumps from Evgeni Malkin and Patric Hornqvist; the Derick Brassard Experiment, which was a complete flop; holding his ground on Daniel Sprong, when much of the fanbase thought Sullivan was crazy for not playing the offensive-minded youngster more; Matt Murray failing to find his game until Dec. 15; and significant injuries to defensemen Kris Letang, Brian Dumoulin, Olli Maatta and Justin Schultz. Oh, and a bunch of games a team with this much talent should never lose.

But through it all, Sullivan has somehow kept his cool. Whenever many expected the coach to snap — like after that loss to the Sabres — he has not. A former baseball player, too, Sullivan has only dug his cleats further into the dirt.

“He’s been so good,” Jake Guentzel said. “When it wasn’t going as well, he took time to work with us. He stuck with us. That’s all you can ask for from your coach. A lot of games, we won because of his coaching. We’re pretty lucky to have him.”

Advertise with us

‘A constant evolution’

The Kessel dynamic illustrates why the Penguins are lucky to have Sullivan.

He not only allows players to speak their minds, but he encourages it, even if sometimes tempers might flare. The feeling is that usually the team and the player are better for it.

“What I love about these players is that we have some personality,” Sullivan said. “I like to call it ‘a man’s argument.’ We’ve got guys on the bench who go at each other. ‘Hey, I want the puck in a certain situation. Why didn’t you give it to me? You didn’t see me. I was open backdoor.’

“Players go at it amongst themselves. I think that’s productive, as long as it doesn’t get to the point where it gets to the wrong side. As a coaching staff, we encourage that. There isn’t a game that goes by that we don’t have a man’s argument or two on the bench.”

Advertise with us

Also a day doesn’t go by where Sullivan doesn’t have a tough conversation or two with a player, privately in his office. Maybe someone is getting sent down. Or perhaps one will be a healthy scratch. This season, more might’ve been needed from one of the Penguins’ key cogs.

Nothing is sugarcoated. Because … well, why?

Mike Sullivan during morning practice Tuesday, April 9, 2019. (Peter Diana/Post-Gazette)

“Sometimes you have to tell players things they don’t want to hear,” Sullivan said. “It’s not unlike being a parent. It’s not because you’re trying to be a jerk. It’s just the opposite. You’re trying to help a player grow or help a situation or whatever it may be. I just think that’s part of my job as the coach.

“For me to avoid those potential conversations that might be confrontational, I think it would be an abdication of my responsibility.”

As much as any of his peers, Sullivan realizes what’s asked of him — and it’s not always Xs and Os. With this team, he’s a part-time psychologist, too.

Advertise with us

Earlier this season, Sullivan tried everything: poking, prodding, pumping tires and even personnel changes. Nothing worked.

“The one thing I’ve learned is that this league can be humbling because it’s so competitive,” Sullivan said. “There are certain things that you can control. There’s a lot that you can’t.

“I’m trying to get better as a person so I can help this team continue to grow and develop. Our players are trying to do the same thing. That’s just a constant evolution, I think.”

Coming full circle

Tough conversations weren’t the only thing Sullivan encountered this season. Before it started, as he stepped off the ice following a training camp practice, he received the worst possible news — his dad had passed away.

Advertise with us

Mike and George Sullivan were extremely close. For the past couple of postseasons, George would move north from his Florida home and stay with Mike and and his wife, Kate. Between games, Mike and George Sullivan would sit out back and drink Guinness, smoke cigars and play cribbage.

“I cherish those times,” Mike said. “It was a great opportunity for me and him to share the playoff experience. For him to have the opportunity to see us win twice was a dream come true for both of us.”

An interesting thing happened for Mike Sullivan when Matt moved in with his parents in September 2017, after graduating from Bowdoin College in Maine and taking a job with Ernst & Young in Pittsburgh.

Instead of cribbage out back, Mike and Matt started playing pool and darts downstairs, usually with some sort of game on in the background. It offered Mike a chance to reconnect with his son after having to sacrifice so much due to a career in pro hockey.

“I haven’t been able to participate in his life the way I would have hoped or would’ve wanted,” Mike said. “To have the opportunity to reconnect with him, for me, has been awesome. It’s been a thrill.”

Advertise with us

Their game of choice is 8-ball. Mike claims Matt’s better — “He practices,” Mike said. “I don’t.” — while Matt said he had to work to start beating his dad.

“He definitely had the upper-hand on me for a little bit when we first got the pool table,” Matt said. “I had to make up some ground and get him back. I was definitely practicing when he would be at the rink.”

Earlier this season, during the tough times, Matt said he could absolutely sense some frustration in his dad, who tried everything possible to get this thing turned around.

“It was tough to see because he wears his emotions on his sleeve,” Matt said. “He would come home from the rink pretty bummed out.”

But even after that silent ride home, Mike Sullivan never lost faith in his team.

Advertise with us

That night and the next day at practice, in public, Sullivan preached the importance of positivity and staying together as a group. He was downright defiant when it was suggested the Penguins might’ve lost a step or two.

As many questioned whether the Penguins were still a playoff team, their inherently stubborn Irishman of a coach refused to believe otherwise.

“That’s something he’s really good at — having a read on what’s going on in the room and what the guys need,” Matt Cullen said. “He’s done a great job with this group.”

‘When the heat’s on’

None of that has been easy for Sullivan, who often finds it tough to unplug during the season or think about anything other than helping the Penguins improve.

Advertise with us

When Sullivan gets home from work, one of the first things he’ll do is take the family’s two black labs, Hank and Stanley, for a long walk with Kate. The two will chat. Mike might even have a cigar.

“Rain or shine, we always try to get the dogs out,” Mike Sullivan said. “I love that.”

Exercise is also essential. Around the team, it’s common to see Sullivan pedaling away on an exercise bike, Air Pods in his ears, or banging out sets of dumbbell press on a Swiss ball.

The music is what you might expect from someone Sullivan’s age — Elton John, Billy Joel and Bob Seger are a few favorites — but there’s also a familial tie here.

Sullivan’s kids — Matt and daughters Kylie and Kaitlin — recently got him into Spotify, specifically a playlist for ‘70s rock. He’s also grown to like newer country, expanding his own likes (Garth Brooks and George Strait) to those of his kids (Zac Brown Band and Brad Paisley).

Advertise with us

One of Sullivan’s favorite things occurs in the summer, when Matt will play guitar on the deck by the pool, and his daughters will sing. Mike might even play the piano. It’s not as relaxing in-season, but family remains a key to minimizing stress.

“My family keeps me grounded,” Sullivan said. “They’re my biggest escape as far as keeping some normalcy in my life when the heat’s on.”

After a long and tumultuous regular season, the heat is again on the Penguins coach, the playoffs only a day away. A first-round exit could undo all the good that occurred during the second half of the regular season.

There will inevitably be more tough times, but Sullivan has also proven himself adept at guiding this team through whatever sort of difficulty it encounters.

“Being a Penguins fan myself, the amount of emotions you go through … during those tough times, it was easy to lose your cool,” Matt Sullivan said. “I knew my dad was struggling inside, but I remember he always believed they would pull out of it. Watching his composure through all of that was really impressive.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.